Tamar Kabakian-Khasholian1. 1. Health Promotion and Community Health Department, Faculty of Health Sciences, American University of Beirut, Riad El Solh 1107 2020, PO Box 11-0236, Lebanon. Electronic address: tk00@aub.edu.lb.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: the rising trends in caesarean section have been partially attributed to women's requests. Many studies in developed and very few in developing countries have attempted to understand this phenomenon. This qualitative study explores experiences of women having caesarean section on demand in a middle-income country with a private health-care system. DESIGN: an inductive qualitative design, using face-to-face semi-structured interviews. SETTING: women were identified and recruited through a perinatal database and selected obstetricians' clinics in the Greater Beirut area in Lebanon. PARTICIPANTS: a purposive sample of women who had a caesarean childbirth within the four months preceding the interview, were visited for an interview at home using a semi-structured interview guide. Thematic content analysis was conducted on a sub-sample of 22 women who requested a caesarean birth. FINDINGS: lack of information about caesarean sections fosters women's fear from labour pain and acts as the main impetus for women to consider caesareans as the pain free alternative. Findings reveal health-care providers' role in reinforcing beliefs about caesarean sections being the way for pain free deliveries by overestimating the safety of the procedure and disregarding postpartum health issues. KEY CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: caesarean birth is presented to women as a safe option for 'pain free' childbirth. This needs to be considered within the cultural context of understanding safety and pain as well as the dynamics of power in maternity care. Health-care professionals need to explore these dimensions and promote women's informed choice as well as encouraging the normality of birth.
OBJECTIVE: the rising trends in caesarean section have been partially attributed to women's requests. Many studies in developed and very few in developing countries have attempted to understand this phenomenon. This qualitative study explores experiences of women having caesarean section on demand in a middle-income country with a private health-care system. DESIGN: an inductive qualitative design, using face-to-face semi-structured interviews. SETTING:women were identified and recruited through a perinatal database and selected obstetricians' clinics in the Greater Beirut area in Lebanon. PARTICIPANTS: a purposive sample of women who had a caesarean childbirth within the four months preceding the interview, were visited for an interview at home using a semi-structured interview guide. Thematic content analysis was conducted on a sub-sample of 22 women who requested a caesarean birth. FINDINGS: lack of information about caesarean sections fosters women's fear from labour pain and acts as the main impetus for women to consider caesareans as the pain free alternative. Findings reveal health-care providers' role in reinforcing beliefs about caesarean sections being the way for pain free deliveries by overestimating the safety of the procedure and disregarding postpartum health issues. KEY CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: caesarean birth is presented to women as a safe option for 'pain free' childbirth. This needs to be considered within the cultural context of understanding safety and pain as well as the dynamics of power in maternity care. Health-care professionals need to explore these dimensions and promote women's informed choice as well as encouraging the normality of birth.
Authors: Mercedes Colomar; Newton Opiyo; Carol Kingdon; Qian Long; Soledad Nion; Meghan A Bohren; Ana Pilar Betran Journal: PLoS One Date: 2021-05-05 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Wouter Bakker; Siem Zethof; Felix Nansongole; Kelvin Kilowe; Jos van Roosmalen; Thomas van den Akker Journal: BMC Med Ethics Date: 2021-03-29 Impact factor: 2.834