Literature DB >> 24174860

Physician 'defiance' towards hand hygiene compliance: Is there a theory-practice-ethics gap?

Manfred Mortell1, Hanan H Balkhy, Elias B Tannous, Mei Thiee Jong.   

Abstract

BACKGROUND: The theory-practice gap has always existed [1,2]. This gap is often cited as a culmination of theory being idealistic and impractical, even if practical and beneficial, is often ignored. Most of the evidence relating to the non-integration of theory and practice assumes that environmental factors are responsible and will affect learning and practice outcomes, hence the gap. Therefore, the author believes that to 'bridge the gap' between theory and practice, an additional dimension is required: ethics. A moral duty and obligation ensuring theory and practice integrate. In order to effectively implement new practices, one must deem these practices as worthy and relevant to their role as healthcare providers (HCP). Hence, this introduces a new concept which the author refers to as the theory-practice-ethics gap. This theory-practice-ethics gap must be considered when reviewing some of the unacceptable outcomes in healthcare practice [3]. The literature suggests that there is a crisis of ethics where theory and practice integrate, and healthcare providers are failing to fulfill our duty as patient advocates. HYPOTHESIS: Physician hand hygiene practices and compliance at King Abdulaziz Cardiac Centre (KACC) are consistent with those of other physicians in the global healthcare arena. That is one of noncompliance to King Abdulaziz Medical City (KAMC) organizational expectations and the World Health Organization (WHO) requirements?
METHODS: An observational study was conducted on the compliance of cardiac surgeons, cardiologists and nurses in the authors' cardiac center from January 2010 to December 2011. The hand hygiene (HH) compliance elements that were evaluated pertained to the WHO's five moments of HH recommendations. The data was obtained through direct observation by KAMC infection prevention and control practitioners.
RESULTS: Physician hand hygiene compliance at KACC was consistently less than 60%, with nurses regularly encouraging physicians to be diligent with hand hygiene practices in the clinical area.
CONCLUSION: Hand hygiene compliance will not improve unless evidence-based recommendations are adopted and endorsed by all healthcare professionals and providers.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Ethics; Hand hygiene; Healthcare associated infection; Physician; Practice; Theory

Year:  2013        PMID: 24174860      PMCID: PMC3809478          DOI: 10.1016/j.jsha.2013.04.003

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Saudi Heart Assoc        ISSN: 1016-7315


  26 in total

1.  Lapses in measures recommended for preventing hospital-acquired infection.

Authors:  P N Chandra; K Milind
Journal:  J Hosp Infect       Date:  2001-03       Impact factor: 3.926

2.  Impact of education on knowledge, attitudes and practices among various categories of health care workers on nosocomial infections.

Authors:  J B Suchitra; N Lakshmi Devi
Journal:  Indian J Med Microbiol       Date:  2007-07       Impact factor: 0.985

3.  A resuscitation "dilemma" theory-practice-ethics. Is there a theory-practice-ethics gap?

Authors:  Manfred Mortell
Journal:  J Saudi Heart Assoc       Date:  2009-08-05

4.  Microbial flora on the hands of health care personnel: differences in composition and antibacterial resistance.

Authors:  W A Horn; E L Larson; K J McGinley; J J Leyden
Journal:  Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol       Date:  1988-05       Impact factor: 3.254

Review 5.  A classical view of the theory-practice gap in nursing.

Authors:  P Allmark
Journal:  J Adv Nurs       Date:  1995-07       Impact factor: 3.187

6.  epic2: National evidence-based guidelines for preventing healthcare-associated infections in NHS hospitals in England.

Authors:  R J Pratt; C M Pellowe; J A Wilson; H P Loveday; P J Harper; S R L J Jones; C McDougall; M H Wilcox
Journal:  J Hosp Infect       Date:  2007-02       Impact factor: 3.926

7.  Compliance with handwashing in a teaching hospital. Infection Control Program.

Authors:  D Pittet; P Mourouga; T V Perneger
Journal:  Ann Intern Med       Date:  1999-01-19       Impact factor: 25.391

8.  A multicentre survey of hand hygiene practice in intensive care units.

Authors:  L J Sproat; T J Inglis
Journal:  J Hosp Infect       Date:  1994-02       Impact factor: 3.926

9.  Hand washing frequency in an emergency department.

Authors:  M R Meengs; B K Giles; C D Chisholm; W H Cordell; D R Nelson
Journal:  J Emerg Nurs       Date:  1994-06       Impact factor: 1.836

10.  Clean Care is Safer Care: a worldwide priority.

Authors:  Didier Pittet; Liam Donaldson
Journal:  Lancet       Date:  2005-10-08       Impact factor: 79.321

View more
  8 in total

1.  Healthcare professionals' hand hygiene knowledge and beliefs in the United Arab Emirates.

Authors:  Wai Khuan Ng; Ramon Z Shaban; Thea van de Mortel
Journal:  J Infect Prev       Date:  2016-11-21

2.  'And you'll suddenly realise 'I've not washed my hands': medical students', junior doctors' and medical educators' narratives of hygiene behaviours.

Authors:  Penelope Cresswell; Lynn V Monrouxe
Journal:  BMJ Open       Date:  2018-03-22       Impact factor: 2.692

3.  Knowledge, Attitude and Practice on Hospital-Acquired Infection Prevention and Associated Factors Among Healthcare Workers at University of Gondar Comprehensive Specialized Hospital, Northwest Ethiopia.

Authors:  Biruk Bayleyegn; Addisu Mehari; Debasu Damtie; Markos Negash
Journal:  Infect Drug Resist       Date:  2021-01-27       Impact factor: 4.003

Review 4.  What were the historical reasons for the resistance to recognizing airborne transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic?

Authors:  Jose L Jimenez; Linsey C Marr; Katherine Randall; Edward Thomas Ewing; Zeynep Tufekci; Trish Greenhalgh; Raymond Tellier; Julian W Tang; Yuguo Li; Lidia Morawska; Jonathan Mesiano-Crookston; David Fisman; Orla Hegarty; Stephanie J Dancer; Philomena M Bluyssen; Giorgio Buonanno; Marcel G L C Loomans; William P Bahnfleth; Maosheng Yao; Chandra Sekhar; Pawel Wargocki; Arsen K Melikov; Kimberly A Prather
Journal:  Indoor Air       Date:  2022-08       Impact factor: 6.554

5.  Disinfectants Used in Stomatology and SARS-CoV-2 Infection.

Authors:  Magdalena Stawarz-Janeczek; Agata Kryczyk-Poprawa; Bożena Muszyńska; Włodzimierz Opoka; Jolanta Pytko-Polończyk
Journal:  Eur J Dent       Date:  2021-03-10

6.  Hand hygiene knowledge of primary health care workers in Abha city, South Western Saudi Arabia.

Authors:  Ahmed A Mahfouz; Ahmed Abolyazid; Hasan M Al-Musa; Nabil J Awadallah; Aesha Faraheen; Shamsunhar Khalil; Mohammad N El-Gamal; Khalid M Al-Musa
Journal:  J Family Med Prim Care       Date:  2017 Jan-Mar

7.  Why hand hygiene is not sufficient: modeling hygiene competence of clinical staff as a basis for its development and assessment.

Authors:  Martin Gartmeier; Maria Baumgartner; Rainer Burgkart; Susanne Heiniger; Pascal O Berberat
Journal:  GMS J Med Educ       Date:  2019-08-15

8.  Improving hand hygiene compliance among healthcare workers: an intervention study in a Hospital in Guizhou Province, China.

Authors:  Xia Mu; Yan Xu; Tingxiu Yang; Ji Zhang; Chong Wang; Wei Liu; Jing Chen; Luyu Tang; Huai Yang
Journal:  Braz J Infect Dis       Date:  2016-06-25       Impact factor: 3.257

  8 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.