Specific and Rapid Detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis Complex in Clinical Samples by Polymerase Chain Reaction.

Background. Tuberculosis, a global health problem and highly prevalent in India, has always been a serious problem with respect to definitive diagnosis. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) techniques are now widely used for early detection and species differentiation of mycobacteria, but mostly with their own limitations. We aim to detect and differentiate Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) infections by choosing appropriate target sequences, ideally present in all mycobacterial species (MTB complex) and absent in others. Methods. Amplification of three target sequences from unrelated genes, namely, hsp 65 (165 bp), dnaJ (365 bp), and insertion element IS 6110 (541 bp) by PCR was carried out in clinical samples from suspected cases of tuberculosis/ mycobacterioses and healthy controls. Results. The sensitivity of this method ranged from 73.33% to 84.61%, and the specificity was 80%. The PCR method was significantly better (P = 0.03 and P = 0.009) than both smear and culture methods. Conclusion. Our trimarker-based PCR method could specifically detect M. tuberculosis and MTB complex infection from that of major pathogenic NTM and nonpathogenic mycobacteria. This method, by well distinguishing between MTB complex and NTM, presented a fast and accurate method to detect and diagnose mycobacterial infections more efficiently and could thereby help in better patient management particularly considering the increase in mycobacterial infections due to emergence of NTM over the past decades.

1. Introduction

Tuberculosis is a major public health problem with a total of 9.2 million new cases and 1.7 million deaths from tuberculosis (TB) in 2006. India accounts for one-fifth of the global TB burden (WHO 2008), which has been on the rise due to multidrug-resistant and highly virulent strains of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) [1] and combined effect of HIV. An accurate diagnosis of tuberculosis is desirable before the start of anti-tuberculosis therapy [2]. The laboratory diagnosis of Mtb depending on acid-fast bacillus (AFB) smear can yield a result within 24 h. However, smear is not very specific for Mtb and also requires 103 to 104 organisms per mL of sputum. Bacterial culture is superior to AFB smear, both in terms of sensitivity and specificity. But, since mycobacteria have very strict growth requirements, culture-based diagnostic methods are slow. Further, diagnoses involving radiological examinations and Tuberculin test help to detect the disease to some extent, but are not very reliable in case of extrapulmonary tuberculosis. The BACTEC system however, gives a very quick result compared to culture, but it is expensive and involves handling of radioisotopes (BACTEC 460). The fluorometric BACTEC MGIT 960 is fast, efficient, and sensitive but expensive to be used in poor economies. In view of these, accurate and early diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) is a critical step in the management and control of TB. Polymerase chain reaction has so far been a very useful tool for rapid detection of mycobacterial DNA in clinical specimens such as sputum, bronchial lavage, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), and ascitic fluid. However, in-house tests vary widely in their accuracy and factors that contribute to heterogeneity in test accuracy, are not well characterized. Definitive diagnosis of tuberculosis and mycobacterioses (nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) infections) has always been a serious problem. These methods also have their own limitations due to region-specific variations in the genome of mycobacteria [3-5]. Our study describes a PCR assay using MTB-complex-specific DNA markers encompassing 165, 365, and 541 bp target fragments of three unrelated genes, namely, hsp 65, dnaJ and insertion element IS 6110, respectively, of M. tuberculosis in tuberculosis suspected patients from Kolkata, India. Considering the increase in mycobacterial infections resulting from the emergence of NTM over the past decades, there is also need for a method that can detect virtually any deep-seated mycobacterial organism present in small numbers in suspected clinical samples irrespective of the mycobacterial species affiliation.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Subjects

The study samples were suspected cases of pulmonary tuberculosis visiting the Chest Outpatient Department of Calcutta National Medical College and Hospital (CNMCH). This study was approved by the Ethical Committees of the institutions involved, and all the subjects signed informed consent documents before entering into this study. A total of 60 subjects, including suspected cases and healthy controls were studied. The suspected TB cases were further categorized into three groups (Group I–III) based on laboratory diagnostic results (AFB-smear, culture and antero-posterior chest X-ray), clinical symptoms, and past history. The clinical and demographic data on studied subjects is presented in Table 1. Five to ten mL of early morning sputum samples were collected from all the subjects. All the samples were smeared and screened with conventional microbiological test such as Ziehl-Neelsen acid fast staining for recording smear positivity and further cultured on Lowenstein-Jensen slants according to standard method. Group I (n = 26) had cases, which were positive by smear Ziehl-Neelsen staining and also culture positive, while Group II (n = 15) had smear negative but culture and radiologically positive samples. In some patients (n = 9), the laboratory diagnosis for Mtb infection was negative but based on their clinical symptoms, they were considered as having other respiratory diseases (than PTB) or mycobacterioses (Group III). However, these patients did not have any past history of tuberculosis and subsequent treatment. The healthy control subjects (designated as Gr IV, n = 10) were with no clinical symptoms or history and were diagnosed negative for Mtb infection (bacteriologically negative). All the 60 samples were further analyzed by PCR method.

Table 1

Characteristics of clinical samples and controls based on conventional diagnostic methods and other clinical symptoms.

Category	Status of the samples				Samples (n)	Age (Range)	Sex (Male/Female) (n)
	*AFB staining (Z-N)#	Culture	X-ray	Other
Group I	+	+	+	+	26	14–72	19/7
Group II	−	+	+	+	15	14–65	10/5
Group III	−	−	−	+	9	14–75	4/5
Group IV	−	−	−	−	10	15–60	8/2

*AFB: acid fast bacilli; #Z-N: ziehl-neelsen; +: positive; −: negative.

2.2. Isolation of DNA from Sputum Samples

The sputum samples were decontaminated followed by DNA isolation according to the previously published method [6].

2.3. PCR Amplification

The PCR amplification targeted two conserved regions and one insertion element of mycobacterial genome. A 165 bp conserved region of a gene coding for 65 k Dalton antigen protein of M. tuberculosis was amplified using primer set published previously [7]. Similarly, a 365 bp region (between sequence position 1377–1741) of dnaJ gene of M. tuberculosis was amplified using genus-specific primers described earlier by Takewaki et al. (1993) [8]. The 541 bp region within insertion element IS6110 of M. tuberculosis was amplified using oligonucleotides designated as Pt-8 and Pt-9 by Kox et al. 1994 [9]. Ten microliters of the amplified PCR product were fractionated electrophoretically on a 2% agarose gel, stained with ethidium bromide and visualized under UV-transilluminator for the accuracy and specificity of PCR amplification, using PhiX174 HaeIII digest as gene ruler. All the PCR amplifications were subjected to internal laboratory standardization using template DNA from M. tuberculosis reference strain H37Rv as positive control (Figure 1). Briefly, 50–100 ng of purified total cellular DNA was amplified with thermostable Taq DNA polymerase in Gene Amp PCR System 9700 (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). To establish positivity, we added 50 uL of reaction mixture containing 10 mm Tris-HCl (pH 8.3), 50 mm KCl, 1.5–2.5 mm MgCl2, 0.01% (w/v) gelatin, 20–50 pmol of respective primers (described earlier), 2.0–2.5 nmol of each of the four deoxynucleoside triphosphates (dATP, dCTP, dGTP and dTTP), 1 U of Taq DNA polymerase (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). The PCR cycle conditions were slight modifications of the previously published one for 165 bp hsp gene fragment (94°C for 20 s to denature the DNA, then cooled to 63°C for 20 s, heating to 72°C for 1 min for extension, cycle repeated 30 times with final incubation at 72°C for 10 min), for 365 bp dnaJ gene fragment (94°C for 30 s to denature the DNA, then cooled to 65°C for 60 s, heating to 72°C for 2.5 min for extension, cycle repeated 35 times with final incubation at 72°C for 10 min) and for 541 bp IS6110 sequence (94°C for 60 s to denature the DNA, then cooled to 65°C for 1.5 min, heating to 72°C for 3.5 min for extension, cycle repeated 38 times with final incubation at 72°C for 10 min) of mycobacterial DNA. Figure 2 shows the amplification of all the above mentioned genetic markers in clinical samples.

Figure 1

PCR showing 165, 365, and 541 bp fragment of M. tuberculosis reference strain H37Rv (positive control). Lane 1: gene marker, Lane 2: 541 bp amplicon, Lane 3: 365 bp amplicon, and Lane 4: 165 bp amplicon.

Figure 2

PCR showing 165, 365, and 541 bp target sequence amplified in case samples. Lane 1- gene marker, Lanes: 2–6, 165 bp amplicon, Lanes: 7–11; 541 bp amplicon, Lanes: 12–16, 365 bp amplicon.

2.4. Statistical Analysis

The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) and Chi-square tests were calculated using ACASTAT Software [10]. The results of 2 × 2 Chi-square tests and P values were uncorrected ones, unless otherwise indicated. A P value ≤0.05 was considered statistically significant.

3. Results

Out of 60 studied samples, 26 were positive by smear Ziehl-Neelsen staining and were also culture positive (Gr I). We detected 22 samples of Gr I as positive by PCR (84.62%). Out of 15 samples of Group II (smear negative but culture and radiologically positive), 11 samples (73.33%) turned out positive by PCR method. Hence, our trimarker system-based polymerase chain reaction detected 33 (80.5%) positive out of 41 patients (combined Gr I & II). We also found 7 samples (77.78%) out of 9 from the III Group as positive for 365 bp dnaJ gene (but not for rest two genes) indicating that they might be cases with mycobacterioses but not tuberculosis. In the controls (Gr IV, n = 10), none was PCR positive for any of the 3 markers used in this study. However, there were 4 samples in Gr I and 2 in Gr II, which could not be amplified for IS6110, possibly due to the presence of PCR inhibitors. Similarly, 2 samples in Gr II did not amplify for hsp 65 gene marker. The PCR amplification results for Gr III clearly demonstrated infection with nontuberculous mycobacteria. The specificity of this study was 80%, and sensitivity range was 73.33% (Gr.II) to 84.61% (Gr.I). Also, the PPV and NPV were 77.78–91.67% and 66.67–80%, respectively. When compared to the smear and culture methods, the results were statistically significant (P = 0.030 and P = 0.009, resp.), showing that the PCR technique had a significantly higher ability to detect tuberculosis caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex. The results of this study are presented in Tables 2, 3, and 4.

Table 2

Detection of mycobacterial infection by polymerase chain reaction.

Category	Samples (n)	PCR results					No PCR- amplification		dnaJ
		Positive n (%)	Sensitivity  (%)	Specificity   (%)	PPV (%)	NPV (%)	For (n [%])
							IS6110	hsp 65
Group I	26	22 (84.62)*	84.6	80	91.67	66.67	4 (15.38)
Group II	15	11 (73.33)*	73.33	80	84.62	66.67	2 (13.33)	2 (13.33)
Group III	9	7 (77.78) #	77.78	80	77.78	80			2 (22.22)
Group IV	10	0 (0)	—	—	—	—	10 (100)	10 (100)	10 (100)

*Indicates positive result for all three markers; #indicates positive result for only dnaJ; PPV: positive predictive value; NPV: negative predictive value.

Table 3

Comparison of PCR and smear methods for detection of mycobacterial infections.

Samples	Smear n (%)	PCR n (%)	P
Positive	26 (43.33)	42 (70)	0.030*
Negative	34 (56.66)	18 (30)

*P value < 0.05.

Table 4

Comparison of PCR and culture methods for detection of mycobacterial infections.

Samples	Culture n (%)	PCR n (%)	P
Positive	41 (68.33)	42 (70)	0.009*
Negative	19 (31.67)	18 (30)

*P value < 0.05.

4. Discussion

Pulmonary tuberculosis is one of the highly infectious diseases and mostly prevalent in India, but it still bears with it the problem of definitive diagnosis. PCR amplification of mycobacterial DNA is a highly sensitive and specific technique to detect Tuberculosis. This also performs better than smear (which needs >10,000 bacilli/mL sample for detection) as well as culture method (which has restricted growth conditions). In these cases, PCR helps to diagnose whether the positivity (smear or culture) is due to MTB complex bacteria or other nontuberculous infection. In case of negative Ziehl-Neelsen staining, PCR helps to confirm the diagnosis. Our Data clearly showed that there is a significant difference between smear and PCR (P = 0.030) and between culture and PCR (P = 0.009) methods, further signifying that the PCR method has proved better than smear and culture methods in this study. However, many of the mycobacterial PCR assays employing species-specific primers allow for the detection of a single or limited number of mycobacterial species [11-16]. The efficiency and success of any rapid diagnostic PCR method depend on the appropriate DNA target sequences chosen for amplification. In this study, the marker system chosen is ideally applicable to most of the mycobacterial species (M. tuberculosis, M. bovis, M. bovis BCG, M. africanum, and M. microti) of MTB complex. The Success of this method for the detection and identification of mycobacteria further increased due to inclusion of one target sequence (dnaJ gene) for NTM. A meta-analysis published recently [17] demonstrated that use of IS6110 as a target of amplification was significantly associated with increased accuracy of the PCR-based detection test. However, although this sequence is present in multiple copies in the bacterial genome, some strains from certain parts of the world lack it [18, 19], and this may cause false-negative results further affecting the sensitivity of the assay. A possible solution to this problem would be to amplify more than one target sequences. Hence, we have also used 165 and 365 bp target DNA sequences in our study. The 365 bp dnaJ gene marker is a genus-specific, one which has a broader spectrum of detection and can be amplified from all mycobacterial (including nontuberculous and non-pathogenic) species, while the 541 bp IS6110 and 165 bp 65 kDa antigen protein gene sequences are amplifiable from almost all the mycobacterial species of MTB complex (but not from NTM) [7, 9], thus accounting for their higher sensitivity. So far no single target sequence has provided 100% sensitivity and a total absence of false positive when used alone. It was also observed that multiplex PCR did not contribute to increase the diagnostic accuracy in a large meta-analysis study [17]. Our trimarker based PCR method could sensitively and specifically detect clinically important mycobacterial infections such as those of M. tuberculosis, M. tuberculosis complex other than M. tuberculosis (especially M. bovis) and differentiate from major pathogenic NTM and nonpathogenic mycobacteria. Hence, this method presented a fast and efficient technique to diagnose tuberculosis infection and differentiate it from other mycobacterial infections in order to help better patient management. However, since some samples could not be amplified properly for certain DNA sequences in this study, it is important to consider PCR inhibitors and the sensitivity of the assay could further improve with effective control of such inhibitors.

5. Conclusions

The study presents a trimarker based PCR technique, which also applies to a wide variety of clinical samples and hence evaluated as a useful technique in the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis. This method is very useful in cases where Ziehl-Neelsen staining and/or culture results are negative. By including one relatively less-specific marker (365 bp dnaJ gene), this PCR method also facilitates discrimination of MTB complex-specific infection from nontuberculous or nonpathogenic mycobacterial infections. The fact that DNA amplification can detect mycobacterial DNA sequences in the presence of excess amounts of human DNA makes it especially useful when quick results are required in certain clinical circumstances. This may also be useful when large-scale screening of mycobacteria is required, such as in parts of the countries where tuberculosis is still endemic and remains a major public health problem.