BACKGROUND: The frequency and impact of medical errors during staged palliation are unknown. METHODS: All patients with hypoplastic left heart syndrome and physiologic equivalents (N = 191) who underwent staged palliation (2001-2011) were studied. Stage 1, interstage, and stage 2 were reviewed to identify diagnostic, technical, judgment, and management errors. The impact of errors on transplant-free survival was examined by parametric competing risks and risk-adjusted regressions using bootstrapping. RESULTS: Stage 1 (N = 191) errors (n = 111, 58%) were common and predominantly intraoperative (n = 84, 44%) or postoperative (n = 43, 23%). Postoperative errors were determinants of death/transplant (hazard ratio, 1.7; P = .01), whereas technical errors (n = 65, 34%) were not, but they delayed recovery and discharge (extra 24 days approximately, P = .0024). Postoperative stage 1 errors led to decrements in total strategy success of approximately 30% (78% vs 48%, P = .004). Stage 2 (N = 134) errors (n = 66, 49%) were common. Intraoperative errors were the most prevalent (n = 61, 46%) but did not compromise survival. Postoperative errors (n = 11, 8%) were determinants of death/transplant (hazard ratio, 2.4; P < .0001). Interstage errors (n = 21, 16%) led to twice the intensive care unit stay (16 vs 7 days, P < .0001) and hospital stay (30 vs 17 days, P < .02) after stage 2. Overall, a child presenting with ideal morphology and managed with no postoperative errors at stage 1 or 2 would have a predicted late survival in excess of 80%. CONCLUSIONS: Technical errors are common and delay recovery. Their effects on survival are mitigated. Intraoperative judgment errors are associated with strategy failure in a univariate model and lead to increased postoperative errors in a multivariate model. Postoperative errors are independently associated with a decrease in univentricular strategy survival.
BACKGROUND: The frequency and impact of medical errors during staged palliation are unknown. METHODS: All patients with hypoplastic left heart syndrome and physiologic equivalents (N = 191) who underwent staged palliation (2001-2011) were studied. Stage 1, interstage, and stage 2 were reviewed to identify diagnostic, technical, judgment, and management errors. The impact of errors on transplant-free survival was examined by parametric competing risks and risk-adjusted regressions using bootstrapping. RESULTS: Stage 1 (N = 191) errors (n = 111, 58%) were common and predominantly intraoperative (n = 84, 44%) or postoperative (n = 43, 23%). Postoperative errors were determinants of death/transplant (hazard ratio, 1.7; P = .01), whereas technical errors (n = 65, 34%) were not, but they delayed recovery and discharge (extra 24 days approximately, P = .0024). Postoperative stage 1 errors led to decrements in total strategy success of approximately 30% (78% vs 48%, P = .004). Stage 2 (N = 134) errors (n = 66, 49%) were common. Intraoperative errors were the most prevalent (n = 61, 46%) but did not compromise survival. Postoperative errors (n = 11, 8%) were determinants of death/transplant (hazard ratio, 2.4; P < .0001). Interstage errors (n = 21, 16%) led to twice the intensive care unit stay (16 vs 7 days, P < .0001) and hospital stay (30 vs 17 days, P < .02) after stage 2. Overall, a child presenting with ideal morphology and managed with no postoperative errors at stage 1 or 2 would have a predicted late survival in excess of 80%. CONCLUSIONS: Technical errors are common and delay recovery. Their effects on survival are mitigated. Intraoperative judgment errors are associated with strategy failure in a univariate model and lead to increased postoperative errors in a multivariate model. Postoperative errors are independently associated with a decrease in univentricular strategy survival.
Authors: Priya N Bhat; John M Costello; Ranjit Aiyagari; Paul J Sharek; Claudia A Algaze; Mjaye L Mazwi; Stephen J Roth; Andrew Y Shin Journal: Cardiol Young Date: 2018-02-07 Impact factor: 1.093
Authors: Christopher E Mascio; Erle H Austin; Jeffrey P Jacobs; Marshall L Jacobs; Amelia S Wallace; Xia He; Sara K Pasquali Journal: J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg Date: 2013-11-16 Impact factor: 5.209