Joshua L Kennedy1, Larry Borish. 1. Department of Medicine, Asthma and Allergic Disease Center, Carter Immunology Center, University of Virginia Health System, Charlottesville, Virginia, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Despite the recognition that bacteria are universally present in the sinuses of patients with chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) no compelling role for a primary infectious etiology of CRS has been elucidated. CRS is a constellation of inflammatory diseases that typically involve either noneosinophilic or eosinophilic processes, distinct conditions that must be treated individually. METHODS: The bacteria that are present in the sinuses may be innocuous bystanders but alternatively may contribute to the presence and severity of the disease through their ability to influence immune responses, function as immune adjuvants, provide antigens or superantigens that contribute to adaptive immune activation, or in forming the basis for the frequent acute superinfections. However, those bacteria that do contribute to the persistence and severity of CRS primarily reside in biofilms, and, as such, are not capable of being eradicated with antibiotics at the doses at which they can be used, even when local irrigation is considered. RESULTS: Biofilms create an inhospitable environment for antibiotic potency by down-regulating the metabolic activity of their "core" bacteria, decreasing the oxygen concentration, and altering the pH at the core of the biofilm. CONCLUSION: Ultimately, if topical antibiotics are considered, they should be primarily focused on treating acute exacerbations and choices of antibiotics should optimally be based on endoscopic culture. This should be done with the recognition that while under certain circumstances antibiotics can ameliorate the severity of CRS, even if bacterial eradication were possible, this would not eliminate the underlying primary pathogenic mechanism or the natural history of these conditions.
BACKGROUND: Despite the recognition that bacteria are universally present in the sinuses of patients with chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) no compelling role for a primary infectious etiology of CRS has been elucidated. CRS is a constellation of inflammatory diseases that typically involve either noneosinophilic or eosinophilic processes, distinct conditions that must be treated individually. METHODS: The bacteria that are present in the sinuses may be innocuous bystanders but alternatively may contribute to the presence and severity of the disease through their ability to influence immune responses, function as immune adjuvants, provide antigens or superantigens that contribute to adaptive immune activation, or in forming the basis for the frequent acute superinfections. However, those bacteria that do contribute to the persistence and severity of CRS primarily reside in biofilms, and, as such, are not capable of being eradicated with antibiotics at the doses at which they can be used, even when local irrigation is considered. RESULTS: Biofilms create an inhospitable environment for antibiotic potency by down-regulating the metabolic activity of their "core" bacteria, decreasing the oxygen concentration, and altering the pH at the core of the biofilm. CONCLUSION: Ultimately, if topical antibiotics are considered, they should be primarily focused on treating acute exacerbations and choices of antibiotics should optimally be based on endoscopic culture. This should be done with the recognition that while under certain circumstances antibiotics can ameliorate the severity of CRS, even if bacterial eradication were possible, this would not eliminate the underlying primary pathogenic mechanism or the natural history of these conditions.
Authors: A Mochizuki; N Tamura; Y Yatabe; S Onodera; T Hiruma; N Inaba; J Kusunoki; H Tomioka Journal: Eur J Pharmacol Date: 2001-10-26 Impact factor: 4.432
Authors: Anthony A Prince; Jacob D Steiger; Ayesha N Khalid; Laurel Dogrhamji; Christine Reger; Steven Eau Claire; Alexander G Chiu; David W Kennedy; James N Palmer; Noam A Cohen Journal: Am J Rhinol Date: 2008 May-Jun
Authors: Eli O Meltzer; Daniel L Hamilos; James A Hadley; Donald C Lanza; Bradley F Marple; Richard A Nicklas; Claus Bachert; James Baraniuk; Fuad M Baroody; Michael S Benninger; Itzhak Brook; Badrul A Chowdhury; Howard M Druce; Stephen Durham; Berrylin Ferguson; Jack M Gwaltney; Michael Kaliner; David W Kennedy; Valerie Lund; Robert Naclerio; Ruby Pawankar; Jay F Piccirillo; Patricia Rohane; Ronald Simon; Raymond G Slavin; Alkis Togias; Ellen R Wald; S James Zinreich Journal: Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg Date: 2004-12 Impact factor: 3.497
Authors: Fausto Braccioni; Sandra C Dorman; Paul M O'byrne; Mark D Inman; Judah A Denburg; Krishnan Parameswaran; Adrian J Baatjes; Ronan Foley; Gail M Gauvreau Journal: J Allergy Clin Immunol Date: 2002-07 Impact factor: 10.793
Authors: Alethea Grobler; Erik K Weitzel; Achim Buele; Camille Jardeleza; Yew C Cheong; John Field; Peter-John Wormald Journal: Laryngoscope Date: 2008-11 Impact factor: 3.325
Authors: Dong-Jin Lim; Daniel Skinner; John Mclemore; Nick Rivers; Jeffrey Brent Elder; Mark Allen; Connor Koch; John West; Shaoyan Zhang; Harrison M Thompson; Justin P McCormick; Jessica W Grayson; Do-Yeon Cho; Bradford A Woodworth Journal: Int Forum Allergy Rhinol Date: 2019-11-06 Impact factor: 3.858
Authors: Robert J Lee; Benjamin M Hariri; Derek B McMahon; Bei Chen; Laurel Doghramji; Nithin D Adappa; James N Palmer; David W Kennedy; Peihua Jiang; Robert F Margolskee; Noam A Cohen Journal: Sci Signal Date: 2017-09-05 Impact factor: 8.192
Authors: Amanda L Willis; Joshua B Calton; Tara F Carr; Alexander G Chiu; Eugene H Chang Journal: Am J Rhinol Allergy Date: 2015-12-28 Impact factor: 2.467
Authors: Michael Hoggard; Brett Wagner Mackenzie; Ravi Jain; Michael W Taylor; Kristi Biswas; Richard G Douglas Journal: Clin Microbiol Rev Date: 2017-01 Impact factor: 26.132
Authors: Benjamin M Hariri; Derek B McMahon; Bei Chen; Jenna R Freund; Corrine J Mansfield; Laurel J Doghramji; Nithin D Adappa; James N Palmer; David W Kennedy; Danielle R Reed; Peihua Jiang; Robert J Lee Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2017-04-03 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Benjamin M Hariri; Sakeena J Payne; Bei Chen; Corrine Mansfield; Laurel J Doghramji; Nithin D Adappa; James N Palmer; David W Kennedy; Masha Y Niv; Robert J Lee Journal: Am J Rhinol Allergy Date: 2016-07 Impact factor: 2.467