| Literature DB >> 23304484 |
Gitte Susanne Rasmussen1, Helle Terkildsen Maindal, Kirsten Lomborg.
Abstract
The aim of this integrative review is to identify and discuss patient needs for education to support self-management in daily life with psoriasis. As psoriasis increasingly gains recognition as a serious chronic autoimmune skin disease with long-term impairment on the life course, and not mainly a cosmetic problem, nurses are highly challenged to develop efficient education to support patient self-management. The paper includes five stages: (1) problem identification, (2) literature search, (3) data evaluation, (4) data analysis and synthesis, and (5) presentation, based on theoretic scaffolding around the concept "need." Nineteen of 164 original papers within nursing, medicine and psychology, and reflecting patient perspective were included. To capture the patients' cultural understanding of the implications of the disease and care, we developed an interlevel model indicating that self-experienced burden of disease and its visibility, personal conditions such as illness perception, and the patient's age at onset time are high-impact factors that should be addressed in future structured patient education programmes. The research on patient needs has hitherto focused on adults, but the problems and vulnerability associated with having a chronic and visible disease during adolescence must be acknowledged, and patient education initiatives designed for this young group are recommended.Entities:
Year: 2012 PMID: 23304484 PMCID: PMC3523575 DOI: 10.1155/2012/890860
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nurs Res Pract ISSN: 2090-1429
Criteria for assessment of identified papers.
| Qualitative papers | Quantitative papers |
|---|---|
| Problem stated unambiguously? | Statement of the problem? |
| Ethical problems reflected? | Identified aim, hypothesis or research question? |
| Identified aims congruent with methodology and methods for data collection and analysis? | Sufficient description of the population and transferability into Danish context? |
| Sufficient details of the informants and settings? | Adequate description of measures? |
| Method for data collection described? | Adequate description of data collection? |
| Sufficient detail of the process of analysis provided to ensure accordance with selected method? | Sufficient description of data analysis? |
| Results presented systematically? | Findings adequately summarised and answering research question? |
| Conclusions reflect results from the study and relevance for practicing nursing in a Danish context? | Generalisability of the findings for Danish nursing practice and discipline? |
Figure 1Flow diagram of the search process, adapted from Moher et al. [34].
Themes, clusters and verification of findings.
| Theme | Cluster | Verification |
|---|---|---|
| Visibility of disease | Disease-specific factors | [ |
| Onset time | ||
| Fluctuating nature of disease | ||
| Physical symptoms: itch, pain, discomfort | Self-experienced burden of disease (physical) | [ |
| Bodily suffering | ||
| Disease impact on self-concept | Self-experienced burden of disease (psychological) | |
| Psychological impact of disease | ||
| Disease as a psychological burden | ||
| Disease impact on family and partner | Self-experienced burden of disease (social) | |
| Disease impact on daily life | ||
| Personal coping strategies | Personal factors | [ |
| Personal factors, illness perception | ||
| Personal factors, partner, family and network |
Figure 2High-impact factors for patient self-management of psoriasis in daily life.
Key data, selected papers.
| No. | Author, Year, Country, Discipline, Design | Aim | Informants, Population | Data, Measures | Findings, Results | Author conclusion and discussion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | Wahl et al., 2000. | To assess health-related quality of life among patients with psoriasis and to compare these estimates with population norms. | 283 patients treated at 3 dermatology departments in the eastern part of Norway. | Short Form 36 | After adjustments had been made according to age, gender, educational level and marital status, it was seen that psoriasis patients reported poorer health-related quality of life in all 8 conceptual domains compared to norms from the general Norwegian population. The largest difference was found on the role limitation scale—emotional scale. | The burden of psoriasis is significant at the emotional life domain. This domain deals with problems in relation to work or other regular daily activities as a result of any emotional problems, such as feeling depressed or anxious. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Wahl et al., 2002. | To present results from a qualitative study that focuses on patients with psoriasis, their experience of living with the disease, and its psychological and social impact. | 22 hospitalized patients with severe disease, that is, more than 30% of the body affected. | Transcribed interviews. | Bodily suffering emerged as the core category, with the following subcategories: | Patients' experience of living with psoriasis includes bodily suffering, changed self-image, the perception of being stigmatised, and social isolation. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Fortune et al., 2002a. | To examine strategies for coping in patients with psoriasis and investigate whether they differ compared to normal controls and patients with other major medical diseases. | 250 patients attending psoriasis specialty clinic at Hope Hospital. 27% with severe psoriasis. | PASI. | Across medical conditions, patients showed remarkable similarity in the type of coping strategies used. | Illness brings with it a generic form of coping that requires shaping to fit the specific demands of specific illnesses like psoriasis. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Fortune et al., 2002b. | To investigate whether coping and alexithymia should be given significant consideration in the conceptualization of patient's adjustment to psoriasis, or whether the cognitive model (illness perception) of the condition held by patients is adequate on its own. | 225 patients from Dermatology Centre at Hope Hospital, Salford. | PASI | Cognitive psychological factors, mainly illness perception and to a lesser extent coping, appear to be more important for the patients' quality of life and psychological well-being than clinical severity. | The study emphasizes the importance of recognizing that the onset of a chronic condition brings with it a range of difficulties that may vary considerably in their nature and severity as perceived by the patient. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Richards et al., 2004. | To investigate the representation of psoriasis symptoms in psoriasis patients and their healthy partners, and to examine how their differences in beliefs about psoriasis may be associated with adaptive outcome in terms of anxiety, depression, and worry. | 58 patients with chronic plaque psoriasis and their partners, recruited either from specialty clinic, dermatology outpatient clinic or inpatient ward setting. | SAPASI | Patients with psoriasis had significantly higher levels of anxiety, depression and worry compared to their partners. | The study offers an insight into the way in which divergence, in terms of the way psoriasis is perceived by patients and their partners, may have an impact on psychological and clinical outcome. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Jankowiak et al., 2004. | To determine the need for health education among patients with psoriasis through the determination of gaps that most frequently occur in this kind of knowledge. | 149 patients. | Questionnaire based on the PDI. | The study illustrated, among other things: | Patients with psoriasis need to expand their knowledge about the disease and self-care methods. The largest knowledge deficit observed were the factors causing the disease. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | O'Leary et al., 2004. | To assess causal beliefs in a psoriasis population and to examine the link between these attributions and mood, quality of life, and health status. | 40 patients from an outpatient skin clinic and 101 from the Psoriasis Association. | PSS | The most commonly endorsed causes were “stress/worry”. More than 60% of the sample scored above the scale midpoint for “stress/psychological” indicating a strong causal belief in this factor | A large proportion of people with psoriasis believe that stress is a causal factor in their illness. This belief was associated with poorer psychological well-being and the perception that psoriasis has a large emotional impact. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Fortune et al., 2004a. | To investigate whether, and to what extent, improvement in the clinical severity of psoriasis induced by photochemotheraphy with psoralen plus ultraviolet A translates into meaningful changes in beliefs about psoriasis, coping, stress or disability. | 72 patients with psoriasis referred for PUVA treatment. | PASI | The study reported that the medical management of psoriasis has demonstrable effects on disability and psoriasis-related stress experienced by the current sample of patients, but not on levels of distress, beliefs about psoriasis or on the coping strategies used by patients. | The findings imply that clinical clearance of psoriasis is not sufficient to bring about changes in patients' distress. Unlike disability, distress in patients with psoriasis is possibly linked to the cognitive aspects of a patients' world view rather than to its more behavioural aspects. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Evers et al., 2005. | To examine whether generic physical, psychological and social factors relevant to patients with chronic diseases contribute to psychological distress in adults with psoriasis and atopic dermatitis. | 128 patients with psoriasis and 128 patients with atopic dermatitis (aged over 16 years) from a dermatology clinic at University Medical Center, St. Radbound. | Skin status assessed with a nine-item scale. | The study reported that higher levels of psychological distress were significantly related to physical symptoms of fatigue, a greater impact of disease on daily life, illness cognition of greater helplessness and less acceptance, less perceived support and a smaller social network. | The study indicates that at least 30% of the patients suffer from a higher level of psychological distress. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Wahl et al., 2006. | To characterize how hospitalized patients coped with psoriasis and eczema during exacerbation of the disease in the period prior to admission to the dermatology ward, and to investigate the relationship between coping and quality of life. | 146 hospitalized patients with psoriasis | JCS. | The results indicate that optimistic, belief-in-oneself and confrontational strategies are most frequently used among patients who are admitted to the dermatological ward for treatment. Use of confronting strategies is related to better quality of life. | It appears that illness results in a generic form of coping that may require shaping to fit the individual demands of diseases like psoriasis, and that patients with psoriasis tend to use significantly less active coping strategies. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Unaeze et al., 2006. | To examine changes in specific aspects in which psoriasis may impact individuals over time, and to determine sociodemographic and clinical characteristics associated with HRQOL at baseline 1993 and with change in HRQOL over time. | 867 patients completed questionnaire in 1993. | IPSO. | Responses to items assessing the impact of psoriasis on social aspects of HRQOL such as social activities, holiday or travel plans, and making new friends were generally stable. | The overall psychosocial impact of psoriasis on patients HRQOL decrease over time. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Dubertret et al., 2006. | To explore the patients' perspective of psoriasis on their lifestyle and well-being and to gain insight into effectiveness and satisfaction with current available therapies for psoriasis. | 18.386 patient association members in seven European countries (Belgium, the Czech republic, Finland, France, Germany, Italy, and the Netherlands). | Self-administered questionnaire developed in collaboration with EUROPSO (European Federation of Psoriasis Patients Associations) and the NPF (National Psoriasis Foundation). | (i) More than 70% reported psoriasis having an overall impact on their lives. The impact was greater with involvement of feet, armpits, genitals and hands. | It is evident from this survey that patients with psoriasis suffer from significant impairment of their QoL. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Uttjek et al., 2007. | The main issue is to find out how psoriasis affects the individual's everyday life, and if there is any variation between genders. | 18 patients were selected from a population of a previous study with regard to gender, place of residence, and in relation to three district health care centres in Västerbotten. | Transcribed interviews. | The following themes emerged: | The worst situations occurred when patients were young and after onset of psoriasis, and included the visibility, the feeling of being marked, the struggle to conceal the disease and the fear of being rejected. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Eghlileb et al., 2007. | To identify the various ways in which the lives of relatives and partners of people with psoriasis are affected by the disease. | 63 patients with psoriasis and their relatives or partners from a dermatology outpatients department of the University Hospital of Wales. | Transcribed interviews and an open-ended postal questionnaire. | The impairment of relatives' lives were assigned to six different domains: | Psoriasis not only interferes with the daily lives and social functioning of patients with psoriasis, but also has a major impact on QoL of their relatives and partners. |
|
| ||||||
| [ |
Watson and de Bruin 2007. | To describe the lived experiences of men and women with psoriasis and how their perceived experiences impact the various dimensions of their self-concept. | 7 patients with psoriasis. | Patients' detailed descriptions | The findings are synthesized in themes shared by all participants: | Evident from the study is the tremendous power yielded by psoriasis in the arena of self-concept change. According to the participants, psoriasis is life changing radically, altering the self and the participants' being in contact with the self and others. |
|
| ||||||
| [ |
Amatya and Nordlind 2008. | To assess patients' perspective of pruritus in psoriasis vulgaris of plaque type. | 20 patients selected from outpatient clinical records of the Department of Dermatology, Karolinska University Hospital. | Transcribed interviews. | Pruritus is a common phenomenon in patients with psoriasis. | The study indicated that pruritus may be severe and affect quality of life in psoriasis patients. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Magin et al., 2009. | To investigate the psychological co-morbidities in psoriasis in patients from general (family) practice and specialist practices. | 29 patients with various disease duration and disease severity. | Transcribed interviews. | A schema of the interactions of psoriasis and psychological co- morbidities is developed with individual themes: | Psychological sequelae are complex and encompass a range of psychological morbidities. Symptoms of anxiety and depression were often causally linked by respondents to experiences of embarrassment or shame or to the socially limiting effects of behavioural avoidance. This was overt in cases where children with psoriasis were teased or taunted. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Globe et al., 2009. | To explore psoriasis patients' perception of the impact of psoriasis. | 39 patients identified by general practitioners participated in 5 separate concept elicitation focus groups. | Transcribed interviews. | All participants reported itch as an important impact on everyday life. | From the patients' perspective, itch is one of the most important symptoms of psoriasis contributing to diminished health-related quality of life in patients with both mild and severe disease. |
|
| ||||||
| [ | Ljosaa et al., 2010. | To investigate | 139 patients recruited prior to a consultation at the inpatient and outpatient dermatology units at a university hospital in Oslo. | Co-morbidity (SCQ-18). | The study showed that | Findings from this study suggest that psoriasis-related skin pain and skin discomfort may be a larger problem than previously estimated. |