OBJECTIVES: Non-physician cataract surgeons (NPCS) provide cataract surgical services in some Sub-Saharan African (SSA) countries. However, their training, placement, legal framework and supervision have not been documented. We sought to do so to inform decision-making regarding future training. METHODS: Standard questionnaires were sent to national eye coordinators and other ophthalmologic leaders in Africa to collect information. Face-to-face interviews were conducted at training programmes in Ethiopia, Tanzania and Kenya, and email interviews were conducted with directors at training programmes in the Gambia and Malawi. RESULTS: Responses were provided for 31/39 (79%) countries to which questionnaires were sent. These countries represent about 90% of the population of SSA. Overall, 17 countries have one or more NPCS; two-thirds of the total 245 NPCS are found in only three countries. Thirty-six percent of NPCS work alone, but a formal functioning supervision system was reported to be present in only one country. The training centres are similar and face similar challenges. CONCLUSIONS: There is considerable variation across SSA in the use and acceptance of NPCS. The placement and support of NPCS after training generally does not follow expectations, and training centres have little role in this. Overall, there was no consensus on whether the cadre, as it is currently viewed, is necessary, desirable or will contribute to addressing cataract surgical needs in SSA.
OBJECTIVES: Non-physician cataract surgeons (NPCS) provide cataract surgical services in some Sub-Saharan African (SSA) countries. However, their training, placement, legal framework and supervision have not been documented. We sought to do so to inform decision-making regarding future training. METHODS: Standard questionnaires were sent to national eye coordinators and other ophthalmologic leaders in Africa to collect information. Face-to-face interviews were conducted at training programmes in Ethiopia, Tanzania and Kenya, and email interviews were conducted with directors at training programmes in the Gambia and Malawi. RESULTS: Responses were provided for 31/39 (79%) countries to which questionnaires were sent. These countries represent about 90% of the population of SSA. Overall, 17 countries have one or more NPCS; two-thirds of the total 245 NPCS are found in only three countries. Thirty-six percent of NPCS work alone, but a formal functioning supervision system was reported to be present in only one country. The training centres are similar and face similar challenges. CONCLUSIONS: There is considerable variation across SSA in the use and acceptance of NPCS. The placement and support of NPCS after training generally does not follow expectations, and training centres have little role in this. Overall, there was no consensus on whether the cadre, as it is currently viewed, is necessary, desirable or will contribute to addressing cataract surgical needs in SSA.
Keywords:
cataract; cataracte; cataratas; chirurgiens non médecins de la cataracte; cirujanos no‐médicos; delegación de funciones; délégation des tâches; human resources; mid‐level personnel; non‐physician cataract surgeons; personal intermedio; personnel de niveau intermédiaire; recursos humanos; ressources humaines; task‐shifting
Authors: Jennifer J Palmer; Farai Chinanayi; Alice Gilbert; Devan Pillay; Samantha Fox; Jyoti Jaggernath; Kovin Naidoo; Ronnie Graham; Daksha Patel; Karl Blanchet Journal: Hum Resour Health Date: 2014-08-15
Authors: Jennifer J Palmer; Farai Chinanayi; Alice Gilbert; Devan Pillay; Samantha Fox; Jyoti Jaggernath; Kovin Naidoo; Ronnie Graham; Daksha Patel; Karl Blanchet Journal: Hum Resour Health Date: 2014-08-15
Authors: Glenn Douglas Guest; Elizabeth McLeod; William R G Perry; Vilami Tangi; Joao Pedro; Ponifasio Ponifasio; Johnny Hedson; Jemesa Tudravu; Douglas Pikacha; Eric Vreede; Basil Leodoro; Noah Tapaua; James Kong; Bwabwa Oten; Deacon Teapa; Stephanie Korin; Leona Wilson; Samson Mesol; Kabiri Tuneti; John G Meara; David A Watters Journal: BMJ Glob Health Date: 2017-11-25
Authors: Nikolaos Mavrakanas; Kazim A Dhalla; Jerry Jecha; Imani Kapesa; Capucine Odouard; Ian Murdoch Journal: Indian J Ophthalmol Date: 2016-11 Impact factor: 1.848