Literature DB >> 24090010

The physician's breach of the duty to inform the parent of deformities and abnormalities in the foetus: "wrongful life" actions, a new frontier of medical responsibility.

Paola Frati1, Matteo Gulino, Emanuela Turillazzi, Simona Zaami, Vittorio Fineschi.   

Abstract

A recent decision of the Italian Highest Court for the first time legitimized wrongful life suits. The Court stated the following principles: (a) the contract between the mother and the doctor has also protective effects in favour of third parties (father, siblings and the disabled child) who have the right to be compensated; (b) the right to compensation is neither based on the right not to be born nor on the right to be born healthy, but rather it is based on the breach of duty of care which coincides with the child's disabled status; (c) siblings may suffer the reduced availability of their parents; (d) the doctor is held responsible for not providing full information to the mother about the foetal deformity. The Supreme Court once again emphasized the importance of information on the matter of very personal choices, such as termination of pregnancy in case of foetal malformations. In the present case, the gynaecologist breached the duty to inform, especially after the patient requested diagnostic tests designed to highlight any foetal malformations and informed the doctor of the possibility of an eventual subsequent termination of pregnancy if foetal malformations were found.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Malpractice claims; medical errors; wrongful birth; wrongful life

Mesh:

Year:  2013        PMID: 24090010     DOI: 10.3109/14767058.2013.850664

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med        ISSN: 1476-4954


  3 in total

1.  Introducing the next generation sequencing in genomic amnio and villuos sampling. The so called "Next Generation Prenatal Diagnosis" (NGPD).

Authors:  Claudio Giorlandino; Alvaro Mesoraca; Domenico Bizzoco; Claudio Dello Russo; Antonella Cima; Gianluca Di Giacomo; Pietro Cignini; Francesco Padula; Nella Dugo; Laura D'Emidio; Cristiana Brizzi; Raffaella Raffio; Vincenzo Milite; Lucia Mangiafico; Claudio Coco; Ornella Carcioppolo; Roberto Vigna; Marialuisa Mastrandrea; Luisa Mobili
Journal:  J Prenat Med       Date:  2014 Jan-Mar

2.  Perspectives of Italian pregnant women on pregnancy examinations and pregnancy care: is the caregiver more important than the care?

Authors:  Ugo Indraccolo; Simona Cona; Alexandra Nistor; Salvatore Renato Indraccolo; Romolo Di Iorio; Piergiorgio Fedeli; Carlo De Angelis
Journal:  Acta Biomed       Date:  2021-03-31

3.  Medical error disclosure: from the therapeutic alliance to risk management: the vision of the new Italian code of medical ethics.

Authors:  Emanuela Turillazzi; Margherita Neri
Journal:  BMC Med Ethics       Date:  2014-07-15       Impact factor: 2.652

  3 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.