BACKGROUND: Predictive models for swallowing dysfunction were developed previously and showed the potential of improved intensity-modulated radiotherapy to reduce the risk of swallowing dysfunction. Still the risk is high. The aim of this study was to determine the potential of swallowing-sparing (SW) intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT) in head and neck cancer (HNC) for reducing the risk of swallowing dysfunction relative to currently used photon therapy. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Twenty-five patients with oropharyngeal (n = 21) and hypopharyngeal (n = 4) cancer received primary radiotherapy, including bilateral neck irradiation, using standard (ST) intensity-modulated photon therapy (IMRT). Prophylactic (54 Gy) and therapeutic (70 Gy) target volumes were defined. The dose to the parotid and submandibular glands was reduced as much as possible. Four additional radiotherapy plans were created for each patient: SW-IMRT, ST-IMPT, 3-beam SW-IMPT (3B-SW-IMPT) and 7-beam SW-IMPT (7B-SW-IMPT). All plans were optimized similarly, with additional attempts to spare the swallowing organs at risk (SWOARs) in the SW plans. Probabilities of swallowing dysfunction were calculated with recently developed predictive models. RESULTS: All plans complied with standard HNC radiotherapy objectives. The mean parotid gland doses were similar for the ST and SW photon plans, but clearly lower in all IMPT plans (ipsilateral parotid gland ST-IMRT: 46 Gy, 7B-SW-IMPT: 29 Gy). The mean dose in the SWOARs was lowest with SW-IMPT, in particular with 7B-SW-IMPT (supraglottic larynx ST-IMRT: 60 Gy, 7B-SW-IMPT: 40 Gy). The observed dose reductions to the SWOARs translated into substantial overall reductions in normal tissue complication risks for different swallowing dysfunction endpoints. Compared with ST-IMRT, the risk of physician-rated grade 2-4 swallowing dysfunction was reduced on average by 8.8% (95% CI 6.5-11.1%) with SW-IMRT, and by 17.2% (95% CI: 12.7-21.7%) with 7B-SW-IMPT. CONCLUSION: SWOAR-sparing with proton therapy has the potential to substantially reduce the risk of swallowing dysfunction compared to similar treatment with photons.
BACKGROUND: Predictive models for swallowing dysfunction were developed previously and showed the potential of improved intensity-modulated radiotherapy to reduce the risk of swallowing dysfunction. Still the risk is high. The aim of this study was to determine the potential of swallowing-sparing (SW) intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT) in head and neck cancer (HNC) for reducing the risk of swallowing dysfunction relative to currently used photon therapy. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Twenty-five patients with oropharyngeal (n = 21) and hypopharyngeal (n = 4) cancer received primary radiotherapy, including bilateral neck irradiation, using standard (ST) intensity-modulated photon therapy (IMRT). Prophylactic (54 Gy) and therapeutic (70 Gy) target volumes were defined. The dose to the parotid and submandibular glands was reduced as much as possible. Four additional radiotherapy plans were created for each patient: SW-IMRT, ST-IMPT, 3-beam SW-IMPT (3B-SW-IMPT) and 7-beam SW-IMPT (7B-SW-IMPT). All plans were optimized similarly, with additional attempts to spare the swallowing organs at risk (SWOARs) in the SW plans. Probabilities of swallowing dysfunction were calculated with recently developed predictive models. RESULTS: All plans complied with standard HNC radiotherapy objectives. The mean parotid gland doses were similar for the ST and SW photon plans, but clearly lower in all IMPT plans (ipsilateral parotid gland ST-IMRT: 46 Gy, 7B-SW-IMPT: 29 Gy). The mean dose in the SWOARs was lowest with SW-IMPT, in particular with 7B-SW-IMPT (supraglottic larynx ST-IMRT: 60 Gy, 7B-SW-IMPT: 40 Gy). The observed dose reductions to the SWOARs translated into substantial overall reductions in normal tissue complication risks for different swallowing dysfunction endpoints. Compared with ST-IMRT, the risk of physician-rated grade 2-4 swallowing dysfunction was reduced on average by 8.8% (95% CI 6.5-11.1%) with SW-IMRT, and by 17.2% (95% CI: 12.7-21.7%) with 7B-SW-IMPT. CONCLUSION: SWOAR-sparing with proton therapy has the potential to substantially reduce the risk of swallowing dysfunction compared to similar treatment with photons.
Authors: R Mazzola; F Ricchetti; A Fiorentino; S Fersino; N Giaj Levra; S Naccarato; G Sicignano; S Albanese; G Di Paola; D Alterio; R Ruggieri; F Alongi Journal: Br J Radiol Date: 2014-10-28 Impact factor: 3.039
Authors: G Brandon Gunn; Pierre Blanchard; Adam S Garden; X Ronald Zhu; C David Fuller; Abdallah S Mohamed; William H Morrison; Jack Phan; Beth M Beadle; Heath D Skinner; Erich M Sturgis; Merrill S Kies; Kate A Hutcheson; David I Rosenthal; Radhe Mohan; Michael T Gillin; Steven J Frank Journal: Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys Date: 2016-02-12 Impact factor: 7.038
Authors: Olivier M Vanderveken; Petr Szturz; Pol Specenier; Marco C Merlano; Marco Benasso; Dirk Van Gestel; Kristien Wouters; Carl Van Laer; Danielle Van den Weyngaert; Marc Peeters; Jan Vermorken Journal: Oncologist Date: 2015-12-28
Authors: Paul B Romesser; Oren Cahlon; Eli Scher; Ying Zhou; Sean L Berry; Alisa Rybkin; Kevin M Sine; Shikui Tang; Eric J Sherman; Richard Wong; Nancy Y Lee Journal: Radiother Oncol Date: 2016-02-08 Impact factor: 6.280
Authors: Adepitan A Owosho; SaeHee K Yom; Zhiqiang Han; Kevin Sine; Nancy Y Lee; Joseph M Huryn; Cherry L Estilo Journal: Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Date: 2016-07-19
Authors: Anna Lee; Julie Kang; Yao Yu; Sean McBride; Nadeem Riaz; Marc Cohen; Eric Sherman; Loren Michel; Nancy Lee; C Jillian Tsai Journal: Int J Part Ther Date: 2019-04-22
Authors: Jianzhong Cao; Xiaodong Zhang; Bo Jiang; Jiayun Chen; Xiaochun Wang; Li Wang; Narayan Sahoo; X Ronald Zhu; Rong Ye; Pierre Blanchard; Adam S Garden; C David Fuller; G Brandon Gunn; Steven J Frank Journal: Radiother Oncol Date: 2021-04-08 Impact factor: 6.901
Authors: Houda Bahig; Brandon G Gunn; Adam S Garden; Rong Ye; Kate Hutcheson; David I Rosenthal; Jack Phan; Clifton D Fuller; William H Morrison; Jay Paul Reddy; Sweet Ping Ng; Neil D Gross; Erich M Sturgis; Renata Ferrarotto; Maura Gillison; Steven J Frank Journal: Int J Part Ther Date: 2021-06-25