BACKGROUND: Cure rates among children with brain tumors differ between low-income and high-income countries. To evaluate causes of these differences, we analyzed aspects of care provided to pediatric neuro-oncology patients in a low middle-income South American country. METHODS: Three methods were used to evaluate treatment of children with brain tumors in Paraguay: (1) a quantitative needs assessment questionnaire for local treating physicians, (2) site visits to assess 3 tertiary care centers in Asunción and a satellite clinic in an underdeveloped area, and (3) interviews with health care workers from relevant disciplines to determine their perceptions of available resources. Treatment failure was defined as abandonment of therapy, relapse, or death. RESULTS: All 3 tertiary care facilities have access to chemotherapy and pediatric oncologists but lack training and tools for neuropathology and optimal neurosurgery. The 2 public hospitals also lack access to appropriate radiological tests and timely radiotherapy. These results demonstrate disparities in Paraguay, with rates of treatment failure ranging from 37% to 83% among the 3 facilities. CONCLUSIONS: National and center-specific deficiencies in resources to manage pediatric brain tumors contribute to poor outcomes in Paraguay and suggest that both national and center-specific interventions are warranted to improve care. Disparities in Paraguay reflect different levels of governmental and philanthropic support, program development, and socio-economic status of patients and families, which must be considered when developing targeted strategies to improve management. Effective targeted interventions can serve as a model to develop pediatric brain tumor programs in other low- and middle-income countries.
BACKGROUND: Cure rates among children with brain tumors differ between low-income and high-income countries. To evaluate causes of these differences, we analyzed aspects of care provided to pediatric neuro-oncology patients in a low middle-income South American country. METHODS: Three methods were used to evaluate treatment of children with brain tumors in Paraguay: (1) a quantitative needs assessment questionnaire for local treating physicians, (2) site visits to assess 3 tertiary care centers in Asunción and a satellite clinic in an underdeveloped area, and (3) interviews with health care workers from relevant disciplines to determine their perceptions of available resources. Treatment failure was defined as abandonment of therapy, relapse, or death. RESULTS: All 3 tertiary care facilities have access to chemotherapy and pediatric oncologists but lack training and tools for neuropathology and optimal neurosurgery. The 2 public hospitals also lack access to appropriate radiological tests and timely radiotherapy. These results demonstrate disparities in Paraguay, with rates of treatment failure ranging from 37% to 83% among the 3 facilities. CONCLUSIONS: National and center-specific deficiencies in resources to manage pediatric brain tumors contribute to poor outcomes in Paraguay and suggest that both national and center-specific interventions are warranted to improve care. Disparities in Paraguay reflect different levels of governmental and philanthropic support, program development, and socio-economic status of patients and families, which must be considered when developing targeted strategies to improve management. Effective targeted interventions can serve as a model to develop pediatric brain tumor programs in other low- and middle-income countries.
Authors: A L Albright; R Sposto; E Holmes; P M Zeltzer; J L Finlay; J H Wisoff; M S Berger; R J Packer; I F Pollack Journal: Neurosurgery Date: 2000-10 Impact factor: 4.654
Authors: Mohammad H Abu Arja; Joseph R Stanek; Andrés E Morales La Madrid; Alvaro Lassaletta; Ute Bartels; Ibrahim Qaddoumi; Jonathan L Finlay; Diana S Osorio Journal: Childs Nerv Syst Date: 2018-11-14 Impact factor: 1.475
Authors: Julia M Challinor; Annette L Galassi; Majeda A Al-Ruzzieh; Jean Bosco Bigirimana; Lori Buswell; Winnie K W So; Allison Burg Steinberg; Makeda Williams Journal: J Glob Oncol Date: 2016-02-03
Authors: Michala Burges; Ibrahim Qaddoumi; Rachel C Brennan; Lisa Krull; Natasha Sahr; Carlos Rodriguez-Galindo; Sima Jeha; Matthew W Wilson Journal: JCO Glob Oncol Date: 2020-10
Authors: Daniel C Moreira; Revathi Rajagopal; Regina M Navarro-Martin Del Campo; Ana C Polanco; Ana Patricia Alcasabas; Luis A Arredondo-Navarro; Danny Campos; Sandro Casavilca-Zambrano; Rosdali Yesenia Diaz Coronado; Nor Faizal; Dharmendra Ganesan; Syed Ahmer Hamid; Rafeah Khan; Kathleen Khu; Jasmin Loh; Marissa Lukban; Tatiana Negreiros; Estuardo Pineda; Nausheen Yaqoob; Nida Zia; Amar Gajjar; Carlos Rodriguez-Galindo; Ibrahim Qaddoumi Journal: JCO Glob Oncol Date: 2020-04
Authors: Paula Aristizabal; Luke P Burns; Nikhil V Kumar; Bianca P Perdomo; Rebeca Rivera-Gomez; Mario A Ornelas; David Gonda; Denise Malicki; Courtney D Thornburg; William Roberts; Michael L Levy; John R Crawford Journal: JCO Glob Oncol Date: 2020-11