Male soldiers are functional in the Japanese strain of a polyembryonic wasp.

Polyembryonic parasitoids clonally produce sterile soldier larvae in both sexes. Female soldier larvae of Copidosoma floridanum defend their siblings and host resources against heterospecific competitors as well as conspecific male embryos that results in female biased sex ratios. However, the male soldiers of the USA strain exhibit no aggressive behaviors against them, suspected to be a secondary loss of male defense function in the course of evolution. From vitro and vivo experiments, we have found functional male soldiers in the Japanese strain of C. floridanum. In vitro experiments, male soldiers exhibit aggressions against four larval competitors, though aggressiveness is much weaker than that of female soldiers. In vivo experiments, heterospecific competitors are equivocally excluded in both male and female broods. Our findings support the idea that male soldiers have evolved primarily to defend against heterospecific competitors. Further experiments against conspecific embryos may be able to confirm this hypothesis.

Sterile female caste is most conspicuously observed in many hymenopteran insects that had evolved eusociality, e.g., bees, wasps and ants. However, in hymenopteran insects, sterile male caste is only known in polyembryonic parasitic wasps. Male caste formation in these polyembryonic parasitoids has been reported well in the genus Copidosoma and other closely related Encyrtid genera12. These species produce larval soldiers in both sexes. A previous study using C. floridanum from North America has demonstrated that the female soldier larvae exhibit aggression toward conspecific and heterospecific competitors134, but the male soldiers are not aggressive at all5. These male soldiers are very similar to female soldiers in their structurally distinctive slender forms, but exhibit no defensive behaviors against the competitors. Thus, these male soldiers are identified as (or called) “nonfunctional soldiers.”

In the female brood, the production of female soldiers is explained by at least two functions (hypotheses): (1) the defense against heterospecific competitors, and (2) sex ratio adjustment in a mixed brood, where male embryos are attacked and killed by female soldiers to promote female biased sex ratios. The above two hypotheses are not exclusive each other. However, in the male brood, these hypotheses cannot be used because nonfunctional male soldiers neither attack heterospecific competitors, nor the own reproductive embryos in a mixed brood. One hypothesis for male soldiers is the sex-ratio conflict, in which the production of nonfunctional male soldiers promotes female biased sex-ratio at emergence in a mixed brood1456. This is a passive variation of the second sex-ratio hypothesis in female soldiers. However, this hypothesis cannot explain why the host resource is used for the nonfunctional male soldiers, instead of reducing the number of male reproductive embryos. Another hypothesis is the secondary loss of defensive behaviors in the course of evolution5. However, we currently have no enough data to support either hypothesis.

The previous studies of C. floridanum indicate that there are differences between the populations originated from the USA and Japan (we here call the USA and Japanese strains). In the USA strain, the development of soldier larvae differs between the sexes178. That is, female soldiers can be found in first-instar hosts, and then increase their number with host development up to two hundreds. In contrast, in males, only a few soldiers develop late in the host development. In contrast, in the Japanese strain, there is no sexual difference in soldier development9. That is, male and female eggs produce similar number of soldiers, in which soldier larvae of both sexes first appear at 1st or 2nd host instar and then increase their number up to more than one hundred. This sexual developmental difference between the USA and Japanese strains may reflect the differences of the functionality of male solders in these two strains. We suspect that male soldiers should have evolved to be functional at the first place (possibly the Japanese strain) and the USA strain might have lost its functionality. We therefore evaluate the functionality of male soldiers in the Japanese strain by in vitro contests and in vivo assessments. This finding should contribute to our questions on the evolution of male soldier castes: why they are very rare; why only found in polyembryonic wasps in hymenopteran insects.

Results

In vitro assay

In the Japanese strain of C. floridanum, in vitro contests revealed that the male soldiers exhibited aggressive behavior toward heterospecific parasitoid larvae, as in the female soldiers (Fig. 1). The in vitro contests revealed that soldiers of both sexes actively attacked the larvae of the other parasitoid species (Fig. 1A). The larvae being attacked all contracted their bodies and died within several minutes. Although both male and female soldiers exhibited aggressive behavior towards the larvae of potential parasitoid competitors, male soldiers are lower in attacking rates (Fig. 1B) and the time till attack is also longer (Table 1). For example, significantly fewer male soldiers attacked their opponents during the test period than female soldiers (against G. pallipes, male soldier = 51.6%; female soldier = 81.1%; χ = 6.7579, df = 1, P = 0.009, Fig. 1B(a); against C. ruficrus, male soldier = 30.6%; female soldiers = 66.7%; χ = 8.911, df = 1, p = 0.0028, Fig. 1B(b); against M. pulchricornis, male soldier = 52.0%; female soldier = 83.3%; χ = 4.703, df = 1, p = 0.0301, Fig. 1B(c); against C. glomerata, male soldier = 28.6%; female soldier = 81.8%; χ = 7.00, df = 1, p = 0.00005, Fig. 1B(d)).

Figure 1

Defense behavior of C. floridanum male soldier.

(A) A male soldier (white arrowhead) attacking a G. pallipes larva (black arrowhead). The image was obtained with a fluorescence microscope (BZ-9000, Keyence, Osaka, Japan). (B) Percentage of cumulative attacks by the soldiers of both sexes in in vitro contests with competitor parasitoid larvae: (a) G. pallipes, (b) C. ruficrus, (c) M. pulchricornis, (d) C. glomerata. female soldiers, male soldiers.

Table 1

The proportion of attacking C. floridanum individuals (%) and the time till initiating an attack (min) against four competitors in the in vitro competition experiment

Competitor	Sex of C. f.	No.	No. attacks (%)	χ2 test score p-value	Time till attack (min) (No. measured)	t-test score (df) p-value
G. pallipes	Male	29	15 (51.6) *	χ2 = 6.7579	265.5 ± 71.3(8)	t = 2.08(21)
	Female	30	25 (81.1)	p = 0.00933	189.3 ± 82.0(15)	P = 0.038
C. ruficrus	Male	49	15 (30.6)	χ2 = 8.9110	173.8 ± 94.3(15)	t = 2.08(28)
	Female	22	15 (68.1)	p = 0.00283	104.6 ± 56.1(15)	P = 0.023
M. pulchricornis	Male	27	14 (51.8)	χ2 = 4.703	191.3 ± 81.1(14)	t = 2.12(27)
	Female	18	15 (83.3)	p = 0.03011	91.9 ± 28.3(15)	p = 0.0003
C. glomerata	Male	49	14 (28.6)*	χ2 = 16.291	303.0 ± 45.3(12)	t = 2.05(25)
	Female	18	15 (83.3)	p = 0.00005	121.1 ± 74.8(15)	p = 0.0001

No. attacks indicates the number of individuals initiating attacking behavior in 6 hours in the total samples (No.). The differences of the number of attacking individuals between males and females of C. f. are tested by χ2 test (score and p-value are shown). In the time till attack, No. measured indicates the sample size. The time till attack between males and females of C. f. are tested by t-test (t-test score with degree of freedom and p-value are shown).

In all cases, the male soldiers required a longer time till attack (against G. pallipes, t = 2.08, df = 21, p = 0.038; C. ruficrus, t = 2.08, df = 22, p = 0.023; M. pulchricornis, t = 2.12, df = 16, p = 0.0003; C. glomerata, t = 2.05, df = 25, p = 0.0001).

These results indicated that C. floridanum soldiers of both sexes exhibited aggression towards heterospecific competitor larvae and eventually killed them. In addition, these results also suggested that male soldiers were less aggressive than female soldiers, because of their tendencies to attack less frequently.

In vivo contest

To validate that the aggressive behavior observed in vitro reflects the in vivo situation, we examined the competitive ability of both sexes against three natural parasitoids used for in vitro contests. When the hosts were multiparasitized by C. floridanum (the Japanese strain) and one of the natural parasitoids, adults of only one species emerged from each host. In all cases, C. floridanum adults were produced in significantly greater numbers than the other parasitoids (Table 2). Furthermore, there were no significant differences between the sexes of C. floridanum (Fisher's exact probability test, P = 0.1203 against G. pallipes, n = 100; P = 0.7479 against C. ruficrus, n = 100; P = 0.4945 against M. pulchricornis, n = 50), suggesting that both sexes of C. floridanum were competitively superior to the other natural parasitoids tested.

Table 2

Competitive ability of C. floridanum in singly and multi-parasitized hosts

		% of hosts producing
Competitor multiparasitized	Sex of C. floridanum	Cf	Gp	Cr	Mp	% host pupation	% host death
G. pallipes	Male	68.0a	20.0b			4.0	8.0
	Female	78.0a	12.0b			2.0	8.0
C. ruficrus	Male	80.0a		6.0b		2.0	12.0
	Female	76.0a		4.0b		0.0	20.0
M. pulchricornis	Male	34.0a			0.0b	0.0	66.0
	Female	36.0a			2.0b	0.0	62.0
C. floridanum alone	Male	86.0				8.0	6.0
	Female	88.0				10.0	2.0
G. pallipes alone			80.0			8.0	12.0
C. ruficrus alone				74.0		14.0	12.0
M. pulchricornis alone					56.0	0.0	44.0

Hosts were multiparasitized at 2nd instar. One hundred hosts (n = 100) were used for each experiment, except for the competition with M. pulchricornis (n = 50). Two types of statistical tests are performed: (1) two-tailed binomial test by F-distribution approximation for the superiority of C. floridanum (male or female) against each competitor, where a indicates significant at p = 0.00000 and (2) Fisher's exact probability test for the effects of C. floridanum (male or female) on the success of each competitor, where b indicates significant at p = 0.00000.

Field survey of sex ratios in mixed broods

The male ratios of mixed broods are extremely biased to females averaging less than 0.06 for all four years examined (Table 3).

Table 3

The sex ratio of mixed broods in C. floridanum collected in the field in Japan

Year	No. Broods	Average male ratio	Ranges of male ratio (max-min)
2003	20	0.031	0.049−0.008
2004	21	0.027	0.056−0.007
2005	26	0.057	0.132−0.002
2007	25	0.036	0.076−0.005

In each brood, 1000 adults are sexed. One-tailed binomial tests indicate that male ratios are significantly lower in each year at p = 0.00000.

Discussion

In vitro contests showed that the male soldiers of the Japanese strain exhibited aggressive behavior toward heterospecific parasitoid larvae, as in the female soldiers (Fig. 1, Table 1). This result coincided with the result of in vivo assessment (Table 2). These findings suggest that a functional sterile caste in larval males could have also developed as an adaptive response to competitors, as in larval females. The current result with the Japanese strain of C. floridanum is a sharp contrast to the report from the USA strain, in which male soldiers lack apparent adaptive function5.

The importance of this finding is that both functional and nonfunctional sterile male soldiers are found in C. floridanum, even though the difference in the functionality of male soldiers may not reflect the difference between the two geographical strains. Furtheremore, the current difference in male functionality between the two strains is also reflected in the developmental stages of male soldiers. The functional Japanese male soldiers are developed earlier in the host stages, while the nonfunctional USA male soldiers only so in later host stages. This fact strongly suggests the “secondary-loss hypothesis” of male functions5. In a closely related C. kohleri, in which only ca. 50 adults emerges from a single host, no male soldiers are produced10. The evolution of male soldiers may be limited by some ecological conditions, such as sex ratios and intraspecific competition11. The evolution of male functionality may be suppressed by intraspecific competition611.

We should also note that the developmental schedule of soldiers is likely to be genetically controlled. The number of male soldiers per host is a highly heritable trait and varies among clones12. The timing of emergence of the first soldier larvae that are specialized to attack conspecific competitors is also genetically determined13.

Our in vitro study also showed that there are sexual differences in the level of aggressiveness of soldiers. While the attack frequency increases with culture periods, those of female attacks are always considerably higher than those of males in all periods in all competitor species (Fig. 1B). In a related polyembryonic species Copidosoma bakeri, which produces mostly single-sex broods, the soldiers of both sex are shown to attack heterospecific parasitoid larvae2.

However, a C. floridanum female frequently lays one fertilized egg (being female wasps) and one unfertilized egg (being male wasps) in the same host. Furthermore, when one female lays only a fertilized (female) egg of a host, the second female tends to lay an unfertilized (male) egg on this host. In these mixed broods, only a few males always emerge from the host, but assure the copulations for all the emerging females from the same host1312. Thus the copulation success of both male and female wasps emerging from mixed broods is guaranteed. In these mixed broods, functional male soldiers become non-adaptive or even maladaptive, if they attack reproductive female embryos that are the future mates of their own male broods25. This problem of conspecific attack is evident in the Japanese strain, where there are functional male soldiers. In the USA strain, female soldiers discriminate relative and non-relative reproductive larva, reducing the attack rates against the relatives1. Unfortunately, we have no data regarding male soldier aggression toward relatives and non-relatives in Japan. Note that the proportion of mixed broods in the wild in Japan is over 50% (usually 60% or higher), and that the sex ratio is very female biased (Table 3), as in the USA. Therefore, in the Japanese strain, the attack against conspecific female embryos (irrespective of relatives or not) should be always damaging the success of male owns. One plausible explanation is that the density of heterospecific competitors is high in the Japanese strain. Therefore, the benefit to kill heterospecific competitors outweighs the cost of killing the conspecific female embryos. This may also explain why the USA strain lost the defensive behaviors in sterile males, if heterospecific competitors are rare. We thus need the comparative data on heterospecific competitors and detailed life histories of the Japanese and USA strains.

Because the aggressiveness of the Japanese male soldiers is still kept, but lower than that of females, the functional males may be an adaptive response of a single unfertilized egg in a single host larva. Therefore, we expect that female wasps often lay a single unfertilized egg in a single host in the Japanese strain.

The existence of both functional and nonfunctional male soldiers in C. floridanum therefore suggests that the evolution of adaptive functions in male soldiers is likely to be affected by ecological conditions or oviposition traits. The evolution of functional male soldiers should be favored under the following conditions: (1) presence of numerous heterospecific competitors with high parasitization rates, (2) high frequency of single egg broods (especially unfertilized eggs), (3) high densities of adult wasps, as this would increase the likelihood of finding mates. This last condition, in particular, may not be satisfied in the American Copidosoma strain, resulting in mixed-sex broods in host larvae.

In the Japanese strain, the number of male soldiers is entirely determined genetically, while the female soldiers are epigenetically affected by environmental conditions12. That is, the male soldiers are expected to be more subjected to the pressure of natural selection. Assuming that having functional soldiers of both sexes is the primitive state, it is possible that soldiers may have evolved first in the Japanese population as adaptation against competing parasitoids. After that, this ancestral Copidosoma spread to North America, where, in response to mating success in mixed broods, male soldier function may have been lost secondarily in American Copidosoma strain. Soldier larvae of C. floridanum are unique among polyembryonic parasitoid wasps in that the level of male functions varies among geographical strains. Further research into the ecological conditions and genetic variability will clarify the developmental process of the male soldiers.

Methods

Insects

The larvae of C. floridanum occur as two morphs; a reproductive larval morph and sterile soldier larval morph1415. The development and functions of both morphs have been well studied in Copidosoma floridanum (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae). C. floridanum is a polyembryonic egg-larval parasitoid that is widely distributed in Asia and North America16. In C. floridanum, a single egg develop into a morula, which then proliferates clonally in the growing host larva and eventually produces more than 2000 clonal embryos1517. Most of the embryos with germ cells develop into reproductive larvae in the final instar host larva, and eventually emerge as adult wasps. In addition to these embryos, a smaller number of embryos without germ cells develop precociously into structurally distinct slender larvae, which are referred to as soldier larvae13. Since the soldier larvae do not molt and finally die without pupating, they are completely sterile. C. floridanum produces clonal broods by laying either an unfertilised (haploid) egg that produces males or a fertilised (diploid) egg that produces females.

The polyembryonic parasitoid C. floridanum and its host Ctenoplusia ( = Acanthoplusia) agnata (Lepidoptera, Noctuidae) were collected in burdock fields in Tokyo, Japan, and maintained in the laboratory according to the methods described by Utsunomiya and Iwabuchi15. Natural parasitoid competitors of C. floridanum, Glyptapanteles pallipes (Braconidae), Cotesia ruficrus (Braconidae) and Meteorus pulchricornis (Braconidae) were also obtained from C. agnata larvae collected in the field in Tokyo and then reared together with a laboratory stock of C. agnata. G. pallipes and C. ruficrus are gregarious larval parasitoids of noctuid moths, and M. pulchricornis is a solitary larval parasitoid with an extremely wide host range. We also used Cotesia glomerata (Braconidae) as a factitious competitor of C. floridanum. Cotesia glomerata was obtained from the larvae of Pieris rapae collected in the field in Tokyo. Larvae (2nd instar) of Pieris rapae were presented to C. glomerata and the resultant parasitized hosts were maintained on an artificial diet.

In vitro assays were conducted in 35-mm plastic Petri dishes for six hours. One C. floridanum soldier larva from all-male (containing male soldiers) or all-female (containing female soldiers) was placed together with the 1st instar larva of a competitor species in a drop of 50 μl IPL-41 medium. As natural competitors, we used three larval parasitoids, G. pallipes, C. ruficrus and M. pulchricornis, which we obtained from larvae of the common host, C. agnata, collected in the field. As a factitious competitor, we used C. glomerata. The soldiers were continuously observed under a phase-contrast microscope during the assay period. If a soldier grasped a competitor larva with its mandibles for more than 1 min, then we recorded this as an aggressive behavior.

To determine whether the sex of C. floridanum affects the heterospecific competitive outcome, hosts were multiparasitized with each sex of C. floridanum and the other natural parasitoids. As in most hymenopteran species, unfertilized C. floridanum eggs produce males and fertilized eggs produce females. Since the oviposition behavior for unfertilized and fertilized eggs is different17, we were able to obtain single-sex broods derived from a single egg for each experiment. In the experiments, host eggs were parasitized by C. floridanum at 22–24 h post-oviposition. The parasitized hosts were then maintained until day 1 of the 2nd instar (L2D1), at which time they were allowed to be parasitized by other parasitoids. The multiparasitized hosts were then maintained until pupation, death or parasitoid emergence. One hundred hosts were used for each experiment, except for the competition with M. pulchricornis (n = 50).

To evaluate the effects of intraspecific competition on the resulting sex ratios in mixed broods, we conducted a field survey. For each mixed brood, we sexed one thousand emerging adults.

Author Contributions

D.U., J.Y. and K.I. conceived the study. D.U. and A.T.N. performed experiments, D.U., J.Y. and K.I. wrote the manuscript.