Free energy landscapes for initiation and branching of protein aggregation.

Experiments on artificial multidomain protein constructs have probed the early stages of aggregation processes, but structural details of the species that initiate aggregation remain elusive. Using the associative-memory, water-mediated, structure and energy model known as AWSEM, a transferable coarse-grained protein model, we performed simulations of fused constructs composed of up to four copies of the Titin I27 domain or its mutant I27* (I59E). Free energy calculations enable us to quantify the conditions under which such multidomain constructs will spontaneously misfold. Consistent with experimental results, the dimer of I27 is found to be the smallest spontaneously misfolding construct. Our results show how structurally distinct misfolded states can be stabilized under different thermodynamic conditions, and this result provides a plausible link between the single-molecule misfolding experiments under native conditions and aggregation experiments under denaturing conditions. The conditions for spontaneous misfolding are determined by the interplay among temperature, effective local protein concentration, and the strength of the interdomain interactions. Above the folding temperature, fusing additional domains to the monomer destabilizes the native state, and the entropically stabilized amyloid-like state is favored. Because it is primarily energetically stabilized, the domain-swapped state is more likely to be important under native conditions. Both protofibril-like and branching structures are found in annealing simulations starting from extended structures, and these structures suggest a possible connection between the existence of multiple amyloidogenic segments in each domain and the formation of branched, amorphous aggregates as opposed to linear fibrillar structures.