Literature DB >> 23962031

Prehospital use of cervical collars in trauma patients: a critical review.

Terje Sundstrøm1, Helge Asbjørnsen, Samer Habiba, Geir Arne Sunde, Knut Wester.   

Abstract

The cervical collar has been routinely used for trauma patients for more than 30 years and is a hallmark of state-of-the-art prehospital trauma care. However, the existing evidence for this practice is limited: Randomized, controlled trials are largely missing, and there are uncertain effects on mortality, neurological injury, and spinal stability. Even more concerning, there is a growing body of evidence and opinion against the use of collars. It has been argued that collars cause more harm than good, and that we should simply stop using them. In this critical review, we discuss the pros and cons of collar use in trauma patients and reflect on how we can move our clinical practice forward. Conclusively, we propose a safe, effective strategy for prehospital spinal immobilization that does not include routine use of collars.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2013        PMID: 23962031      PMCID: PMC3949434          DOI: 10.1089/neu.2013.3094

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Neurotrauma        ISSN: 0897-7151            Impact factor:   5.269


  215 in total

Review 1.  Airway management in adults after cervical spine trauma.

Authors:  Edward T Crosby
Journal:  Anesthesiology       Date:  2006-06       Impact factor: 7.892

2.  Emergency intubation: a prospective multicentre descriptive audit in an Australian helicopter emergency medical service.

Authors:  M Gunning; E O'Loughlin; M Fletcher; J Crilly; M Hooper; D Y Ellis
Journal:  Emerg Med J       Date:  2009-01       Impact factor: 2.740

3.  What are the highest priorities for research in emergency prehospital care?

Authors:  Helen Snooks; Angela Evans; Bridget Wells; Julie Peconi; Marie Thomas; Malcolm Woollard; Henry Guly; Emma Jenkinson; Janette Turner; Chris Hartley-Sharpe
Journal:  Emerg Med J       Date:  2009-08       Impact factor: 2.740

4.  Airway management in the patient with potential cervical spine instability: continuing professional development.

Authors:  Arnaud Robitaille
Journal:  Can J Anaesth       Date:  2011-10-27       Impact factor: 5.063

5.  The impact of prehospital endotracheal intubation on outcome in moderate to severe traumatic brain injury.

Authors:  Daniel P Davis; Jeremy Peay; Michael J Sise; Gary M Vilke; Frank Kennedy; A Brent Eastman; Thomas Velky; David B Hoyt
Journal:  J Trauma       Date:  2005-05

6.  A comparison of methods of cervical immobilization used in patient extrication and transport.

Authors:  J R Cline; E Scheidel; E F Bigsby
Journal:  J Trauma       Date:  1985-07

Review 7.  Extrication, immobilization and radiologic investigation of patients with cervical spine injuries.

Authors:  O A Karbi; D A Caspari; C H Tator
Journal:  CMAJ       Date:  1988-10-01       Impact factor: 8.262

8.  The safety of awake tracheal intubation in cervical spine injury.

Authors:  A Meschino; J H Devitt; J P Koch; J P Szalai; M L Schwartz
Journal:  Can J Anaesth       Date:  1992-02       Impact factor: 5.063

9.  The lateral trauma position: what do we know about it and how do we use it? A cross-sectional survey of all Norwegian emergency medical services.

Authors:  Sabina Fattah; Guri R Ekås; Per Kristian Hyldmo; Torben Wisborg
Journal:  Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med       Date:  2011-08-04       Impact factor: 2.953

10.  Patient safety in pre-hospital emergency tracheal intubation: a comprehensive meta-analysis of the intubation success rates of EMS providers.

Authors:  Hans Morten Lossius; Jo Røislien; David J Lockey
Journal:  Crit Care       Date:  2012-02-11       Impact factor: 9.097

View more
  27 in total

1.  [Parameters influencing the preclinical application of cervical collars].

Authors:  M Kreinest; S Goller; G Rauch; B Gliwitzky; C Frank; S Matschke; C G Wölfl; M Münzberg
Journal:  Unfallchirurg       Date:  2017-08       Impact factor: 1.000

2.  Semirigid cervical spine collar and risk of missing significant soft tissue injuries.

Authors:  Mohammed Hassan Hussain; Kenneth Corsar
Journal:  BMJ Case Rep       Date:  2019-04-04

3.  Emergency Neurological Life Support: Traumatic Spine Injury.

Authors:  Deborah M Stein; William A Knight
Journal:  Neurocrit Care       Date:  2017-09       Impact factor: 3.210

Review 4.  On-scene treatment of spinal injuries in motor sports.

Authors:  M Kreinest; M Scholz; P Trafford
Journal:  Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg       Date:  2016-12-22       Impact factor: 3.693

5.  Expertise of German paramedics concerning the prehospital treatment of patients with spinal trauma.

Authors:  M Kreinest; S Goller; B Gliwitzky; P A Grützner; M Küffer; D Häske; V Papathanassiou; M Münzberg
Journal:  Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg       Date:  2016-05-12       Impact factor: 3.693

Review 6.  Cervical immobilization in trauma patients: soft collars better than rigid collars? A systematic review and meta-analysis.

Authors:  Henrik C Bäcker; Patrick Elias; Karl F Braun; Michael A Johnson; Peter Turner; John Cunningham
Journal:  Eur Spine J       Date:  2022-10-01       Impact factor: 2.721

7.  Evaluating the paramedic application of the prehospital Canadian C-Spine Rule in sport-related injuries.

Authors:  Harrison Carmichael; Christian Vaillancourt; Ian Shrier; Manya Charette; Elisabeth Hobden; Ian G Stiell
Journal:  CJEM       Date:  2021-03-15       Impact factor: 2.410

8.  The role of cervical collars and verbal instructions in minimising spinal movement during self-extrication following a motor vehicle collision - a biomechanical study using healthy volunteers.

Authors:  Tim Nutbeam; Rob Fenwick; Barbara May; Willem Stassen; Jason E Smith; Lee Wallis; Mike Dayson; James Shippen
Journal:  Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med       Date:  2021-07-31       Impact factor: 2.953

Review 9.  Does turning trauma patients with an unstable spinal injury from the supine to a lateral position increase the risk of neurological deterioration?--A systematic review.

Authors:  Per Kristian Hyldmo; Gunn E Vist; Anders Christian Feyling; Leif Rognås; Vidar Magnusson; Mårten Sandberg; Eldar Søreide
Journal:  Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med       Date:  2015-09-17       Impact factor: 2.953

Review 10.  Development of a new Emergency Medicine Spinal Immobilization Protocol for trauma patients and a test of applicability by German emergency care providers.

Authors:  Michael Kreinest; Bernhard Gliwitzky; Svenja Schüler; Paul A Grützner; Matthias Münzberg
Journal:  Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med       Date:  2016-05-14       Impact factor: 2.953

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.