Characteristics of children and adolescents in a psychiatric hospital and a corrections facility.

Popular opinion holds that youngsters in corrections programs are delinquents in need of reform, whereas youngsters in psychiatric settings have mental health problems and need therapy. Yet some literature suggests that youth in the two settings may not differ greatly in their mental health status. The authors compared demographic, emotional, and behavioral characteristics of youngsters placed in public psychiatric hospital and corrections settings, and they found few differences. Child Behavior Checklist scores for social competence and total problems were high and quite similar for youngsters in the two settings. White children scored significantly worse than black children on Child Behavior Checklist Internalizing, Externalizing, and total problems in corrections settings but not in the psychiatric hospital. Moreover, race was the only variable that predicted the site in which youth were placed. The findings suggest a need to study (1) the mental health needs of youngsters in nonmental health settings and (2) the procedures by which youth are assigned to service settings.