Robert C Smallridge1, Ana-Maria Chindris, Yan W Asmann, John D Casler, Daniel J Serie, Honey V Reddi, Kendall W Cradic, Michael Rivera, Stefan K Grebe, Brian M Necela, Norman L Eberhardt, Jennifer M Carr, Bryan McIver, John A Copland, E Aubrey Thompson. 1. Department of Medicine (R.C.S.), Division of Endocrinology and Metabolism, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, Florida 32224; Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (A.M.C., J.D.C.), Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, Florida 32224; Department of Health Sciences Research (Y.W.A., D.J.S.), Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, Florida 32224; Department of Medicine, Division of Endocrinology (H.V.R., N.L.E., B.M.), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905; Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology (K.W.C., S.K.G.), Division of Clinical Biochemistry and Immunology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905; Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology (M.R.), Division of Anatomic Pathology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905; Department of Cancer Biology (B.N., J.M.C., J.A.C., E.A.T.), Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, Florida 32224; and Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (N.L.E.), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905.
Abstract
CONTEXT: The BRAF V600E mutation (BRAF-MUT) confers an aggressive phenotype in papillary thyroid carcinoma, but unidentified additional genomic abnormalities may be required for full phenotypic expression. OBJECTIVE: RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) was performed to identify genes differentially expressed between BRAF-MUT and BRAF wild-type (BRAF-WT) tumors and to correlate changes to patient clinical status. DESIGN: BRAF-MUT and BRAF-WT tumors were identified in patients with T1N0 and T2-3N1 tumors evaluated in a referral medical center. Gene expression levels were determined (RNA-Seq) and fusion transcripts were detected. Multiplexed capture/detection and digital counting of mRNA transcripts (nCounter, NanoString Technologies) validated RNA-Seq data for immune system-related genes. PATIENTS: BRAF-MUT patients included nine women, three men; nine were TNM stage I and three were stage III. Three (25%) had tumor infiltrating lymphocytes. BRAF-WT included five women, three men; all were stage I, and five (62.5%) had tumor infiltrating lymphocytes. RESULTS: RNA-Seq identified 560 of 13 085 genes differentially expressed between BRAF-MUT and BRAF-WT tumors. Approximately 10% of these genes were related to MetaCore immune function pathways; 51 were underexpressed in BRAF-MUT tumors, whereas 4 (HLAG, CXCL14, TIMP1, IL1RAP) were overexpressed. The four most differentially overexpressed immune genes in BRAF-WT tumors (IL1B; CCL19; CCL21; CXCR4) correlated with lymphocyte infiltration. nCounter confirmed the RNA-Seq expression level data. Eleven different high-confidence fusion transcripts were detected (four interchromosomal; seven intrachromosomal) in 13 of 20 tumors. All in-frame fusions were validated by RT-PCR. CONCLUSION: BRAF-MUT papillary thyroid cancers have reduced expression of immune/inflammatory response genes compared with BRAF-WT tumors and correlate with lymphocyte infiltration. In contrast, HLA-G and CXCL14 are overexpressed in BRAF-MUT tumors. Sixty-five percent of tumors had between one and three fusion transcripts. Functional studies will be required to determine the potential role of these newly identified genomic abnormalities in contributing to the aggressiveness of BRAF-MUT and BRAF-WT tumors.
CONTEXT: The BRAFV600E mutation (BRAF-MUT) confers an aggressive phenotype in papillary thyroid carcinoma, but unidentified additional genomic abnormalities may be required for full phenotypic expression. OBJECTIVE: RNA sequencing (RNA-Seq) was performed to identify genes differentially expressed between BRAF-MUT and BRAF wild-type (BRAF-WT) tumors and to correlate changes to patient clinical status. DESIGN:BRAF-MUT and BRAF-WT tumors were identified in patients with T1N0 and T2-3N1 tumors evaluated in a referral medical center. Gene expression levels were determined (RNA-Seq) and fusion transcripts were detected. Multiplexed capture/detection and digital counting of mRNA transcripts (nCounter, NanoString Technologies) validated RNA-Seq data for immune system-related genes. PATIENTS: BRAF-MUT patients included nine women, three men; nine were TNM stage I and three were stage III. Three (25%) had tumor infiltrating lymphocytes. BRAF-WT included five women, three men; all were stage I, and five (62.5%) had tumor infiltrating lymphocytes. RESULTS: RNA-Seq identified 560 of 13 085 genes differentially expressed between BRAF-MUT and BRAF-WT tumors. Approximately 10% of these genes were related to MetaCore immune function pathways; 51 were underexpressed in BRAF-MUT tumors, whereas 4 (HLAG, CXCL14, TIMP1, IL1RAP) were overexpressed. The four most differentially overexpressed immune genes in BRAF-WT tumors (IL1B; CCL19; CCL21; CXCR4) correlated with lymphocyte infiltration. nCounter confirmed the RNA-Seq expression level data. Eleven different high-confidence fusion transcripts were detected (four interchromosomal; seven intrachromosomal) in 13 of 20 tumors. All in-frame fusions were validated by RT-PCR. CONCLUSION:BRAF-MUT papillary thyroid cancers have reduced expression of immune/inflammatory response genes compared with BRAF-WT tumors and correlate with lymphocyte infiltration. In contrast, HLA-G and CXCL14 are overexpressed in BRAF-MUT tumors. Sixty-five percent of tumors had between one and three fusion transcripts. Functional studies will be required to determine the potential role of these newly identified genomic abnormalities in contributing to the aggressiveness of BRAF-MUT and BRAF-WT tumors.
Authors: Laura Barreyro; Britta Will; Boris Bartholdy; Li Zhou; Tihomira I Todorova; Robert F Stanley; Susana Ben-Neriah; Cristina Montagna; Samir Parekh; Andrea Pellagatti; Jacqueline Boultwood; Elisabeth Paietta; Rhett P Ketterling; Larry Cripe; Hugo F Fernandez; Peter L Greenberg; Martin S Tallman; Christian Steidl; Constantine S Mitsiades; Amit Verma; Ulrich Steidl Journal: Blood Date: 2012-06-21 Impact factor: 22.113
Authors: A Dardano; R Rizzo; A Polini; M Stignani; S Tognini; G Pasqualetti; S Ursino; C Colato; M Ferdeghini; O R Baricordi; F Monzani Journal: J Clin Endocrinol Metab Date: 2012-08-28 Impact factor: 5.958
Authors: Silvia Penuela; Laszlo Gyenis; Amber Ablack; Jared M Churko; Amy C Berger; David W Litchfield; John D Lewis; Dale W Laird Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2012-06-29 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Ricardo Celestino; Eva Sigstad; Marthe Løvf; Gard O S Thomassen; Krystyna K Grøholt; Lars H Jørgensen; Aasmund Berner; Patrícia Castro; Ragnhild A Lothe; Trine Bjøro; Manuel Sobrinho-Simões; Paula Soares; Rolf I Skotheim Journal: Genes Chromosomes Cancer Date: 2012-09-07 Impact factor: 5.006
Authors: Trevor E Angell; Melissa G Lechner; Julie K Jang; Adrian J Correa; Jonathan S LoPresti; Alan L Epstein Journal: Thyroid Date: 2014-07-15 Impact factor: 6.568
Authors: Iñigo Landa; Nikita Pozdeyev; Christopher Korch; Laura A Marlow; Robert C Smallridge; John A Copland; Ying C Henderson; Stephen Y Lai; Gary L Clayman; Naoyoshi Onoda; Aik Choon Tan; Maria E R Garcia-Rendueles; Jeffrey A Knauf; Bryan R Haugen; James A Fagin; Rebecca E Schweppe Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2019-02-08 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Trevor E Angell; Melissa G Lechner; Julie K Jang; Jonathan S LoPresti; Alan L Epstein Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2014-10-07 Impact factor: 12.531