A Morice1, A Coupry, F Lintz, H Robert. 1. North Mayenne Hospital, Orthopaedic Department, 229, boulevard Paul-Lintier, 53100 Mayenne, France.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: The best treatment for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) mucoid degeneration remains open to debate. Current options are total or partial ACL resection, or a more conservative strategy, reduction plasty. The goal of this study was to retrospectively evaluate the effects of reduction plasty for ACL hypertrophy due to mucoid degeneration from clinical outcome and knee laxity points of view. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Arthroscopy was carried out on 23 knees (21 patients) to perform a circular volume reduction plasty of the ACL, while preserving the greatest number of ligament fibers. Notchplasty was not performed. All the patients were seen again with an average follow-up of 32 months (range 8-70). RESULTS: All the knees except three had symmetric postoperative flexion. Three patients still had pain. No patient reported having subjective feelings of instability. Among the 20 knees tested with the GNRB(TM) knee laxity measurement device, one knee had a 2.4mm difference in laxity and three had between 3 and 4mm of difference; 16 knees had no residual laxity. DISCUSSION: Treatment of ACL mucoid degeneration by reduction plasty leads to complete pain relief in 80% of cases while maintaining good postoperative knee stability. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV. Retrospective study.
INTRODUCTION: The best treatment for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) mucoid degeneration remains open to debate. Current options are total or partial ACL resection, or a more conservative strategy, reduction plasty. The goal of this study was to retrospectively evaluate the effects of reduction plasty for ACL hypertrophy due to mucoid degeneration from clinical outcome and knee laxity points of view. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Arthroscopy was carried out on 23 knees (21 patients) to perform a circular volume reduction plasty of the ACL, while preserving the greatest number of ligament fibers. Notchplasty was not performed. All the patients were seen again with an average follow-up of 32 months (range 8-70). RESULTS: All the knees except three had symmetric postoperative flexion. Three patients still had pain. No patient reported having subjective feelings of instability. Among the 20 knees tested with the GNRB(TM) knee laxity measurement device, one knee had a 2.4mm difference in laxity and three had between 3 and 4mm of difference; 16 knees had no residual laxity. DISCUSSION: Treatment of ACL mucoid degeneration by reduction plasty leads to complete pain relief in 80% of cases while maintaining good postoperative knee stability. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV. Retrospective study.