Experimental elevation of testosterone lowers fitness in female dark-eyed juncos.

Testosterone (T) is often referred to as the "male hormone," but it can influence aggression, parental behavior, and immune function in both males and females. By experimentally relating hormone-induced changes in phenotype to fitness, it is possible to ask whether existing phenotypes perform better or worse than alternative phenotypes, and hence to predict how selection might act on a novel or rare phenotype. In a songbird, the dark-eyed junco (Junco hyemalis), we have examined the effects of experimentally elevated T in females on fitness-related behaviors such as parental care. In this study, we implanted female juncos with exogenous T and examined its effect on fitness (survival, reproduction, and extra-pair mating) to assess whether T-altered phenotypes would prove to be adaptive or deleterious for females. Experimental elevation of T decreased the likelihood that a female would breed successfully, and T-implanted females had lower total reproductive success at every stage of the reproductive cycle. They did not, however, differ from control females in fledgling quality, extra-pair offspring production, survival, or reproduction in the following year. Previous work in this system has shown that experimental elevation of T in males alters behavior and physiology and decreases survival but increases the production of extra-pair offspring, leading to higher net fitness relative to control animals. Our results suggest that increased T has divergent effects on male and female fitness in this species, and that prevailing levels in females may be adaptive for them. These findings are consistent with sexual conflict.