G Verma1, A W Chuck, P Jacobs. 1. Department of Medicine, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. gverma@ualberta.ca
Abstract
SETTING: Long-term care facilities in Canada, a low tuberculosis (TB) incidence country. OBJECTIVE: To compare the impact and cost-effectiveness of three screening strategies for TB on entry to long-term care: no screening, screening for latent tuberculous infection (LTBI) using the tuberculin skin test (TST) or screening for active disease with a chest X-ray. DESIGN: Cost effectiveness analysis. RESULTS: With the LTBI screening strategy, the number needed to screen to prevent one active case was 1410 and the cost per case averted was Canadian $109 913. The number needed to screen to prevent one case using the active screening strategy was 1266, and the cost per case averted was $672 298. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that TB screening strategies on entry to long-term care are costly, with large numbers needed to screen. Screening with TST was more cost-effective than chest X-ray screening. Higher risk of reactivation of LTBI is associated with improved cost-effectiveness of screening. Short time horizons and test performance characteristics place limitations on screening programmes in this setting. Future considerations include the changing demographics of the institutionalised elderly.
SETTING: Long-term care facilities in Canada, a low tuberculosis (TB) incidence country. OBJECTIVE: To compare the impact and cost-effectiveness of three screening strategies for TB on entry to long-term care: no screening, screening for latent tuberculous infection (LTBI) using the tuberculin skin test (TST) or screening for active disease with a chest X-ray. DESIGN: Cost effectiveness analysis. RESULTS: With the LTBI screening strategy, the number needed to screen to prevent one active case was 1410 and the cost per case averted was Canadian $109 913. The number needed to screen to prevent one case using the active screening strategy was 1266, and the cost per case averted was $672 298. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that TB screening strategies on entry to long-term care are costly, with large numbers needed to screen. Screening with TST was more cost-effective than chest X-ray screening. Higher risk of reactivation of LTBI is associated with improved cost-effectiveness of screening. Short time horizons and test performance characteristics place limitations on screening programmes in this setting. Future considerations include the changing demographics of the institutionalised elderly.
Authors: Knut Lönnroth; Giovanni Battista Migliori; Ibrahim Abubakar; Lia D'Ambrosio; Gerard de Vries; Roland Diel; Paul Douglas; Dennis Falzon; Marc-Andre Gaudreau; Delia Goletti; Edilberto R González Ochoa; Philip LoBue; Alberto Matteelli; Howard Njoo; Ivan Solovic; Alistair Story; Tamara Tayeb; Marieke J van der Werf; Diana Weil; Jean-Pierre Zellweger; Mohamed Abdel Aziz; Mohamed R M Al Lawati; Stefano Aliberti; Wouter Arrazola de Oñate; Draurio Barreira; Vineet Bhatia; Francesco Blasi; Amy Bloom; Judith Bruchfeld; Francesco Castelli; Rosella Centis; Daniel Chemtob; Daniela M Cirillo; Alberto Colorado; Andrei Dadu; Ulf R Dahle; Laura De Paoli; Hannah M Dias; Raquel Duarte; Lanfranco Fattorini; Mina Gaga; Haileyesus Getahun; Philippe Glaziou; Lasha Goguadze; Mirtha Del Granado; Walter Haas; Asko Järvinen; Geun-Yong Kwon; Davide Mosca; Payam Nahid; Nobuyuki Nishikiori; Isabel Noguer; Joan O'Donnell; Analita Pace-Asciak; Maria G Pompa; Gilda G Popescu; Carlos Robalo Cordeiro; Karin Rønning; Morten Ruhwald; Jean-Paul Sculier; Aleksandar Simunović; Alison Smith-Palmer; Giovanni Sotgiu; Giorgia Sulis; Carlos A Torres-Duque; Kazunori Umeki; Mukund Uplekar; Catharina van Weezenbeek; Tuula Vasankari; Robert J Vitillo; Constantia Voniatis; Maryse Wanlin; Mario C Raviglione Journal: Eur Respir J Date: 2015-04 Impact factor: 16.671
Authors: Jun Li; Benjamin H K Yip; Chichiu Leung; Wankyo Chung; Kin On Kwok; Emily Y Y Chan; Engkiong Yeoh; Puihong Chung Journal: PLoS One Date: 2018-01-02 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Jun Li; Pui-Hong Chung; Cyrus L K Leung; Nobuyuki Nishikiori; Emily Y Y Chan; Eng-Kiong Yeoh Journal: Infect Dis Poverty Date: 2017-06-01 Impact factor: 4.520