IMPORTANCE: National recommendations for the prevention and treatment of obesity emphasize reducing energy intake through self-monitoring food consumption. However, little information is available on the energy content of foods offered by nonchain restaurants, which account for approximately 50% of restaurant locations in the United States. OBJECTIVE: To measure the energy content of foods from independent and small-chain restaurants that do not provide stated information on energy content. DESIGN: We used bomb calorimetry to determine the dietary energy content of the 42 most frequently purchased meals from the 9 most common restaurant categories. Independent and small-chain restaurants were randomly selected, and 157 individual meals were analyzed. SETTING: Area within 15 miles of downtown Boston. PARTICIPANTS: A random sample of independent and small-chain restaurants. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Dietary energy. RESULTS: All meal categories provided excessive dietary energy. The mean energy content of individual meals was 1327 (95% CI, 1248-1406) kcal, equivalent to 66% of typical daily energy requirements. We found a significant effect of food category on meal energy (P ≤ .05), and 7.6% of meals provided more than 100% of typical daily energy requirements. Within-meal variability was large (average SD, 271 kcal), and we found no significant effect of restaurant establishment or size. In addition, meal energy content averaged 49% greater than those of popular meals from the largest national chain restaurants (P < .001) and in subset analyses contained 19% more energy than national food database information for directly equivalent items (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: National chain restaurants have been criticized for offering meals with excess dietary energy. This study finds that independent and small-chain restaurants, which provide no nutrition information, also provide excessive dietary energy in amounts apparently greater than popular meals from chain restaurants or information in national food databases. A national requirement for accurate calorie labeling in all restaurants may discourage menus offering unhealthy portions and would allow consumers to make informed choices about ordering meals that promote weight gain and obesity.
IMPORTANCE: National recommendations for the prevention and treatment of obesity emphasize reducing energy intake through self-monitoring food consumption. However, little information is available on the energy content of foods offered by nonchain restaurants, which account for approximately 50% of restaurant locations in the United States. OBJECTIVE: To measure the energy content of foods from independent and small-chain restaurants that do not provide stated information on energy content. DESIGN: We used bomb calorimetry to determine the dietary energy content of the 42 most frequently purchased meals from the 9 most common restaurant categories. Independent and small-chain restaurants were randomly selected, and 157 individual meals were analyzed. SETTING: Area within 15 miles of downtown Boston. PARTICIPANTS: A random sample of independent and small-chain restaurants. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Dietary energy. RESULTS: All meal categories provided excessive dietary energy. The mean energy content of individual meals was 1327 (95% CI, 1248-1406) kcal, equivalent to 66% of typical daily energy requirements. We found a significant effect of food category on meal energy (P ≤ .05), and 7.6% of meals provided more than 100% of typical daily energy requirements. Within-meal variability was large (average SD, 271 kcal), and we found no significant effect of restaurant establishment or size. In addition, meal energy content averaged 49% greater than those of popular meals from the largest national chain restaurants (P < .001) and in subset analyses contained 19% more energy than national food database information for directly equivalent items (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: National chain restaurants have been criticized for offering meals with excess dietary energy. This study finds that independent and small-chain restaurants, which provide no nutrition information, also provide excessive dietary energy in amounts apparently greater than popular meals from chain restaurants or information in national food databases. A national requirement for accurate calorie labeling in all restaurants may discourage menus offering unhealthy portions and would allow consumers to make informed choices about ordering meals that promote weight gain and obesity.
Authors: Jessie Gruner; Robin S DeWeese; Cori Lorts; Michael J Yedidia; Punam Ohri-Vachaspati Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2017-12-21 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Lorien E Urban; Judith L Weber; Melvin B Heyman; Rachel L Schichtl; Sofia Verstraete; Nina S Lowery; Sai Krupa Das; Molly M Schleicher; Gail Rogers; Christina Economos; William A Masters; Susan B Roberts Journal: J Acad Nutr Diet Date: 2016-01-20 Impact factor: 4.910
Authors: Louis Goffe; Stephen Rushton; Martin White; Ashley Adamson; Jean Adams Journal: Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act Date: 2017-09-22 Impact factor: 6.457
Authors: Susan B Roberts; Sai Krupa Das; Vivian Marques Miguel Suen; Jussi Pihlajamäki; Rebecca Kuriyan; Matilda Steiner-Asiedu; Amy Taetzsch; Alex K Anderson; Rachel E Silver; Kathryn Barger; Amy Krauss; Leila Karhunen; Xueying Zhang; Catherine Hambly; Ursula Schwab; Andresa de Toledo Triffoni-Melo; Salima F Taylor; Christina Economos; Anura V Kurpad; John R Speakman Journal: BMJ Date: 2018-12-12