Kate Gerrish1, Andrew Naisby, Mubarak Ismail. 1. Department of Nursing Research, University of Sheffield and Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, UK.
Abstract
AIM: To explore experiences of the diagnosis and management of tuberculosis from the perspective of Somali patients and healthcare professionals involved in their care. BACKGROUND: The Somali population has the third highest incidence of tuberculosis occurring in persons born outside the UK. Tuberculosis is a disease with sociocultural as well as physical consequences. Nurses should understand how the disease is experienced by people from different ethnic backgrounds to implement strategies for prevention and management of tuberculosis. DESIGN: A focused ethnography. METHOD: Individual interviews with 14 Somali patients and 18 healthcare professionals with experience of providing care to Somalis were undertaken in 2008-2009. Interviews explored the patient experience from onset of symptoms to completion of treatment. Data were analysed using Framework approach. FINDINGS: Despite presenting in primary care early, patients experienced diagnostic delays due to low clinical suspicion of tuberculosis among general practitioners. Although patients reported felt and enacted stigma, it did not adversely affect concordance with treatment. Patients were reticent about sharing their diagnosis among wider networks due to perceived stigma. Psychological support from families and specialist nurses was valued highly. Healthcare professionals perceived that stigmatization of tuberculosis was diminishing among Somalis leading to improved management of tuberculosis. Patients and healthcare professionals raised concerns about the longer term physical and psychosocial implications of tuberculosis once treatment was completed. CONCLUSION: Nurses have a role in promoting early presentation, timely diagnosis, and treatment adherence through supporting Somali patients and raising awareness of the disease among primary care practitioners.
AIM: To explore experiences of the diagnosis and management of tuberculosis from the perspective of Somali patients and healthcare professionals involved in their care. BACKGROUND: The Somali population has the third highest incidence of tuberculosis occurring in persons born outside the UK. Tuberculosis is a disease with sociocultural as well as physical consequences. Nurses should understand how the disease is experienced by people from different ethnic backgrounds to implement strategies for prevention and management of tuberculosis. DESIGN: A focused ethnography. METHOD: Individual interviews with 14 Somali patients and 18 healthcare professionals with experience of providing care to Somalis were undertaken in 2008-2009. Interviews explored the patient experience from onset of symptoms to completion of treatment. Data were analysed using Framework approach. FINDINGS: Despite presenting in primary care early, patients experienced diagnostic delays due to low clinical suspicion of tuberculosis among general practitioners. Although patients reported felt and enacted stigma, it did not adversely affect concordance with treatment. Patients were reticent about sharing their diagnosis among wider networks due to perceived stigma. Psychological support from families and specialist nurses was valued highly. Healthcare professionals perceived that stigmatization of tuberculosis was diminishing among Somalis leading to improved management of tuberculosis. Patients and healthcare professionals raised concerns about the longer term physical and psychosocial implications of tuberculosis once treatment was completed. CONCLUSION: Nurses have a role in promoting early presentation, timely diagnosis, and treatment adherence through supporting Somali patients and raising awareness of the disease among primary care practitioners.
Authors: Maeve K Lalor; Laura F Anderson; Esther L Hamblion; Andy Burkitt; Jennifer A Davidson; Helen Maguire; Ibrahim Abubakar; H Lucy Thomas Journal: BMC Med Date: 2017-06-13 Impact factor: 8.775
Authors: Kerri A Viney; Penelope Johnson; Markleen Tagaro; Saen Fanai; Nguyen N Linh; Paul Kelly; David Harley; Adrian Sleigh Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2014-05-17 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Kathleen Yin; Joshua Jung; Enrico Coiera; Liliana Laranjo; Ann Blandford; Adeel Khoja; Wan-Tien Tai; Daniel Psillakis Phillips; Annie Y S Lau Journal: J Med Internet Res Date: 2020-06-02 Impact factor: 5.428