OBJECTIVE: Extreme emotional reactivity is a defining feature of borderline personality disorder, yet the neural-behavioral mechanisms underlying this affective instability are poorly understood. One possible contributor is diminished ability to engage the mechanism of emotional habituation. The authors tested this hypothesis by examining behavioral and neural correlates of habituation in borderline patients, healthy comparison subjects, and a psychopathological comparison group of patients with avoidant personality disorder. METHOD: During fMRI scanning, borderline patients, healthy subjects, and avoidant personality disorder patients viewed novel and repeated pictures, providing valence ratings at each presentation. Statistical parametric maps of the contrasts of activation during repeated versus novel negative picture viewing were compared between groups. Psychophysiological interaction analysis was employed to examine functional connectivity differences between groups. RESULTS: Unlike healthy subjects, neither borderline nor avoidant personality disorder patients exhibited increased activity in the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex when viewing repeated versus novel pictures. This lack of an increase in dorsal anterior cingulate activity was associated with greater affective instability in borderline patients. In addition, borderline and avoidant patients exhibited smaller increases in insula-amygdala functional connectivity than healthy subjects and, unlike healthy subjects, did not show habituation in ratings of the emotional intensity of the images. Borderline patients differed from avoidant patients in insula-ventral anterior cingulate functional connectivity during habituation. CONCLUSIONS: Unlike healthy subjects, borderline patients fail to habituate to negative pictures, and they differ from both healthy subjects and avoidant patients in neural activity during habituation. A failure to effectively engage emotional habituation processes may contribute to affective instability in borderline patients.
OBJECTIVE: Extreme emotional reactivity is a defining feature of borderline personality disorder, yet the neural-behavioral mechanisms underlying this affective instability are poorly understood. One possible contributor is diminished ability to engage the mechanism of emotional habituation. The authors tested this hypothesis by examining behavioral and neural correlates of habituation in borderline patients, healthy comparison subjects, and a psychopathological comparison group of patients with avoidant personality disorder. METHOD: During fMRI scanning, borderline patients, healthy subjects, and avoidant personality disorderpatients viewed novel and repeated pictures, providing valence ratings at each presentation. Statistical parametric maps of the contrasts of activation during repeated versus novel negative picture viewing were compared between groups. Psychophysiological interaction analysis was employed to examine functional connectivity differences between groups. RESULTS: Unlike healthy subjects, neither borderline nor avoidant personality disorderpatients exhibited increased activity in the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex when viewing repeated versus novel pictures. This lack of an increase in dorsal anterior cingulate activity was associated with greater affective instability in borderline patients. In addition, borderline and avoidant patients exhibited smaller increases in insula-amygdala functional connectivity than healthy subjects and, unlike healthy subjects, did not show habituation in ratings of the emotional intensity of the images. Borderline patients differed from avoidant patients in insula-ventral anterior cingulate functional connectivity during habituation. CONCLUSIONS: Unlike healthy subjects, borderline patients fail to habituate to negative pictures, and they differ from both healthy subjects and avoidant patients in neural activity during habituation. A failure to effectively engage emotional habituation processes may contribute to affective instability in borderline patients.
Authors: Andrew E Skodol; John G Gunderson; Bruce Pfohl; Thomas A Widiger; W John Livesley; Larry J Siever Journal: Biol Psychiatry Date: 2002-06-15 Impact factor: 13.382
Authors: K Luan Phan; Israel Liberzon; Robert C Welsh; Jennifer C Britton; Stephan F Taylor Journal: Neuropsychopharmacology Date: 2003-04-23 Impact factor: 7.853
Authors: Håkan Fischer; Christopher I Wright; Paul J Whalen; Sean C McInerney; Lisa M Shin; Scott L Rauch Journal: Brain Res Bull Date: 2003-01-30 Impact factor: 4.077
Authors: H W Koenigsberg; P D Harvey; V Mitropoulou; A S New; M Goodman; J Silverman; M Serby; F Schopick; L J Siever Journal: J Pers Disord Date: 2001-08
Authors: Justin S Feinstein; Philippe R Goldin; Murray B Stein; Gregory G Brown; Martin P Paulus Journal: Neuroreport Date: 2002-07-19 Impact factor: 1.837
Authors: Nelson H Donegan; Charles A Sanislow; Hilary P Blumberg; Robert K Fulbright; Cheryl Lacadie; Pawel Skudlarski; John C Gore; Ingrid R Olson; Thomas H McGlashan; Bruce E Wexler Journal: Biol Psychiatry Date: 2003-12-01 Impact factor: 13.382
Authors: Kathryn R Cullen; Lori L LaRiviere; Nathalie Vizueta; Kathleen M Thomas; Ruskin H Hunt; Michael J Miller; Kelvin O Lim; Sellman C Schulz Journal: Brain Imaging Behav Date: 2016-06 Impact factor: 3.978
Authors: Merav H Silverman; Sylia Wilson; Ian S Ramsay; Ruskin H Hunt; Kathleen M Thomas; Robert F Krueger; William G Iacono Journal: Dev Psychopathol Date: 2019-06-03
Authors: Bryan T Denny; Jin Fan; Xun Liu; Kevin N Ochsner; Stephanie Guerreri; Sarah Jo Mayson; Liza Rimsky; Antonia McMaster; Antonia S New; Marianne Goodman; Larry J Siever; Harold W Koenigsberg Journal: J Affect Disord Date: 2014-09-28 Impact factor: 4.839
Authors: Marianne Goodman; David Carpenter; Cheuk Y Tang; Kim E Goldstein; Jennifer Avedon; Nicolas Fernandez; Kathryn A Mascitelli; Nicholas J Blair; Antonia S New; Joseph Triebwasser; Larry J Siever; Erin A Hazlett Journal: J Psychiatr Res Date: 2014-07-02 Impact factor: 4.791