Parallels in amphibian and bat declines from pathogenic fungi.

Pathogenic fungi have substantial effects on global biodiversity, and 2 emerging pathogenic species-the chytridiomycete Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis, which causes chytridiomycosis in amphibians, and the ascomycete Geomyces destructans, which causes white-nose syndrome in hibernating bats-are implicated in the widespread decline of their vertebrate hosts. We synthesized current knowledge for chytridiomycosis and white-nose syndrome regarding disease emergence, environmental reservoirs, life history characteristics of the host, and host-pathogen interactions. We found striking similarities between these aspects of chytridiomycosis and white-nose syndrome, and the research that we review and propose should help guide management of future emerging fungal diseases.

Fungi and fungus-like organisms have been recognized historically as prominent plant pathogens that can have detrimental effects on agricultural crops and wild flora (,). Fisher et al. () recently reviewed the increasing role and recognition of pathogenic fungi that affect global biodiversity. Their analyses showed that most (91%) recent extinctions and extirpations caused by fungal disease have affected animals rather than plants. In particular, 2 emerging pathogenic fungi—the chytridiomycete Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis, which causes chytridiomycosis in amphibians (,), and the ascomycete Geomyces destructans, which causes white-nose syndrome (WNS) in hibernating bats ()—are implicated in the widespread decline of their vertebrate hosts. In general, increased global biosecurity and monitoring are recommended to prevent and manage emerging fungal diseases (), but there are also pressing research needs that can help specifically address these 2 devastating pathogenic fungi. We call attention to parallels between chytridiomycosis and WNS and highlight areas where urgent research is required (Table). Comparison of these diseases also illustrates broader themes and questions that can be used to direct research on future emerging fungal diseases.

Table

Current knowledge and unresolved research questions regarding the pathogenic fungi Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis and Geomyces destructans, the causative agents of chytridiomycosis and WNS, respectively*

Area of knowledge	B. dendrobatidis			G. destructans
	Current knowledge	Unresolved research questions		Current knowledge	Unresolved research questions
Disease emergence	Multiple regions of endemism and 1 widely introduced hypervirulent lineage (7–9)	How and from where did the hypervirulent lineage emerge?		Limited genetic differentiation in North America (10)	How do strains from North America and Europe compare genetically, and is genetic variation greater in Europe, suggesting historic endemism?
				Possibly endemic to Europe and introduced to North America (6,11,12)
Abiotic reservoirs	Can survive in water and soil (13,14)	Can B. dendrobatidis form desiccation-resistant resting spores? Can B. dendrobatidis survive and reproduce as a saprophytic, nonparasitic form?		Apparent persistence in soils and on cave walls (12,15)	How widespread is G. destructans in the environment? Can G. destructans survive and reproduce as a saprophytic, nonparasitic form?
Biotic reservoirs	Host generalist pathogen of amphibians (4,5)	Can B. dendrobatidis complete its life cycle on other vertebrate hosts?		Host generalist pathogen of bats (6)	Can G. destructans infect or persist on other vertebrates?
	Can also infect reptiles, nematodes, and waterfowl (16–18)
Life history and infection risk of the host	Aquatic, biphasic, tropical amphibian species at greatest risk for chytridiomycosis (19)	To what extent can life history characteristics of the host predict global patterns of disease-related population decline among amphibian species?		Bat species that hibernate experience most deaths from WNS (20)	Are only those species that hibernate susceptible to population decline from WNS? What role does life history of the host play in predicting species declines and extinctions from WNS?
Host–pathogen interactions	Antimicrobial peptides and antifungal metabolites from skin-associated bacteria contribute to B. dendrobatidis resistance (21)	What is the immune response of B. dendrobatidis–tolerant hosts to infection?		Host immune down-regulation during hibernation probably important to WNS progression (24)	What is the host immune response to G. destructans infection?
	Susceptible species appear to show little innate or adaptive immune response to B. dendrobatidis infection (22,23)	Does B. dendrobatidis evade the amphibian immune system through activity of secreted proteases?			How does host immunity vary seasonally? What role does immune function play in the observed winter season/hibernation mortality from WNS? Do proteases contribute to pathogenicity of G. destructans?

*WNS, white-nose syndrome.

Disease Emergence

Effective control of any disease requires understanding of the processes that have resulted in its emergence. The study of a pathogen’s geographic origin and phylogenetic history often provides critical insight in this regard. In general, infectious diseases can emerge from 2 distinct scenarios: 1) the geographic spread of a novel pathogen into a new area with naive hosts or 2) a shift in pathogenicity or host specificity of an endemic pathogen as a result of environmental changes that alter host–pathogen interactions (). Current evidence predominantly suggests that chytridiomycosis and WNS outbreaks are driven by anthropogenic transport of novel pathogenic fungi into new geographic regions.

As chytridiomycosis began emerging globally, it was initially unclear whether B. dendrobatidis was newly introduced in regions affected by chytridiomycosis or whether it was globally endemic and had recently increased in pathogenicity as a result of environmental degradation or climate change (,,). Spatiotemporal patterns of declines in amphibian populations from chytridiomycosis and population genetics data on B. dendrobatidis provide increasing evidence that the pathogen has been recently introduced in many areas (,). Wave-like patterns of amphibian deaths from chytridiomycosis have been documented at multiple sites globally, and these spatiotemporal dynamics suggest that B. dendrobatidis behaves as a novel pathogen spreading geographically through naive host populations (). In addition, B. dendrobatidis strains isolated from across the world have low levels of genetic diversity, consistent with a pathogen that has recently undergone rapid range expansion (,).

In early research, Africa was proposed as the place of origin for B. dendrobatidis, and the African clawed frog (Xenopus laevis), which is not susceptible to chytridiomycosis, was thought to be a primary carrier responsible for global dispersal of B. dendrobatidis out of Africa (). This amphibian species was used in human pregnancy assays beginning in the mid-1930s and later became a widely used biological model. On the basis of museum evidence that some African clawed frogs were infected with B. dendrobatidis in the late 1930s, Weldon et al. () hypothesized that global demand for the species resulted in the spread of B. dendrobatidis out of Africa to other areas where it subsequently became established in native, naive wild populations. Amphibian species in pet stores, zoos, museums, and the food market are now known to carry B. dendrobatidis infections (,,), and the international trade of amphibians is thought to be a major factor driving the spread of B. dendrobatidis, with other key carrier species, such as the North American bullfrog (Lithobates catesbeianus), contributing to the pathogen’s global invasion (,,,,).

The leading hypothesis, based on population genomic evidence, posits that a single hypervirulent B. dendrobatidis lineage is largely responsible for global chytridiomycosis-related amphibian declines and that the emergence of this lineage likely resulted from anthropogenic pathogen transport (). Anthropogenic activity might have helped generate this hypervirulent strain by promoting fungal lineage mixing. Lineage mixing enables distantly related pathogen strains to outbreed, and this process can result in the emergence of novel, virulent genotypes that spread rapidly through susceptible host populations, as appears to have occurred with chytridiomycosis ().

Studies of population genetics have contributed substantially to our understanding of B. dendrobatidis as a novel pathogen in regions affected by chytridiomycosis; however, wider global sampling and phylogenetic analysis of the fungus is needed (Table). Africa remains a critical region for the study of endemic B. dendrobatidis diversity, but research on strains isolated worldwide suggests that other strains also are endemic to Eurasia (–). Although these endemic strains might play a relatively small role in the global decline of amphibian populations, further study and broader sampling of B. dendrobatidis can improve our understanding of its phylogenetic history and shed light on the possible contributions of lineage mixing and genetic variation to pathogenicity.

Our ability to accurately reconstruct B. dendrobatidis phylogeny is hampered by the limited number of B. dendrobatidis samples collected from species other than those susceptible to chytridiomycosis. As a result, additional cryptic, endemic lineages may remain overlooked or undersampled because they are associated with B. dendrobatidis–tolerant hosts (,), and environmental reservoirs could represent another source of undiscovered pathogen diversity. The global distribution of B. dendrobatidis before chytridiomycosis emergence and the geographic origin of the hypervirulent lineage remain uncertain (), but both African () and Japanese () amphibian species appear to have been asymptomatic B. dendrobatidis hosts decades before amphibian declines were reported in other regions.

The origin of G. destructans and processes resulting in WNS emergence are unresolved. Bats in Europe are known to carry G. destructans asymptomatically, which has led to speculation that G. destructans was introduced from the Old World to susceptible North American bats, probably through human transport (,). Genetic markers show no differentiation among North American G. destructans samples collected across the expanding area of WNS, suggesting that G. destructans was recently introduced and is spreading rapidly through North America (). Furthermore, the first observation of WNS in North America occurred in a cave that had high levels of tourism, providing circumstantial evidence for a link between human activity and G. destructans introduction (). Although no global population genomic study has been conducted for G. destructans, the possibility that lineage mixing and recombination among fungal strains has contributed to WNS outbreaks is intriguing. In a laboratory study, North American bats died when infected with North American or European strains of G. destructans (). These results were interpreted as further indirect evidence that G. destructans is novel to North America. However, recent sampling suggests that bat hibernacula host a diversity of previously uncharacterized Geomyces spp (), and given our limited understanding of the global distribution of G. destructans strains and their phylogenetic relationships (), it remains possible that G. destructans is endemic to North America. The distribution of G. destructans lineages in North America, similar to B. dendrobatidis distribution in some parts of Asia (,), might therefore include endemic, avirulent fungal strains in addition to recently introduced, potentially more virulent lineages. Currently, however, the lack of evidence for G. destructans presence in North America outside of WNS-affected areas supports the hypothesis that the fungus is indeed novel to this region (). As with B. dendrobatidis, firm conclusions regarding the geographic origins of G. destructans await a much broader global sampling of G. destructans combined with fine-scale population genetic analyses of highly polymorphic markers (Table) ().

Environmental Reservoirs

Theoretical work suggests that if environmental reservoirs (abiotic substrates or alternative biotic hosts that enable pathogen persistence) exist, diseases can have serious population-level effects on host species and even precipitate host extinction (). The existence of multiple hosts can buffer a pathogen against population fluctuations in focal host species, and tolerant species may therefore increase pathogen burden for susceptible species by supporting high pathogen densities. Abiotic reservoirs also enable pathogen persistence when suitable vertebrate hosts are rare or absent, which also may increase pathogen burden for susceptible species. For example, mathematical models show that the risk for host extinction from chytridiomycosis increases when fungal zoospores have long residence time in the environment or if B. dendrobatidis can reproduce apart from amphibian hosts (). Because of their effects on disease dynamics, recognition of the full range of environmental reservoirs is essential for effective management of any emerging disease.

There is strong reason to suspect that B. dendrobatidis and G. destructans have environmental reservoirs. In general, fungi may be unique pathogens because many can persist in the environment apart from animal hosts, yet environmental pressures can select for fungal traits that contribute to virulence during infection of certain host organisms (). Fungi in the phylum Chytridiomycota have a nearly global distribution and occupy roles as heterotrophs and saprobes in water and soil (). Similarly, multiple species of Geomyces are saprophytic (). Given the ecologic characteristics of their broader taxonomic groups, it is perhaps unsurprising that environmental sampling is now revealing a variety of reservoirs for B. dendrobatidis and G. destructans.

Further work is needed to fully characterize the abiotic reservoirs of both pathogens (Table). As an aquatic fungus, B. dendrobatidis can survive in various aqueous media for several weeks () and may grow in moist soil (). Although these laboratory studies demonstrate the range of conditions under which B. dendrobatidis might occur, patterns of fungal persistence in natural environments are yet to be studied intensively. In addition, Di Rosa et al. () have suggested that B. dendrobatidis may exist as a stress-tolerant resting spore, representing another abiotic reservoir for the fungus. However, whether the structure in question is in fact an alternate life stage of B. dendrobatidis remains unclear (). Environmental distribution of G. destructans also is poorly understood, but the pathogen has been detected in soil samples (), and viable spores have been collected from cave walls in bat hibernacula (), both factors that suggest the fungus has abiotic reservoirs.

Chytridiomycosis and WNS are caused by host-generalist pathogens that have multiple biotic reservoirs. B. dendrobatidis infects hundreds of amphibian species globally (,). In North America, WNS has spread among 9 bat species (). Although research has predominately focused on the prevalence of B. dendrobatidis and G. destructans in taxa negatively affected by those pathogens (amphibians and bats, respectively), wider sampling of these fungi is warranted (Table). For example, despite more than a decade of B. dendrobatidis–related research, it was only recently discovered that the fungus may infect reptiles without causing disease (). Furthermore, experimental B. dendrobatidis infections can lead to death of nematodes, although whether these organisms frequently serve as hosts for B. dendrobatidis in the wild is unclear (). B. dendrobatidis has also recently been found on migratory waterfowl and may be carried among bodies of water by the infected keratinized feet and webbings of such birds (). Whether bats are the only vertebrates capable of hosting G. destructans remains to be seen. Raccoons, bears, rodents, or other mammals that frequent cave systems where G. destructans is present are the most likely candidates to serve as alternative hosts (Table). Mammalian species that experience lowered body temperatures during winter torpor or hibernation may warrant particular attention, given G. destructans’s preference for psychrophilic growth (,).

Life History Characteristics and Infection Risk of the Host

Host life history characteristics can play a critical role in determining infection risk, and some amphibians and bats appear to be susceptible to pathogenic fungi in part because of their life histories. Amphibians often reach high population densities and have increased contact rates when breeding at aquatic sites; both factors promote pathogen transmission (). Amphibians also may have intraspecific host reservoirs because of their complex life histories (i.e., aquatic larvae experience persistent sublethal infections and expose terrestrial adults that visit aquatic sites), enabling pathogen persistence within amphibian populations (). Many amphibians undergo immune suppression during metamorphosis, increasing their infection risk during this life stage (). These factors probably explain, in part, the results of a study from Central America that found amphibian species that were highly aquatic were those most likely to suffer B. dendrobatidis–related population declines or extirpations (). Analyses of amphibian communities in other regions are needed to determine whether life history characteristics of the host are broadly useful in predicting global chytridiomycosis-associated declines in amphibian populations (Table).

Just as some amphibian species are particularly susceptible to chytridiomycosis because of their life histories, the species of North American bats that are affected by WNS have life history characteristics that similarly predispose them to disease outbreaks. Bat populations in North America that are declining from WNS are known to breed, roost, and hibernate communally in large aggregations in cave systems where increased densities and contact between bats can facilitate pathogen transmission (,). There is speculation that if host density during hibernation influences WNS severity, this life history attribute may help explain the lack of WNS in Europe, where bat species typically form smaller hibernation aggregations than in North America (). Bats in warm Mediterranean regions of Europe that have short hibernation periods appear to be free of G. destructans (), which further supports a role for host life history in mediating pathogen transmission. In addition, the down-regulation of immune function in bats during hibernation () is roughly analogous to the immune suppression that occurs during amphibian metamorphosis, a trait that seems to be linked to increased infection susceptibility (). WNS emerged in the northeastern United States but is rapidly spreading southwestward toward regions of high bat species richness where many species do not hibernate. Whether those species in the southwestern United States that do not hibernate will be at risk for WNS is unclear (). To best predict infection risk and effectively manage amphibian and bat diversity, the degree to which life history and ecologic variation among hosts influence disease susceptibility needs to be better understood (Table). In this regard, broad epidemiologic studies and analyses of incoming reports and publications could yield key insights.

Host–Pathogen Interactions

The pathologies of chytridiomycosis and WNS are broadly similar in that both diseases result from infection by dermatophyte fungi that can severely disrupt host physiology (,,,). Amphibian skin plays a major role in physiologic regulation, and B. dendrobatidis infection of this tissue causes electrolyte imbalance in host individuals that ultimately leads to death from cardiac arrest (). In bats, WNS results in death by increasing arousal frequency during hibernation, which depletes bat energy reserves (). These behavioral changes in bats may ultimately be a reaction to the disruption of physiologic processes, including water balance, gas exchange, and thermoregulation caused by G. destructans infection of the wing membrane structure (). However, in amphibians and bats, considerable interspecific variation exists in disease-related illness and death from these fungal infections (–). One unresolved question for both chytridiomycosis and WNS is the degree to which interspecific differences in host–pathogen interactions underlie variation in disease outcome.

Some evidence indicates that host defenses mediate species-specific responses to chytridiomycosis and WNS. In amphibians, basic physiologic and anatomic traits that vary among species, such as skin sloughing rate and skin thickness, could provide innate defenses against the keratinophilic activity of B. dendrobatidis (,). Research also has shown that species-specific assemblages of skin-associated bacteria and suites of antimicrobial peptides affect amphibian susceptibility to chytridiomycosis (). Not surprisingly, innate and adaptive amphibian immune function probably plays a critical role in determining chytridiomycosis disease outcome (). The few studies that have investigated host immune response to chytridiomycosis suggest that susceptible frog species have a weak adaptive immune response to B. dendrobatidis infection (,). In contrast, work on the disease-resistant frog Xenopus laevis suggests that innate and adaptive immune components constitute host response to B. dendrobatidis infection in this species (). Examining host immune response to B. dendrobatidis among closely related amphibians that differ in disease susceptibility would be of tremendous value to more fully elucidate the immune genes, pathways, and responses that contribute to B. dendrobatidis tolerance (Table). Bat immune response to G. destructans infection is poorly characterized (), but species may be susceptible to WNS partly because of natural immune system down-regulation during hibernation (). This current gap in knowledge deserves particular attention given that differences in host immune function between bat species in North America and Europe could account for their differential susceptibility to WNS (,). Immunogenetic studies are urgently needed to better understand the immunologic mechanisms driving WNS-associated population declines among bat species in North America. Comparisons between susceptible and nonsusceptible species, species in North America and Europe, and active and hibernating bats will be particularly important in this regard (Table).

Alternatively, disease processes in chytridiomycosis and WNS may largely reflect activity of the pathogenic fungi themselves, and further work is needed to understand the factors that drive pathogenicity in these fungal species (Table). Researchers have hypothesized that B. dendrobatidis may evade or suppress the amphibian immune system (,), but understanding of molecular and cellular mechanisms for such activity is lacking. Recent genomic comparisons with other fungi suggest that expansions of protease gene families during the recent evolutionary history of B. dendrobatidis might account for the pathogen’s ability to colonize amphibian skin and evade the amphibian immune system (). Because secreted proteases also appear to contribute to virulence in other dermatophyte fungi (), activity of these genes could help explain pathogenicity of G. destructans as well. G. destructans is known to produce secretory proteases in culture (), although the role of these proteins during pathogenesis of WNS has yet to be elucidated.

Conclusions

In general, the fungal diseases chytridiomycosis and WNS show striking similarities. Both diseases appear to be driven by novel pathogens introduced to new geographic regions by human transport. B. dendrobatidis and G. destructans are host-generalist pathogens with abiotic reservoirs that can persist even when the density of host species is low. The life history characteristics of many amphibians and bats result in high host densities, high rates of host contact with the fungi, and depressed immune function during specific life stages or seasons, all of which are factors that contribute to pathogen persistence and transmission within a host community. Finally, both B. dendrobatidis and G. destructans are dermatophyte fungi that appear to successfully overcome host defenses in some of their primary host species.

Recognizing the commonalities between chytridiomycosis and WNS can help identify management efforts that may best address future emerging fungal diseases. Because anthropogenic transport of novel pathogens appears to play a major role in fungal disease emergence, increased global biosecurity aimed at minimizing the spread of invasive pathogens may be among the most effective fungal disease mitigation strategies (). Although biosecurity will aid in detecting and preventing transport of many pathogen types, these efforts are particularly critical for controlling pathogenic fungi, given that they may infect a broad range of host species and persist on abiotic substrates long enough to increase their likelihood of successful dispersal to new areas. In addition, disease monitoring might focus on animals with life history characteristics that increase their risk for pathogen exposure or illness following pathogen introduction into a population. Species that exhibit social behavior or other intraspecific interactions might be especially vulnerable to disease outbreaks. For example, an opportunistic pathogenic fungus was recently identified in a declining population of timber rattlesnakes (), and susceptibility to outbreaks of fungal disease might be predicted for this and similar species given their communal denning behavior and potential for lowered immune function during hibernation.

Although pathogen virulence and disease outbreaks of are extremely difficult to predict, scientists focusing on wildlife disease might prioritize research on fungi closely related to currently pathogenic species while remaining vigilant of fungal disease outbreaks in new host species. Pathogenic fungi have primarily been viewed as threats to ectothermic organisms because ectotherms can have low body temperatures that are suitable for the growth of many fungi (,). B. dendrobatidis (,) and G. destructans (,) are psychrophilic species with growth optima at lower temperatures (17°–25°C for B. dendrobatidis, 10°–15°C for G. destructans). In contrast, endothermic body temperatures generally exceed the upper thermal tolerance limits of fungi, a factor that might partially explain why WNS affects bats during hibernation when their internal temperature is lowered and immune function is inhibited (,). However, some researchers hypothesize that anthropogenic climate warming will select for increasing heat tolerance in fungi, presumably resulting in a greater number of fungi capable of surviving in the range of endothermic body temperatures (). Regional warming and associated changes in fungal heat tolerance may therefore create new pathogen risks for endothermic vertebrate hosts. In conclusion, we suggest psychrophilic fungal species probably will continue to be major pathogens of ectothermic vertebrates, whereas fungi with thermal tolerances closer to endothermic body temperatures may represent increasing threats to endotherms. Despite the associated challenges, the recent devastating effects of chytridiomycosis and WNS suggest that biologists and epidemiologists should give greater attention to pathogenic fungi if they wish to preserve vertebrate biodiversity in a rapidly changing global environment.