Ramsey M Dallal1, John Pang2, Ian Soriano2, Daniel Cottam3, Jeffrey Lord4, Susan Cox5. 1. Einstein Healthcare Network, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Electronic address: Dallalr@einstein.edu. 2. Einstein Healthcare Network, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. 3. Bariatric Medical Institute, Salt Lake City, Utah. 4. Sacred Heart Health System, Pensacola, Florida. 5. American Society of Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery, Gainesville, Florida.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The medicolegal aspects of bariatric surgery are very difficult to analyze scientifically because there is no central, searchable database of closed case claims and little incentive for malpractice insurers to divulge data. Examining medicolegal data may provide insight into the financial and psychological burden on physicians. Detailed data also may be used to improve patient safety and determine common causes of negligence. METHODS: All U.S.-based members of the American Society of Metabolic and Bariatric Surgeons were asked to complete a survey regarding their bariatric-related medical malpractice experience. RESULTS: Of the 1672 eligible members that received the survey, 330 responded (19.7%). Mean years in practice was 15.3 ± 9. Mean annual cost of malpractice insurance was $59,200 ± $52,000 (N = 197). The respondent surgeons experienced 1.5 ± 3.2 lawsuits on average over the course of their practice. Of the 330 respondents, 144 (48%) did not report a bariatric-related lawsuit filed against them. Of the 464 lawsuits reported by 156 surgeons, 126 were settled out of court (27%), 249 were dropped (54%), and 54 (18%) went to trial. Seventy-two percent of cases that went to trial were found to be in favor of the defense. The mean lifetime amount paid for suits was $250,000±$660,000. The probability of a bariatric surgeon experiencing a lawsuit was independently associated with the years in practice (P = .03) and number of total cases the surgeon has performed (P = .01). The annual cost of malpractice insurance was independently predicted by the amount paid in previous claims (P = .01). CONCLUSIONS: The probability of a medical malpractice lawsuit correlates positively to the number of procedures performed and the number of years the surgeon has been in practice.
BACKGROUND: The medicolegal aspects of bariatric surgery are very difficult to analyze scientifically because there is no central, searchable database of closed case claims and little incentive for malpractice insurers to divulge data. Examining medicolegal data may provide insight into the financial and psychological burden on physicians. Detailed data also may be used to improve patient safety and determine common causes of negligence. METHODS: All U.S.-based members of the American Society of Metabolic and Bariatric Surgeons were asked to complete a survey regarding their bariatric-related medical malpractice experience. RESULTS: Of the 1672 eligible members that received the survey, 330 responded (19.7%). Mean years in practice was 15.3 ± 9. Mean annual cost of malpractice insurance was $59,200 ± $52,000 (N = 197). The respondent surgeons experienced 1.5 ± 3.2 lawsuits on average over the course of their practice. Of the 330 respondents, 144 (48%) did not report a bariatric-related lawsuit filed against them. Of the 464 lawsuits reported by 156 surgeons, 126 were settled out of court (27%), 249 were dropped (54%), and 54 (18%) went to trial. Seventy-two percent of cases that went to trial were found to be in favor of the defense. The mean lifetime amount paid for suits was $250,000±$660,000. The probability of a bariatric surgeon experiencing a lawsuit was independently associated with the years in practice (P = .03) and number of total cases the surgeon has performed (P = .01). The annual cost of malpractice insurance was independently predicted by the amount paid in previous claims (P = .01). CONCLUSIONS: The probability of a medical malpractice lawsuit correlates positively to the number of procedures performed and the number of years the surgeon has been in practice.