BACKGROUND: Some publications have shown that equivalent doses of erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESA) defined on label differ from those effective in clinical practice. Therefore, real costs could vary from theoretical costs in the treatment of anaemia in chronic kidney disease (CKD). OBJECTIVES: To perform a cost-minimization analysis to establish the economic impact of the principal ESAs used in treating anaemia secondary to CKD in daily practice. SECONDARY OBJECTIVES: to determine patient-month cost based on the erythropoietin resistance index (ERI); to analyze the difference in cost between pre-dialysis and peritoneal dialysis (PD) patients; and to analyze the association between iron deposits and ESA cost. SETTING: This study was carried out at 2 tertiary hospitals in Spain. METHOD: A multicentre cost-minimization analysis was performed in adult outpatients treated with ESAs for anaemia due to CKD. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The primary outcome was the patient-month cost for each ESA. RESULTS: 409 patients were included. Median patient-month cost was: epoetin (103.2 [63.7, 187.8] euros), darbepoetin α (134.4 [67.2, 216.0] euros) and CERA (147.5 [98.3, 196.7] euros). Median patient-month cost according to ERI was: epoetin (1.60 [0.90, 2.60] euros/kg), darbepoetin α (2.01 [0.95, 3.48] euros/kg) and CERA (1.87 [1.33, 3.00] euros/kg). Median patient-month cost in pre-dialysis was 126.0 (73.7, 201.6) euros and in PD 153.0 (100.2, 275.4) euros. Median patient-month cost for patients with TSI < 20% was 147.5 (98.3, 224.9) euros compared to 100.9 (67.2, 196.7) euros which was the cost for patients with IST ≥ 20%. The median patient-month cost for patients with ferritin < 100 mcg/l was 134.4 (85.0, 201.6) euros compared to 100.8 (68.8, 196.7) euros, which was the cost for patients with ferritin ≥ 100 mcg/l (p = 0.242). CONCLUSION: Doses of CERA used in clinical practice are lower than those recommended on label, which directly influences cost and treatment efficiency. Cost stratification based on iron deposits has shown that patients with low TSI or ferritin require higher doses and consequently an associated higher cost. Thus, to guarantee adequate iron levels is essential in the rational use of ESAs.
BACKGROUND: Some publications have shown that equivalent doses of erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESA) defined on label differ from those effective in clinical practice. Therefore, real costs could vary from theoretical costs in the treatment of anaemia in chronic kidney disease (CKD). OBJECTIVES: To perform a cost-minimization analysis to establish the economic impact of the principal ESAs used in treating anaemia secondary to CKD in daily practice. SECONDARY OBJECTIVES: to determine patient-month cost based on the erythropoietin resistance index (ERI); to analyze the difference in cost between pre-dialysis and peritoneal dialysis (PD) patients; and to analyze the association between iron deposits and ESA cost. SETTING: This study was carried out at 2 tertiary hospitals in Spain. METHOD: A multicentre cost-minimization analysis was performed in adult outpatients treated with ESAs for anaemia due to CKD. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The primary outcome was the patient-month cost for each ESA. RESULTS: 409 patients were included. Median patient-month cost was: epoetin (103.2 [63.7, 187.8] euros), darbepoetin α (134.4 [67.2, 216.0] euros) and CERA (147.5 [98.3, 196.7] euros). Median patient-month cost according to ERI was: epoetin (1.60 [0.90, 2.60] euros/kg), darbepoetin α (2.01 [0.95, 3.48] euros/kg) and CERA (1.87 [1.33, 3.00] euros/kg). Median patient-month cost in pre-dialysis was 126.0 (73.7, 201.6) euros and in PD 153.0 (100.2, 275.4) euros. Median patient-month cost for patients with TSI < 20% was 147.5 (98.3, 224.9) euros compared to 100.9 (67.2, 196.7) euros which was the cost for patients with IST ≥ 20%. The median patient-month cost for patients with ferritin < 100 mcg/l was 134.4 (85.0, 201.6) euros compared to 100.8 (68.8, 196.7) euros, which was the cost for patients with ferritin ≥ 100 mcg/l (p = 0.242). CONCLUSION: Doses of CERA used in clinical practice are lower than those recommended on label, which directly influences cost and treatment efficiency. Cost stratification based on iron deposits has shown that patients with low TSI or ferritin require higher doses and consequently an associated higher cost. Thus, to guarantee adequate iron levels is essential in the rational use of ESAs.
Authors: W H Hörl; C Jacobs; I C Macdougall; F Valderrábano; I Parrondo; K Thompson; B G Carveth Journal: Nephrol Dial Transplant Date: 2000 Impact factor: 5.992
Authors: R Marín; M A Goicoechea; M Gorostidi; A Cases; J Díez; G Escolar; F Fernández-Vega; R Palomar; E Rodrigo; I Martínez; J Segura Journal: Nefrologia Date: 2006 Impact factor: 2.033
Authors: Manuel Molina; Maria Jose Navarro; Carmen de Gracia; Gracia Alvarez; Rosa de Alarcon; Maria Angeles Garcia Journal: Ren Fail Date: 2008 Impact factor: 2.606