Where are We Now with Decompressive Hemicraniectomy for Malignant Middle Cerebral Artery Infarction?

In spite of the best medical treatment, large hemispheric infarction, resulting from acute occlusion of either the internal carotid or the proximal middle cerebral artery with insufficient collateral blood flow is associated with a high case fatality rate of approximately 60%. Thus, a decompressive hemicraniectomy is considered a life-saving procedure for this devastating disease. Findings of three recent randomized, controlled clinical trials and their meta-analysis showed that early surgical decompression not only reduced the number of case fatalities but also increased the incidence of favorable outcomes. The authors review the pathophysiology, historical background in previous studies, operative timing, surgical technique and clinical outcomes of surgical decompression for malignant hemispheric infarction.

INTRODUCTION

When patients present with acute occlusion of either the internal carotid artery (ICA) or the proximal middle cerebral artery (MCA) within the therapeutic time window for restoration of cerebral blood flow, rapid recanalization using intravenous/intra-arterial (IA) thrombolysis and IA mechanical embolectomy is the goal of acute stroke management.11) However, if the patient presents beyond the therapeutic time window, life-threatening brain swelling and herniation, known as malignant MCA infarction, can manifest within one week after the onset of stroke symptoms, along with a further decrease of consciousness and pupillary dilatation, necessitating early application of a decompressive hemicraniectomy for achievement of a better clinical outcome.24)

The present article reviews the pathophysiology, historical background in previous studies, operative timing, surgical technique and clinical outcomes of decompressive hemicraniectomy for malignant MCA infarction involving the MCA territory with or without anterior cerebral artery and posterior cerebral artery territories.

PATHOPHYSIOLOGY

Acute occlusion of either the ICA or the proximal MCA and insufficient collateral blood flow result in cerebral infarction of the MCA territory and associated severe brain edema. Cytotoxic edema results from failure of sodium-potassium adenosine triphosphatase in brain cell membranes and is followed by vasogenic edema in association with disruption of the blood-brain barrier.

The space-occupying lesion inside the cranial vault increases the intracranial pressure, thereby reducing the cerebral perfusion pressure and cerebral blood flow. In particular, a space-occupying lesion in a unilateral hemisphere causes pressure gradients between the supratentorial and infratentorial compartments and between the bilateral supratentorial compartments. These pressure gradients then lead to transtentorial and subfalcine herniations. The transtentorial uncal herniation and the resultant displacement of the subthalamic-upper brainstem structures will impair the consciousness of the patient.

Thus, the aim of decompressive surgery is external herniation of the swollen infarcted brain for relief of brainstem compression and to reduce intracranial pressure.

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND

The original purpose of decompressive hemicraniectomy was to help patients survive in cases of acute large hemispheric infarction.25) Various case reports, retrospective studies and trials have suggested that this surgical treatment lowers mortality without increasing the incidence of severely disabled survivors.8)13)15)23)27)29) Three European randomized, controlled clinical trials were conducted between 2001 and 2007.10)12)32) However, the DECIMAL (DEcompressive Craniectomy In MALignant middle cerebral artery infarction) trial in France and DESTINY (DEcompressive Surgery for the Treatment of malignant INfarction of the middle cerebral arterY) trial in Germany were stopped due to slow recruitment of cases and significant difference in mortality between groups.12)32)

Notwithstanding, the HAMLET (Hemicraniectomy After Middle cerebral artery infarction with Life-threatening Edema Trial) study, conducted in the Netherlands, was completed and published in 2009.10) Thirty two patients were randomly assigned to undergo surgical decompression and another 32 patients received the best medical treatment over a five-year period. According to the results, the use of hemicraniectomy resulted in a reduction in the number of case fatalities and poor outcomes (modified Rankin Scale score 5) for patients with large hemispheric infarction who were treated within 48 hours of stroke onset.

OPERATING TIMING

The clinical outcome for patients is considered to show improvement with early surgical decompression before or immediately after any neurological deterioration related to brain swelling.10)22)26)28)31)33)36) This clinical deterioration includes pupil asymmetry, an altered consciousness level and aggravated hemiplegia.6)

Patients commonly manifest such neurological deterioration within one week after the onset of stroke symptoms. In particular, one third of patients show deterioration within 24 hours, while another third show deterioration 24 - 48 hours after symptom onset.24)

To date, many clinical and radiological data defining early predictors of malignant hemispheric infarction have been reported.6)7)9)14)16)18)20)30)34) Malignant edema after acute infarction can be predicted based on the volume of the infarcted brain tissue, however, extension of the initial infarct territory, delayed spontaneous recanalization of the occluded vessel, hemorrhagic transformation of the infarcted brain and the fluid volume state of the patient can all make the prediction difficult. Thus, the predictors lack a sufficient predictive value with regard to selection of candidates for a decompressive hemicraniectomy prior to neurological deterioration. In addition, in order to ensure timely decompressive surgery, all patients with acute large hemispheric infarction should be observed in an intensive care unit or stroke unit setting. Thus, determination of strict cutoff criteria with a high specificity and positive predictive value for malignant infarction is needed.21)

The predictive value of the infarct volume assessed by early CT scan after stroke onset has not been found to be satisfactory, as follows: (1) hypodensity covering > 50% of MCA territory within five hours after symptom onset was predictive of a malignant course with a sensitivity of 61% and specificity of 94%;34) (2) hypodensity covering > 50% of MCA territory within 12 hours was predictive with a sensitivity of 64% and specificity of 66%;17) (3) hypodensity covering > 50% and 67% of MCA territory within 18 hours was predictive with a sensitivity of 58% and 45%, respectively and specificity of 94% and 100%, respectively.7)

One useful predictor is the initial infarct volume assessed using diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance (MR) imaging > 145 cm3 within 14 hours after acute MCA occlusion, which achieved a sensitivity of 100% and a specificity of 94% in the study by Oppenheim et al.20)

The cutoff criteria for lesion volume and associated midline brain shift for prediction of malignant edema should differ according to the timing after stroke onset.4)21) Gerriets et al. reported a midline shift ≥ 2.5, 3.5, 4.0 and 5.0 mm in transcranial color-coded duplex sonography as a predictor of malignant edema after 16, 24, 32 and 40 hours, respectively, after stroke onset with a specificity of 100% and positive predictive value of 100%.4)

Meanwhile, assessment of the final infarct volume can be performed using perfusion CT or perfusion MR images on admission, however, such perfusion parameters are still not optimal.3)30) In the MR perfusion study reported by Thomalla et al., perfusion lesion volume > 162 mL on a time-to-peak (TTP) map with a TTP delay threshold of > 4 seconds was found to predict malignant infarction with a sensitivity of 83% and specificity of 75%.30)

SURGICAL TECHNIQUE

Conceptually, decompressive craniectomy procedures include both internal and external decompression. In the case of external decompression, the frontal, temporal and parietal bones overlying the infarcted hemisphere are removed, allowing for external herniation of the swollen infarcted brain.

With the patient in a state of general anesthesia, a skin incision is started just above the zygomatic arch 0.5 cm anterior to the tragus and then carried superiorly and posteriorly over the ear and around the parietal bone to the contralateral frontal midpupillary line. The hemicraniectomy then involves the removal of a large fronto-temporo-parietal bone flap, as large as possible. The craniectomy is limited by the following boundaries. The bone flap is made anteriorly in order to avoid violation of the frontal sinus, except in the case of a huge frontal sinus. The medial limit is 2 cm from the midline, in order to minimize venous bleeding on the dura. The posterior limit of the bone flap is approximately 5 - 6 cm posterior to the external auditory canal, thereby covering the MCA territory posteriorly and allowing for a neutral head position without compressing the brain. Inferiorly, the temporal squama is removed to the level of the zygomatic arch.

Following a stellate-shaped dural incision, it is commonly recommended that the infarcted brain tissue not be removed due to the presence of a salvageable penumbra area or viable tissue.10)12)32) However, the internal decompression (removal of the infracted brain tissue and/or an anterior temporal lobectomy) can be performed for patients with whole hemispheric infarction.19) Expansive duraplasty is then performed using a large flap of pericranial tissue or an artificial dura substitute. The dimensions of the expansive duraplasty should be extended in order to accommodate the subsequent aggravation of the brain edema.

Meticulous hemostasis is critical for prevention of a postoperative epidural hematoma. Multiple dural tenting sutures, bipolar coagulation of bleeding points on the dural surface, application of commercial hemostatic materials and placement of a closed suction drain in the epidural/subgaleal space are all used.

Finally, the temporalis muscle and skin flap are reapproximated and sutured layer by layer. However, the temporalis muscle and fascia can be resected in order to maximize external herniation of the swollen brain. Removal of the temporalis muscle does not cause problems with chewing, as the grinding phase of the closure stroke only requires one-third of the maximal bite force and only leads to a minimal decrease in the maximal bite force.1)5) Resection of the temporalis muscle and fascia provides a two-fold volume expansion on average when compared with the conventional technique on postoperative day 3 (Fig. 1).22)

Fig. 1

Computed tomography (CT) scans taken before and after decompressive surgery, including a hemicraniectomy with resection of the temporalis muscle and fascia for acute middle cerebral artery (MCA) infarction. (A) Preoperative CT scan taken 20 hours after stroke onset shows an MCA territory infarction with a significant midline brain shift. (B) On postoperative CT scan one day after decompressive surgery, the craniectomy covers the whole MCA territory without any epidural/subgaleal hematoma and completely relieves the midline brain shift. (C) On postoperative CT scan three days after decompressive surgery, the overlying scalp successfully accommodates the aggravated brain swelling.

Technical obstacles to obtaining the best external decompression are an insufficient craniectomy size, epidural/subgaleal hematoma, thick and swollen temporalis muscle, tough and inelastic temporalis fascia and tight scalp.2)22)35) Making hemicraniectomy as large as possible, meticulous hemostasis and resection of the temporalis muscle and fascia will all maximize external herniation of the infarcted brain.

The bone flap is stored in a tissue bank (< 70℃). Cranioplasty is then performed using the autogenous bone flap two to three months after the craniectomy.

OUTCOMES OF HEMICRANIECTOMY

After decompressive surgery for malignant MCA infarction, clinical outcomes at 6-12 months after stroke onset have been reported. For the criteria determining favorable and unfavorable outcomes, a dichotomization of the mRS score between 0-3 and 4 to death or between 0-4 and 5 to death has been used; however, an mRS score of 0-3 is most appropriate for a favorable outcome as it includes independent functional outcomes.

In the HAMLET study, the patients were randomly assigned to undergo surgical decompression or to receive the best medical treatment within four days of stroke onset.10) The decompressive-surgery group had a lower incidence of mortality (22% versus 59%) and mRS 5-6 (41% versus 59%) than the group that received the best medical treatment. However, the incidence of patients with mRS of 0-3 did not differ between the two groups (25% versus 25%).

Results of a pooled analysis of the three European randomized controlled trials indicated a better clinical outcome than that of the HAMLET study.31) Performance of decompressive surgery within 48 hours of stroke onset resulted in reduced mortality and an increase in the number of patients who had a favorable functional outcome. In addition, more patients in the decompressive-surgery group had mRS 0-3 (43% versus 21%) and mRS 0-4 (75% versus 24%) compared with those in the control group who received the best medical treatment.

In analysis of the three predefined subgroups of the DECIMAL trial, in the decompressive-surgery group, younger age showed correlation with a favorable outcome and there was a trend toward a worse outcome in patients with higher infarct volumes.32) However, no significant difference in the clinical outcome with mRS scores was observed between surviving patients with dominant and non-dominant hemisphere infarction.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with malignant hemispheric infarction, decompressive surgery can reduce the number of cases of fatality and increase the number of favorable outcomes. In particular, if a decompressive hemicraniectomy is performed early, before irreversible cerebral herniation, using appropriate surgical techniques, favorable outcomes with functional independence can be achieved in a high proportion of patients.