OBJECTIVE: Optimization of colposcopy practice requires a program of quality assurance including the monitoring of performance indicators. The European Federation of Colposcopy (EFC) aimed to identify a list of quality indicators for colposcopic practice, which are relevant, reproducible and practical across all of the member countries. STUDY DESIGN: A five-round Delphi consultation was conducted in 30 full, 5 associate and 4 potential member countries in order to determine a core list of quality indicators including optimal target ranges. RESULTS: Six indicators were selected from a list of 37 proposed standards. Two further rounds of consultation were conducted to determine expert opinion on the target level for each of the standards. The six indicators identified and corresponding targets were: documentation of whether or not the squamocolumnar junction has been seen (100%); colposcopy prior to treatment for abnormal cervical cytology (100%); percentage of excisional treatments/conizations to contain cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia grade two or worse (≥85%); percentage of excised lesions/conizations with clear margins (≥80%); and two indicators concerned the number of cases to be colposcoped per year: ≥50 low-grade/minor and ≥50 high-grade/major cytological abnormalities. CONCLUSIONS: A Delphi consultation identified six EFC quality indicators. These are a first step in an international attempt to optimize colposcopy practice throughout Europe. The current targets are based on expert opinion and may need adaptation in the future. Data are needed from European colposcopy settings to determine whether the indicators are achievable practice-based benchmarks and will help in improving and fine tuning the list of performance indicators and targets.
OBJECTIVE: Optimization of colposcopy practice requires a program of quality assurance including the monitoring of performance indicators. The European Federation of Colposcopy (EFC) aimed to identify a list of quality indicators for colposcopic practice, which are relevant, reproducible and practical across all of the member countries. STUDY DESIGN: A five-round Delphi consultation was conducted in 30 full, 5 associate and 4 potential member countries in order to determine a core list of quality indicators including optimal target ranges. RESULTS: Six indicators were selected from a list of 37 proposed standards. Two further rounds of consultation were conducted to determine expert opinion on the target level for each of the standards. The six indicators identified and corresponding targets were: documentation of whether or not the squamocolumnar junction has been seen (100%); colposcopy prior to treatment for abnormal cervical cytology (100%); percentage of excisional treatments/conizations to contain cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia grade two or worse (≥85%); percentage of excised lesions/conizations with clear margins (≥80%); and two indicators concerned the number of cases to be colposcoped per year: ≥50 low-grade/minor and ≥50 high-grade/major cytological abnormalities. CONCLUSIONS: A Delphi consultation identified six EFC quality indicators. These are a first step in an international attempt to optimize colposcopy practice throughout Europe. The current targets are based on expert opinion and may need adaptation in the future. Data are needed from European colposcopy settings to determine whether the indicators are achievable practice-based benchmarks and will help in improving and fine tuning the list of performance indicators and targets.
Authors: Edward J Mayeaux; Akiva P Novetsky; David Chelmow; Francisco Garcia; Kim Choma; Angela H Liu; Theognosia Papasozomenos; Mark H Einstein; L Stewart Massad; Nicolas Wentzensen; Alan G Waxman; Christine Conageski; Michelle J Khan; Warner K Huh Journal: J Low Genit Tract Dis Date: 2017-10 Impact factor: 1.925