Literature DB >> 24111504

A belief in the soul may contribute to the stress experienced in the dissecting room.

Helen Martyn1, Anthony Barrett, Helen D Nicholson.   

Abstract

The aim of this research was to explore whether medical students believe in a soul and how this may affect their dissecting experience. Three questionnaires were delivered electronically to the 2011 cohort of second-year medical students over a 2-year period. At the University of Otago, students enter medicine via three categories: Health Sciences First Year (following 1 year of university); postgraduate (following a Bachelors or higher degree); and 'other' category entry (Allied Health Professional or 3 years after a Bachelors degree). The entry category, age, ethnicity and gender of the students were collected; 51.6% of the students believed in the concept of a soul. On a scale of 1-5, students ranked the importance of religion/spirituality as 2.69. Those who believed in a soul were more likely to have a religious/spiritual component to their life and be males or 'other' category entrants. However, there were many students who believed in the soul who did not have a religious/spiritual association, suggesting that this belief extends beyond religion. Those who believed in a soul had significantly higher anticipatory stress and experienced higher levels of stress during dissection. A higher proportion of students in the 'other' category entrants believed in the concept of the soul and also had significantly higher levels of stress during dissection. Our data suggest that a belief in a soul may affect students' experiences in dissecting. Incorporating the teaching of humanities with anatomy may help medical students as they assimilate both the biomedical and philosophical aspects of dissection.
© 2013 Anatomical Society.

Keywords:  dissection; entry category; medical students; soul; spirituality

Mesh:

Year:  2013        PMID: 24111504      PMCID: PMC3931545          DOI: 10.1111/joa.12122

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Anat        ISSN: 0021-8782            Impact factor:   2.610


  10 in total

1.  Attitudes of medical and dental students to dissection.

Authors:  J Snelling; A Sahai; H Ellis
Journal:  Clin Anat       Date:  2003-03       Impact factor: 2.414

2.  Brains and persons: an educational perspective.

Authors:  D Gareth Jones; Mike R King; Maja I Whitaker
Journal:  Clin Anat       Date:  2012-01-31       Impact factor: 2.414

3.  Attitudes and reactions of Jordanian medical students to the dissecting room.

Authors:  Ziad M Bataineh; Taghreed A Hijazi; Marwan F Abu Hijleh
Journal:  Surg Radiol Anat       Date:  2006-03-28       Impact factor: 1.246

4.  Emotional impact of cadaver dissection: a survey in a medical college in western Nepal.

Authors:  P Vijayabhaskar; P R Shankar; A K Dubey
Journal:  Kathmandu Univ Med J (KUMJ)       Date:  2005 Apr-Jun

5.  Do we need dissection in an integrated problem-based learning medical course? Perceptions of first- and second-year students.

Authors:  Samy A Azer; Norm Eizenberg
Journal:  Surg Radiol Anat       Date:  2007-02-21       Impact factor: 1.246

6.  Medical students' responses to the dissection of the heart and brain: A dialogue on the seat of the soul.

Authors:  Helen Martyn; Anthony Barrett; Paul Trotman; Helen Nicholson
Journal:  Clin Anat       Date:  2011-07-12       Impact factor: 2.414

Review 7.  The anatomic location of the soul from the heart, through the brain, to the whole body, and beyond: a journey through Western history, science, and philosophy.

Authors:  Giuseppe Santoro; Mark D Wood; Lucia Merlo; Giuseppe Pio Anastasi; Francesco Tomasello; Antonino Germanò
Journal:  Neurosurgery       Date:  2009-10       Impact factor: 4.654

8.  Attitudes and reactions of Arab medical students to the dissecting room.

Authors:  M F Abu-Hijleh; N A Hamdi; S T Moqattash; P F Harris; G F Heseltine
Journal:  Clin Anat       Date:  1997       Impact factor: 2.414

9.  Medical students' understanding of the concept of a soul.

Authors:  Helen Martyn; Anthony Barrett; Helen D Nicholson
Journal:  Anat Sci Educ       Date:  2013-05-03       Impact factor: 5.958

10.  Talking about death: implementing peer discussion as a coping mechanism to overcome fears about dissection, death, and dying.

Authors:  Sanet Henriët Kotzé; Calvin Gerald Mole
Journal:  Anat Sci Educ       Date:  2012-12-03       Impact factor: 5.958

  10 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.