Bethany Taylor1, Kenneth Carswell, Amanda C de C Williams. 1. Department of Rehabilitation Psychology, Camden & Islington NHS Foundation Trust, London, United Kingdom. Electronic address: Bethanytaylor@candi.nhs.uk.
Abstract
CONTEXT: There are limited studies and few theoretical models addressing the interaction between pain and symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder, with none concerning this interaction in survivors of torture, who frequently report persistent pain. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to explore the relationship between persistent pain and re-experiencing of traumatic events in survivors of torture. METHODS: Nine torture survivors were interviewed about their experiences of pain and re-experiencing, and the results analyzed using interpretative phenomenological analysis. Levels of pain and post-traumatic stress were assessed. RESULTS: Four superordinate themes emerged, namely "pain is the enemy," "pain and intrusive memories are connected," "changed identity," and "resilience and resources." These themes showed a complex relationship between torture, pain, re-experiencing, and other aspects of individual experience, such as the multiple losses experienced by torture survivors. Both pain and post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms were shown to have profound impacts on the everyday lives of participants. CONCLUSION: The results suggest that the relationship between pain and re-experiencing requires a broad model that considers the impact of a range of individual, social, and environmental factors on the interaction between pain and traumatic stress symptoms in survivors of torture. The study has clinical implications, most notably the need to attempt more integrated treatment of pain and traumatic symptoms where they occur together, and to consider the meaning and impact of pain when treating survivors of torture. Further investigation of the relationship between pain and traumatic stress symptoms in torture survivors is needed, as are studies of combined treatment for pain and trauma.
CONTEXT: There are limited studies and few theoretical models addressing the interaction between pain and symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder, with none concerning this interaction in survivors of torture, who frequently report persistent pain. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to explore the relationship between persistent pain and re-experiencing of traumatic events in survivors of torture. METHODS: Nine torture survivors were interviewed about their experiences of pain and re-experiencing, and the results analyzed using interpretative phenomenological analysis. Levels of pain and post-traumatic stress were assessed. RESULTS: Four superordinate themes emerged, namely "pain is the enemy," "pain and intrusive memories are connected," "changed identity," and "resilience and resources." These themes showed a complex relationship between torture, pain, re-experiencing, and other aspects of individual experience, such as the multiple losses experienced by torture survivors. Both pain and post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms were shown to have profound impacts on the everyday lives of participants. CONCLUSION: The results suggest that the relationship between pain and re-experiencing requires a broad model that considers the impact of a range of individual, social, and environmental factors on the interaction between pain and traumatic stress symptoms in survivors of torture. The study has clinical implications, most notably the need to attempt more integrated treatment of pain and traumatic symptoms where they occur together, and to consider the meaning and impact of pain when treating survivors of torture. Further investigation of the relationship between pain and traumatic stress symptoms in torture survivors is needed, as are studies of combined treatment for pain and trauma.
Authors: Deepika E Slawek; Madiha Syed; Chinazo O Cunningham; Chenshu Zhang; Jonathan Ross; Merrill Herman; Nancy Sohler; Haruka Minami; Frances R Levin; Julia H Arnsten; Joanna L Starrels Journal: J Psychiatr Res Date: 2021-12-02 Impact factor: 5.250
Authors: Whitney Scott; Maite Garcia Calderon Mendoza Del Solar; Harriet Kemp; Lance M McCracken; Amanda C de C Williams; Andrew S C Rice Journal: Pain Date: 2020-05 Impact factor: 7.926
Authors: Wegdan Hasha; Jannicke Igland; Lars T Fadnes; Bernadette Kumar; Jasmin Haj-Younes; Elisabeth Marie Strømme; Eirin Zerwekh Norstein; Rolf Vårdal; Esperanza Diaz Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2020-12-17 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Viktoria Zander; Henrik Eriksson; Kyllike Christensson; Maria Müllersdorf Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2015-09-25 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Melita J Giummarra; Sara L Casey; Anna Devlin; Liane J Ioannou; Stephen J Gibson; Nellie Georgiou-Karistianis; Paul A Jennings; Peter A Cameron; Jennie Ponsford Journal: Pain Rep Date: 2017-09-15
Authors: Wegdan Hasha; Lars T Fadnes; Jannicke Igland; Rolf Vårdal; Line Merete Giusti; Elisabeth Marie Strømme; Jasmin Haj-Younes; Unni Heltne; Bernadette N Kumar; Esperanza Diaz Journal: Trials Date: 2019-12-27 Impact factor: 2.279