This study aims at investigating the efficiency of bimodal spectroscopy in detection of hypertrophic scar tissue on a preclinical model. Fluorescence and Diffuse Reflectance spectra were collected from 55 scars deliberately created on ears of 20 rabbits, amongst which some received tacrolimus injection to provide non-hypertrophic scar tissue. The spectroscopic data measured on hypertrophic and non-hypertrophic scar tissues were used for developing our classification algorithm. Spectral features were extracted from corrected data and analyzed to classify the scar tissues into hypertrophic or non-hypertrophic. The Algorithm was developed using k-NN classifier and validated by comparing to histological classification result with Leave-One-Out cross validation. Bimodal spectroscopy showed promising results in detecting hypertrophic tissue (sensibility 90.5%, specificity 94.4%). The features used for classification were extracted from the autofluorescence spectra collected at 4 CEFS with excitations at 360, 410, and 420 nm. This indicates the hypertrophic process may involve change in concentration of several fluorophores (collagen, elastin and NADH) excited in this range, or modification in volume of explored tissue layers (epidermis and dermis) due to tissue thickening.
This study aims at investigating the efficiency of bimodal spectroscopy in detection of hypertrophic scar tissue on a preclinical model. Fluorescence and Diffuse Reflectance spectra were collected from 55 scars deliberately created on ears of 20 rabbits, amongst which some received tacrolimus injection to provide non-hypertrophic scar tissue. The spectroscopic data measured on hypertrophic and non-hypertrophic scar tissues were used for developing our classification algorithm. Spectral features were extracted from corrected data and analyzed to classify the scar tissues into hypertrophic or non-hypertrophic. The Algorithm was developed using k-NN classifier and validated by comparing to histological classification result with Leave-One-Out cross validation. Bimodal spectroscopy showed promising results in detecting hypertrophic tissue (sensibility 90.5%, specificity 94.4%). The features used for classification were extracted from the autofluorescence spectra collected at 4 CEFS with excitations at 360, 410, and 420 nm. This indicates the hypertrophic process may involve change in concentration of several fluorophores (collagen, elastin and NADH) excited in this range, or modification in volume of explored tissue layers (epidermis and dermis) due to tissue thickening.
Hypertrophy is defined as an increase in tissular volume of an organ, resulting from normal
physiological process [1] or caused by
abnormal accumulation of tissular components, such as hypertrophic scars or keloids occurred on
human skin. In the latter case, the excessive growth of the scar can be of great cosmetic concern
when occurring on the face, or result in functional loss of nearby organs [2]. Hypertrophic scars occurring in all age groups has higher
incidence rate for individuals aged 10–20. They are common in African subjects following a
traumatic event on skin. In some people, keloid may recur spontaneously after treatment.Cutaneous hypertrophic scars are due to an accumulation of collagen cross-links (accounting for
tissue hardening) and to an overproduction of collagen, raising above the surrounding skin or
growing indefinitely beyond the boundaries of the original wound into a large, tumorous (although
benign) neoplasm. Kischer and Brody [3]
identified collagen nodules to be the structural unit of hypertrophic scars and keloids. These
nodules, which are absent from mature scars, contain higher density of fibroblasts and
unidirectional collagen fibrils in a highly organized and distinct orientation. In addition,
hypertrophic scars differ from normal skin by the presence of richer vasculature (depending on scar
age), higher mesenchymal cell density, and thickened epidermal cell layer. Keloidal scars, depending
on their maturity, are mainly composed of either type III (early) or type I (late) collagen.At present, clinical examination is the major method for hypertrophic scar tissue diagnosis. But,
involving biopsy and subsequent histological analysis, it is of poor sensitivity and time-consuming
[2]. Removal of the suspected scar tissue,
leading to higher skin tension, would prolong the wound’s healing and raise the risk of
hypertrophy incidence. Thus, a non-invasive method for characterizing this kind of tissue in
vivo is of prior interest for both clinicians and patients.In the frame of developing non invasive diagnostic methods for in vivo tissue
characterization, fibred optical spectroscopy has been widely studied over the last several decades
[4-6]. In contrast to surgical biopsy, the spectroscopic methods don’t require
any tissue removal. The principle consists in exploiting tissue-light interactions between near-UV
and near-infrared (NIR) to probe the optical properties of the biological tissues in
vivo. The main interactions exploited are absorption, scattering and fluorescence
[7]. The resulting intensity spectra are
measured and serve for developing classification algorithms to automatically characterize the tissue
states [8-10].Light Induced Fluorescence Spectroscopy (LIFS) is one of the most studied spectroscopic methods
for characterizing pathological tissues in cervix [11-13], esophagus [8], breast [14] and skin [19].
Biochemical and structural modifications associated to disease development can involve significant
changes in intra-cellular and extra-cellular constituents among which some fluoresce under proper
light excitation. These endogenous fluorophores include amino acids (tryptophan and tyrosine),
structural proteins (collagen and elastin), pyridine nucleotides (NADH and NADPH), flavins and
porphyrins. The AutoFluorescence (AF) emitted by these molecules is modulated by various factors,
such as tissular concentration, quantum yield or biochemical environment. When pathological
phenomena occur, these modulating factors are modified and change the bulk fluorescence intensity
emitted by the tissue. Spatially resolved Diffuse Reflectance (DR) spectroscopy is another fibred
optic technique efficiently applied in tissue photodiagnosis in vivo [11, 15, 16]. It consists in measuring the light backscattered by the tissue
after multiple scattering and absorption of photons from an incident light over a wide wavelength
band (350–750nm). The spectral features of the DR spectra depend on the scattering and
absorbing properties of the tissue, involving main chromophores such as hemoglobin, melanin and
water. A number of studies have demonstrated that the latter could change significantly for
different tissue conditions [15, 17]. So, a diagnosis algorithm could be created by exploiting the
optical-property-based spectroscopic features. The tissue depths to which the optical properties can
be analyzed are determined by the multiple fiber probe geometry, as well as the excitation
wavelength(s) [14]. Several fibers with
different Collecting-to-Exciting Fiber separation (CEFS) are used for providing various probing
depths, but with a limitation to the superficial layers of the tissue especially for UV-Visible
wavelengths (a few hundreds of micrometers). Furthermore, numerous studies [8, 18–20] showed that each of these techniques separately provides
complementary information on the tissue status, but that combining both (bimodal configuration) can
bring superior diagnostic results.As skin hypertrophy in scar tissues introduces a series of morphological and structural changes
involving several fluorophores and chromophores (namely collagen, elastin, hemoglobin), we applied
bimodal (multiple AF and DR) spectroscopy to diagnose hypertrophic scar tissues on a preclinical
model. An anti-inflammatory drug, whose inhibition effect of hypertrophy formation had been tested
along with this study, was partially applied to the model. We obtained not only hypertrophic but
also non-hypertrophic scar tissues for spectra measurement. An experimental protocol was strictly
followed for ensuring high quality data acquisition. Specific algorithms were developed for
classifying each tissue site automatically based on discriminant spectroscopic features. The
efficiency of the method was asserted upon sensibility and specificity obtained by comparing the
classification results with those from histological analysis.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Pre-clinical model
Up to the present, rabbit’s ear is the only animal model that provides reproducible
hypertrophic scar for in vivo study [36]. Hence, the protocol described in [36] was applied on 20 rabbits’ ears to induce hypertrophic scar for our
study. All procedures followed the Helsinki rules and were approved by the animal regional ethic
committee of Northeastern France (january 2009). In brief (please refer to [23] for details), 20 New Zealand female white rabbits, between 2.5
and 4 kg and aged about 100 days (CEGAV, Les Hautes Noes, France), were kept under standard
condition and fed ad libitum for 2 weeks before the experiment. Then, they were
anesthetized by intramuscular injection of ketamine (45mg/kg) and
xylazine (7mg/kg). The ventral surface of rabbits’ ear was
shaved and treated with chlorhexidine to avoid wound’s infection. Two
10mm-diameter wounds were created on each ear with help of a circular dye cutter by
removing the underneath perichondrium down to bare cartilage. The wounds were spaced from each other
by 4 cm in order to avoid inter-wound reaction. They had been covered by Tegaderm dressing
(Tegaderm, 3M Health Care, St.Paul, MN) until entirely re-epithelialized. Hypertrophic scars
appeared basically in 28 days after the initial wounding. An immunomodulator drug with
anti-inflammatory and antifibrinogenic proliferation properties (Tacrolimus), whose efficiency on
inhibiting hypertrophic scar formation was investigated in [23], was applied to certain wounding in order to create non-hypertrophic scar
tissues for comparison.
2.2. Spectroscopy instrumentation and measurement protocol
The spatially resolved bimodal spectroscopic system used in the present work was adapted from the
one developed by [19,20]. In brief (see Fig. 1), it consists of an
infrared-filtered 300W Xenon arc lamp (PE30-BF PerkinElmer, Eurosep, France)
producing excitation light in the range of 350–750nm. The lamp’s
output light is focused by a plano-convex lens on the entrance of a bunch of seven optical fibers
(individual core diameter 200μm, numerical aperture 0.22) grouped together
in a unique SMA connector. Between the light source and the SMA entrance, band-pass excitation
filters (mounted on a filter wheel) and a couple of linearly variable short-and long-pass filters
(LVF-series Linear Variable Filters, Ocean Optics) are used to configure the spectral shape of the
excitation light for our experimental requirement. The positioning of all these filters is automated
by linear or rotative motorized stages (LTA Long-Travel actuators and M-UMR8.51 linear stages,
Newport) which are controlled by a dedicated motion controller (XPS motion controller, Newport). The
use of this motion controller allow us programmable multi-excitation measurements. For DR
measurements, a wide band excitation (350 – 750nm) is required. In our
experimental set-up, an extra linear motorized stage (Newport) was used during DR measurements to
extend the travel distance of the LVFs so as to free the light path between the lens and the
excitation fiber entrance.
Fig. 1
Schematics of the spatially resolved bimodal fibred spectroscopy set up. 1) Short arc Xenon
Source 2) Heat control filter 3) Plano condenser lens 4) Wide band-pass filter wheel 5) Combined set
of short- and long-pass linearly variable filters 6) Excitation fiber positioning stage 7)
Micrometric translation stages 8) Fiber optics probe (distal tip) 9) Micrometric stage motor
controller 10) Imaging Spectrograph 11) PC computer
Schematics of the spatially resolved bimodal fibred spectroscopy set up. 1) Short arc Xenon
Source 2) Heat control filter 3) Plano condenser lens 4) Wide band-pass filter wheel 5) Combined set
of short- and long-pass linearly variable filters 6) Excitation fiber positioning stage 7)
Micrometric translation stages 8) Fiber optics probe (distal tip) 9) Micrometric stage motor
controller 10) Imaging Spectrograph 11) PC computerIn order to explore various tissue depths, 6 fibers were chosen to collect the light re-emitted
by tissue at the 6 following CEFS : 429, 438, 453, 672, 696 and 1090μm.
These collecting fibers are connected inline to the entrance slit of a multi-channel spectrometric
system (iHR320 Imaging spectrometer, Symphony STE CCD, Jobin Yvon, HORIBA®). This system
acquires the intensity spectra coming simultaneously from the 6 collecting fibers, allowing for
spatially resolved measurements. The spectrometer features a diffraction grating groove of
150gr/nm density, which span the largest measure range
(496nm) in keeping a relatively high spectral resolution (1.2nm).
The spectrograph also features an internal filter wheel with 4 different long-pass filters
alternatively used to eliminate the back-reflected excitation light from detection during AF
measurements (see Table 1). For the present study, 9 narrow
intensity peaks (FWHM= 15 ± 2nm) ranging from 360 to
450nm by step of 10nm were chosen for AF measurement, and a wide
wavelength range 350 – 700nm was used for DR measurement (cf. 1). The
latter were automatically configured by loading a preset configuration file. A multi-excitation
measurement on one tissue site, with 3 acquisitions in a row, takes about one minute and leads to a
set of 180 spectra (9 AF and 1 DR spectra acquired 3 times at 6 CEFS).
Tab. 1.
Acquisition parameters of the multichannel spectrometer with Gain = 1.7, ADC frequency
= 20kHz and Slit width = 0.5mm, Output power was measured at the distal tip of the
fiber probe
Measurements
Integration Time (ms)
Excitation Bands (nm)
Central peak Wavelength (nm)
Probe output Power (μW)
Emission Filters
λcut–off (nm)
AF
500
352–368
360
220
400
362–378
370
123
372–388
380
115
435
382–398
390
109
455
392–408
400
120
402–418
410
120
412–428
420
101
475
422–438
430
103
432–448
440
103
DR
200
350–700
-
1540
no filter
Acquisition parameters of the multichannel spectrometer with Gain = 1.7, ADC frequency
= 20kHz and Slit width = 0.5mm, Output power was measured at the distal tip of the
fiber probeFrom a metrological point of view, rigorous calibration procedures are needed to ensure all
measured results are meaningful when compared to each others between individuals or among time
[22]. Table
2 summarizes the main calibration procedures performed on our programmable light source
(including lamp, focusing lens, band-pass filters and excitation fibers of the probe) and on the
detection channels (including sensing fibers of the probe, spectrograph’s filter,
diffraction grating and detector). The references of the corresponding calibration devices used for
each metrological configuration are given together with the frequency of application of these
procedures (before each measure, daily, monthly). These calibration results served to correct raw
spectra through a series of preprocessing steps detailed in the next section.
Tab. 2.
Type of calibration measures performed for the experimental protocol with corresponding
calibration devices and application frequencies
Calibration Type
Calibration device (references)
Frequency
Wavelength calibration of the spectrograph
HgAr Lamp (LSP035 HgAr Line Source, LOT)
monthly
Intensity response calibration
Calibrated Tungsten Lamp (DH-2000, Mikropack)
monthly
Background substraction
Shuttered light source
every 2 hours
Diffuse reflectance standard measurement
Integrating Sphere (ISP-30-6-IRRAD, Mikropack)
daily
Illumination energy normalization
Power meter (841-PE + 818-UV, Newport)
daily
Type of calibration measures performed for the experimental protocol with corresponding
calibration devices and application frequencies
2.3. Histo-Clinical Analysis
After spectra measurement, each tissue site was removed for histological analysis under
conventional optical microscopy. The thicknesses of tissues’ epidermis, dermis,
perichondrium and cartilage were measured for every scar tissue. The dermal lymphocytes and
fibroblasts densities were also examined for evaluating the cellular proliferation of underline
tissue. Based on these measurements, two quantitative parameters were calculated to characterize the
tissue samples : Dermal Fibroblasts Density (DFD) and Scar Elevation Index (SEI) [23]. SEI is a parameter related to the volume increase of
tissue after scarring defined as the ratio between the scar elevation thickness
(h – h) over the original
thickness (h) of the skin. DFD was measured by counting the number of
fibroblasts per μm2 in a tissue section. According to these
criteria, all tissue samples were tagged as hypertrophic or non-hypertrophic by two experts. In
short (please refer to [23] for details),
mean dermal thickness, SEI and DFD are significantly higher in Hypertrophic scars (HT) than in
Non-Hypertrophic scars (NHT) with p¡0.05 (Student’s t-Test, n=25). The
resulting classification (30 hypertrophic and 25 non-hypertrophic) was used as gold standard for
developing our spectroscopic data-based classification algorithm. Examples of tissue slices and of
rabbit’ear scars are given in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2
(a), (b), (c) Images of histological slices for normal and scar tissues (Hematoxylin and Eosin
stains). (d) scars on the ventral side of an anesthetized rabbit’s ear. (e) fiber probe
positioning piece. (f) irregular scar tissue (28 days after surgical wound)
(a), (b), (c) Images of histological slices for normal and scar tissues (Hematoxylin and Eosin
stains). (d) scars on the ventral side of an anesthetized rabbit’s ear. (e) fiber probe
positioning piece. (f) irregular scar tissue (28 days after surgical wound)
3. Preprocessing of the raw spectra
Firstly, all acquired spectra were subtracted by a background spectrum measured at the same day
with shuttered light source. Then, 3 subsequent spectra obtained under each configuration (every
couple of excitation and CEFS) were averaged to obtain a higher SNR (Signal-to-Noise Ratio). A
median filter with window frame size of 3 points (2.34nm) eliminated high amplitude
narrow artifacts, while a Savitzky-Golay filter with window size of 25 points
(20.25nm) eliminated high frequency noises by smoothing the spectra. Each intensity
value of a AF spectrum was multiplied by a corresponding correction factor obtained by the spectral
response calibration procedure (tungsten lamp). The spectrally corrected AF spectra were then
normalized to the illumination power and exposure time for eliminating the influence of excitation
intensity variations [22]. At last, all
preprocessed spectra were normalized to their individual maximum for a line-shape analysis mentioned
hereafter.
4. Spectroscopic Data Analysis
4.1. Initial selection of proper measurement sites
The strong light absorption due to erythema on some tissue sites deformed some acquired spectra
to such an extent that they were not exploitable. Therefore, a revision algorithm eliminating all
the data measured on these tissue sites was necessary before performing the spectral data
classification. In general, these over-distorted spectra exhibiting quite different line-shape have
intensity values non-correlated to those measured on most of tissue sites in the same class.
Therefore, the median value of the inter-correlation vector of each spectrum was compared to a
threshold (in our case 70%) so that a spectrum was considered as outlier if the value was
less than the threshold i.e. eliminated from the data pool. By this method, we retained 44 (22
hypertrophic and 22 non-hypertrophic) out of 55 tissue sites for further analysis. The analysis of
the tissue surface photographs and of the histological slice images confirmed the initial assumption
that a very high blood level due to inflammatory reaction was found for most of these 11 eliminated
sites.
4.2. Feature extraction
In order to extract discriminant features for classification, we first calculated the mean
spectrum of each spectra class. The line-shapes of the class mean spectra represent the general
spectral features in each class (intra-class spectra). The comparison of their line-shapes can help
us to reveal discriminant features between spectra of different classes (inter-class spectra). A
discriminant feature should be, for the most part, found in the spectral ranges where the
intra-class spectra has more uniform intensity values and the inter-class ones differ the most.
Here, intensity standard deviation (SD) was used to examine the intensity uniformity of the
intra-class spectra. Fig. 3 shows the mean spectra and SD
calculated for the normalized AF intensity spectra excited at 360nm and measured at
the 5th CEFS (430μm). For both HT and NHT classes, the intensity spectra
show a higher uniformity in the range between 400 and 680nm (SD ∈
[0.016, 0.0519]). Hence, a threshold value of 0.05 was fixed for locating these
“uniformity” ranges in all spectra acquired under different system
configurations.
Fig. 3
Mean±SD peak-normalized spectra excited at 368nm and measured at the CEFS of
438μm for (a) normal (n = 22), (b) hypertrophic
scar (HT, n = 22) and (c) non-hypertrophic scar (NHT, n
= 22) tissues. (d) Mean AF spectra for hypertrophic (bold line) and non-hypertrophic (dotted
line) tissues excited at 368nm and measured at the 5th CEFS. The spectra are
divided into 4 wavelength bands of 73nm width each (A :385–456nm, B :457–530nm, C
:531–605nm, D :606–679nm) with respective correlation values : 0.943, 0.999, 0.999
and 0.866.
Mean±SD peak-normalized spectra excited at 368nm and measured at the CEFS of
438μm for (a) normal (n = 22), (b) hypertrophic
scar (HT, n = 22) and (c) non-hypertrophic scar (NHT, n
= 22) tissues. (d) Mean AF spectra for hypertrophic (bold line) and non-hypertrophic (dotted
line) tissues excited at 368nm and measured at the 5th CEFS. The spectra are
divided into 4 wavelength bands of 73nm width each (A :385–456nm, B :457–530nm, C
:531–605nm, D :606–679nm) with respective correlation values : 0.943, 0.999, 0.999
and 0.866.For locating the wavelength ranges where inter-class spectra (AF and RD) differ the most, another
algorithm was developed based on the comparison of mean spectra correlations. Indeed, when two data
sets are different, they must be independent and have relatively low correlation. Thus, we divided
the class mean spectral curve into several pieces of equal size and analyzed locally their
differences by calculating piece to piece their intensity correlation. As can be seen in Fig. 3, the ranges where the class mean spectra differ more from
each other have low correlation values (in the frames of A and D). On the other hand, the piece
lengths defined for the correlation comparison can vary for revealing spectral differences at
various scales. So, the mean spectra were segmented using various sizes (4 to 73 nm) and the piece
to piece correlations were calculated at these different scales. A correlation threshold value of
0.95 was used to consider a wavelength range as “discriminant”, and therefore of
interest for carrying out the final feature extraction.Interesting spectral features to be exploited can be either intensity absolute values or any
other parameters representing the spectral line-shape like : mean intensities, under-curve areas,
intensity or area ratios, slopes [18-20]. In a number of studies, statistical methods like
Principle Component Analysis (ACP) have also been applied to the entire spectra in order to
decompose the spectra into a linear combination of orthogonal basis (uncorrelated) spectra called
Principal Components (PCs) [8, 24]. The first PC accounts for the spectral features that represents
the most variation of the original data, and the subsequent ones represent features with
progressively smaller variance. To describe a specific spectrum, a linear combination of PCs is
used, with each PC weighted by the appropriate PC score. Typically, the value of these PC scores are
used in classification but their complexity (linear combinations of numerous raw spectral
intensities) is finally not easy to deal with, especially when it comes to the discussion on the
signification of a limited exploitable number of intensity points.The feature extraction implemented here addressed spectral features characterizing the line-shape
of the normalized spectra of different tissues groups. Thus, the spectral slope was thought to be
more interesting to exploit than other features and used alone as classification features. For
calculating the slopes in each wavelength range, a linear least-square method was used to determine
a line that has the best fit to the spectral curve spanning range. Finally, 486 slope
characteristics in total were extracted from spectra (9AF + DF) measured for each scar
site.
4.3. Feature selection
As presented in [25], though many
candidate features are introduced to better represent the class domain due to unknown underlying
class probabilities, the irrelevant and redundant features potentially present in the data set may
affect the learning algorithm and reduce the classification performance. In addition, the large size
of the 486-variables data set makes the classification problem more complicated, time-consuming, and
yield a poor generalizing capability. A non-parametric significance statistical test
(Mann-Whitney-Wilcoxon) was first applied to each feature, so as to examine whether its distribution
was significantly independent for the two underlined classes. After this step, we obtain a subset of
112 features whose distribution was significantly independent for the different classes. Then, a
heuristic method of stepwise regression was implemented for further feature selection. We started
with a forward iterative selection procedure, during which variables were added one by one into the
underline subset. The added feature remained in the subset if it enhanced the classification
accuracy in terms of increasing the under-curve area in a Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC).
Otherwise, the feature was discarded. The iteration ended up when all features had been tested once.
Afterward, the features in the resulting subset were discarded one by one, in order to examine if
their abandoning would reduce the classification accuracy. If so, the discarded feature was included
again in the subset, and otherwise definitely eliminated from the pool. At the end of these
consecutive selection procedures, only 4 features were retained for the final classification (see
Table 3).
Tab. 3.
Set of the 4 selected slope features used for classification
CEFS (μm)
Excitation wavelength (nm)
AF emission wavelength bands (nm)
feature F
429
368
484 – 531
F1
438
410
528 – 599
F2
453
420
532.5 – 591.5
F3
672
410
626 – 648
F4
Set of the 4 selected slope features used for classification
4.4. Supervised classification
The efficiency of a regularized linear classifier (Fisher’s Linear Discriminant Analysis,
LDA) and a non-regularized non-linear classifier (k-Nearest Neighbors, k-NN) were comparatively
tested in the present study. Considering a linear combination of the characteristics, the first
method aims at splitting the high-dimensional input space with a separation hyperplane. This
separator is found by maximizing the ratio of between-class variance to the within-class variance.
LDA can handle classification problems where the within-class frequencies are unequal and is
well-regularized even when the data dimension is large such as in [19]. As for the k-NN, it provides non linear decision boundaries. It
projects data of a test sample onto a multidimensional feature space consisting of the data from a
labeled training set. The test sample is assigned with the most found class in its neighborhood
including the k nearest training samples. This technique is simple and can deal with problems where
data are totally confused. In addition, it can offer a good classification accuracy for low
dimension problems which may be the case in our study, because the number of features was
efficiently reduced in previous steps [18].Leave-One-Out (LOO) cross-validation method [16,
19, 26] was
performed to obtain unbiased classification results. In practice, one tissue site is excluded from
the data set and k-NN (with k = 1) or LDA classifier is applied to the rest of this data set
to generate a classifying scheme. The resulting scheme is then used to classify the previously
excluded site. The classification result is compared to that obtained by the gold standard, such as
histological analysis. We note 1 if the tissue site was correctly classified, and 0 otherwise. This
process was repeated until all sites were excluded and tested once. The classification efficiency
was asserted upon Sensibility (Se) and Specificity (Sp) calculated by the ratio of well classified
to total tissue sites.Finally, we obtained the following results for each classifier :
Se = 85.7% and Sp = 94.4% for LDA,
Se = 90.5% and Sp = 94.4% for
k-NN. The k-NN method gave the highest positive predictive and negative predictive values of
94.2% and 90.8% respectively.
5. Discussion
Looking at the final 4 most discriminant spectral features F1–F4 in Table 3, it can be noticed that none of them is relative to DR spectra. This
observation implies the light absorption and diffusion due to chromophores (such as melanin and
hemoglobin) do not contribute to the changes in DR spectra in a significantly enough way for
differentiating between HT and NHT tissues. On the contrary, the absorption and scattering effects
may partially contribute to discriminant changes in AF spectra. The curve-shape distortions of the
in vivo AF spectra can be associated to changes in namely structural organization
of the Extra-Cellular Matrix (ECM), blood volume, oxygen saturation of hemoglobin and mean depth of
blood vessels and related to hypertrophic and non-hypertrophic cicatricial skin tissues. The 4
selected slopes are those of AF intensity spectra collected at excitation wavelengths 360, 410 and
420 nm, which puts forward their specific discrimination efficiency and also the relationship
between hypertrophic tissues and the constitutive fluorophores excited at these wavelengths.Table 4 summarizes AF emission wavelength peaks and
bands of the main skin fluorophores reported by previous studies using excitations around 370, 410
and 420nm. The epidermis is an avascular stratified squamous epithelium in which
keratinocytes form the major proliferating cellular constituent. The dermis is a highly vascularized
conjunctive layer in which assemble the collagen and elastin fibers into dense arrays [19, 20]. In
hypertrophic skin, the tissue overgrowth is related to increased metabolic activity. Flavins and
NADH, two major intra-cellular co-enzyme involved in metabolism mechanisms with emission peak
respectively at 535nm and 460nm, are interesting for targeting
this mechanism change [4, 27, 28]. Porphyrins are
intermediate products in the cellular cycle characterized by two emission peaks at 635 and 670 nm
[4]. Using spectral imaging to investigate the
morphological structure changes in hypertrophic tissues, Chen et al. [21] found that collagen fiber network was disorganized and disrupted,
resulting in a lower level of second harmonic generation signal on the fluorescent image. The
distribution of elastin fibers was also disrupted but accumulated in a higher quantity in
hypertrophic tissues thus generating more intense fluorescence. Collagen and elastin are structural
proteins constituting the extracellular matrix in dermis. Their cross-links have a relatively high
quantum efficiency compared with their monomers [37]. Cross-linking of fibrils is the origin of collagen fluorescence which emission
peak (460 to 500nm) shifts with excitation (370 to 420nm). Same
observation has been reported for elastin with emission peak shifts from 470 to
500nm.
Tab. 4.
AF emission wavelength peaks and bands reported in the literature for main skin endogenous
fluorophores in epidermis and dermis (corresponding embedded layers in last row) excited at
wavelengths 370, 410 and 420 nm.
Excitation wavelength (nm)
AF emission wavelength peaks and bands
(nm)
NADH [4, 27, 28]
Flavins [4]
Porphyrins [4]
Collagen [27,
29]
Elastin [29, 30]
Keratin [28, 31, 32]
370
450–470
530–550
460
470
475
410
450–470
530–550
635, 670
490
480
420
450–470
530–550
635, 670
490
480
500
Embedded place
cells
cells
cells
dermis
dermis
epidermis
AF emission wavelength peaks and bands reported in the literature for main skin endogenous
fluorophores in epidermis and dermis (corresponding embedded layers in last row) excited at
wavelengths 370, 410 and 420 nm.When looking at the excitation-emission wavelength combinations relative to our discriminant
features shown in Table 3, we could make some potential
links between the information carried by :– F1 and the biochemical changes in the epidermis (relative to keratin), in the dermis
(elastin), and in both layers (flavins),– F2 and F3 together, and changes relative to keratin in the epidermis, collagen in the
dermis, and mainly flavins and lipopigments in both layers,– F4 and the modifications associated to porphyrins in the epidermal and dermal
cells.It is worth noting that the 3 shortest feature-relative CEFS are close from each others (429, 438
and 453 nm). Indeed, for spatially resolved spectroscopy, using multiple collecting
fibres at different CEFS can explore various tissue depths. For instance, it has been reported that
using a CEFS of 250 μm allow excitations in the wavelength range 337
– 400nm arrive at depths of 225 – 250μm in
skin tissues [33, 34]. [35] mentioned the
maximum probing depth in an homogeneous medium (localized at CEFS/2) can be defined
as . The Fig. 4 synthesizes the mean thickness (±SD)of epidermis and dermis
measured for healthy, hypertrophic and non-hypertrophic samples, and the corresponding maximal
exploring depths of our collecting probes defined by the aforementioned equation at feature-relative
excitation wavelengths (below 420nm). It can be noticed that the 4 most
discriminant features are obtained for the 4 firsts CEFS (429, 438, 453, 672
μm) among those tested here, offering a probing depth between 203 and
308μm (see Fig. 4). In this probing
depth, dermis accounts for the major part in healthy tissue. However, during the scarring process,
both epidermis and dermis thickness increases for hypertrophic and non-hypertrophic tissue. With
this structural change, the exploring tissue portion changes and exhibits in the form of measured
spectral line-shape, because fluorophores embedded in dermis give less and less contribution to the
measured AF spectra.
Fig. 4
Schematic representation of the correspondences between mean thicknesses measured for healthy,
hypertrophic (HT) and non-hypertrophic (NHT) tissue samples and the maximum penetration depth of
excitation lights below 420nm in relation with the two main discriminant CEFS 440
and 670μm
Schematic representation of the correspondences between mean thicknesses measured for healthy,
hypertrophic (HT) and non-hypertrophic (NHT) tissue samples and the maximum penetration depth of
excitation lights below 420nm in relation with the two main discriminant CEFS 440
and 670μmThe difference in fluorescence intensity between HT and NHT can also be reflected on the
extracted features, though it is not as evident as on the images. This may be due to compensation of
intensity contribution of two fluorophores excited (collagen and elastin) and emitting fluorescence
in the same wavelength range [21]. Therefore,
it could be interesting to test other spectral features, such as intensities ratio, for which the
difference might be more pronounced. This could further enhance the classification performance. The
obtained results corroborate the fact that morphological modifications in the matrix fiber network
observed through a point spectroscopy modality may be a good tool to help the clinician for
identifying scared skin tissue boundaries or for tracking skin scar formation.
6. Conclusion
In this study, the efficiency of bimodal (multi-AF and DR) spectroscopy was investigated in the
detection of hypertrophic scar tissue on a preclinical model. A specific feature extraction and
selection algorithm was developed and validated on our spectral data for classifying hypertrophic
and non-hypertrophic tissues, giving a sensibility of 90.5% and a specificity of
94.4%. Interpretation has been given relative to the discriminant features found by our
extraction/selection methods. To our knowledge, this is the first use of spectroscopic methods on
hypertrophic scar tissue. Considering this relative high diagnostic accuracy, our methods and
findings can complete the future usage of spectroscopy in clinical dermatology.
Authors: Bruce W Murphy; Rebecca J Webster; Berwin A Turlach; Christopher J Quirk; Christopher D Clay; Peter J Heenan; David D Sampson Journal: J Biomed Opt Date: 2005 Nov-Dec Impact factor: 3.170
Authors: Heloise Gisquet; Honghui Liu; W C P M Blondel; Agnes Leroux; Clothilde Latarche; J L Merlin; J F Chassagne; Didier Peiffert; François Guillemin Journal: Skin Res Technol Date: 2011-01-17 Impact factor: 2.365