Stage T1 glottic carcinoma: results of radiation therapy or laser excision.

A retrospective analysis was made of the data on 60 patients with stage T1 glottic carcinoma (43 T1a, 17 T1b) who received radiation therapy and 17 patients with T1a disease who underwent laser excision as the primary treatment modality. Patients who received radiation therapy achieved 3- and 5-year actuarial local control rates of 92% and 89% for T1a and 77% and 77% for T1b disease, respectively. In patients who underwent laser excision (all with T1a disease), the 3-year local control rate was 77%. Of the 42 evaluable irradiated T1a patients, 31 (74%) had a normal to near-normal voice, eight (19%) had mild or intermittent hoarseness, and three (7%) had persistent hoarseness. Of the 13 evaluable patients in the laser-excision group, four (31%) had a normal to near-normal voice, five (38%) had mild or intermittent hoarseness, and four (31%) had persistent hoarseness. The difference in the quality of voice between these two groups is statistically significant (P = .012), although the ultimate local control rate after salvage therapy for irradiated patients (97%) was similar to that for laser-excision patients (94%).