PURPOSE: Milling and micronization of particles are routinely employed in the pharmaceutical industry to obtain small particles with desired particle size characteristics. The aim of this study is to demonstrate that particle shape is an important factor affecting the fracture mechanism in milling. METHODS: Needle-shaped crystals of the β polymorph of D-mannitol were prepared from recrystallization in water. A portion of the recrystallized materials was ball-milled. Unmilled and milled sieved fractions of recrystallized D-mannitol were analyzed by dynamic image analysis (DIA) and inverse gas chromatography (IGC) at finite concentration to explain the breakage/fracture behavior. RESULTS: In the process of ball-milling, D-mannitol preferentially fractured along their shortest axis, exposing (011) plane with increased hydrophilicity and increased bounding rectangular aspect ratio. This is in contrary to attachment energy modeling which predicts a fracture mechanism across the (010) plane with increased hydrophobicity, and small change in particle shape. CONCLUSIONS: Crystal size, and more importantly, crystal shape and facet-specific mechanical properties, can dictate the fracture/cleavage behavior of organic crystalline materials. Thorough understanding of the crystal slip systems, combining attachment energy prediction with particle shape and surface characterization using DIA and IGC, are important in understanding fracture behavior of organic crystalline solids in milling and micronization.
PURPOSE: Milling and micronization of particles are routinely employed in the pharmaceutical industry to obtain small particles with desired particle size characteristics. The aim of this study is to demonstrate that particle shape is an important factor affecting the fracture mechanism in milling. METHODS: Needle-shaped crystals of the β polymorph of D-mannitol were prepared from recrystallization in water. A portion of the recrystallized materials was ball-milled. Unmilled and milled sieved fractions of recrystallized D-mannitol were analyzed by dynamic image analysis (DIA) and inverse gas chromatography (IGC) at finite concentration to explain the breakage/fracture behavior. RESULTS: In the process of ball-milling, D-mannitol preferentially fractured along their shortest axis, exposing (011) plane with increased hydrophilicity and increased bounding rectangular aspect ratio. This is in contrary to attachment energy modeling which predicts a fracture mechanism across the (010) plane with increased hydrophobicity, and small change in particle shape. CONCLUSIONS: Crystal size, and more importantly, crystal shape and facet-specific mechanical properties, can dictate the fracture/cleavage behavior of organic crystalline materials. Thorough understanding of the crystal slip systems, combining attachment energy prediction with particle shape and surface characterization using DIA and IGC, are important in understanding fracture behavior of organic crystalline solids in milling and micronization.
Authors: Raimundo Ho; Steven J Hinder; John F Watts; Sarah E Dilworth; Daryl R Williams; Jerry Y Y Heng Journal: Int J Pharm Date: 2009-12-16 Impact factor: 5.875
Authors: Umang V Shah; Dolapo Olusanmi; Ajit S Narang; Munir A Hussain; Michael J Tobyn; Steve J Hinder; Jerry Y Y Heng Journal: Pharm Res Date: 2014-07-19 Impact factor: 4.200
Authors: Mohammad A Azad; Gerard Capellades; Allison B Wang; David M Klee; Gregory Hammersmith; Kersten Rapp; David Brancazio; Allan S Myerson Journal: AAPS PharmSciTech Date: 2021-03-11 Impact factor: 3.246
Authors: Jasdip S Koner; Ali Rajabi-Siahboomi; James Bowen; Yvonne Perrie; Daniel Kirby; Afzal R Mohammed Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2015-11-10 Impact factor: 4.379