OBJECTIVE: To compare the cost-effectiveness of three different strategies for long-term monitoring of antiretroviral therapy (ART) failure and regimen switching in sub-Saharan Africa: a symptom-based approach, or monitoring of either CD4 cell counts or plasma viral load (pVL). DESIGN: Markov model. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Hypothetical HIV-infected adult population who began first-line ART and subsequently had up to 6 years of follow-up. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Total cost, life expectancy and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). RESULTS: A symptom-based approach yielded a life expectancy of 64.0 months at a total cost of US$ 4028 per person. All laboratory-based strategies, at testing intervals of 6 or 12 months, were cost-saving and improved life expectancy, compared with a symptom-based approach. The life-expectancy gain was larger for pVL than for CD4 strategies at 6-monthly (2.3 and 0.9 months, respectively) and 12-monthly testing (2.0 and 0.8 months, respectively). Cost-savings of 6-monthly pVL or CD4 testing were similar (US$ 630 and 621, respectively), whereas 12-monthly CD4 cell counts were more cost-saving than 12-monthly pVL (US$ 1132 and 880, respectively). Testing every 12 months - rather than every 6 months - decreased the ICER by 102% for CD4 cell count and 67% for pVL. These findings were robust to a wide range of deterministic sensitivity analyses, but were sensitive to the specificity and costs of diagnostic tests. CONCLUSION: Additional diagnostic costs are balanced by cost-savings from avoiding unnecessary switching due to misdiagnosis of ART failure. Routine pVL monitoring may be preferred as a replacement for CD4 cell counts because of its additional public-health advantages in preventing drug-resistance, supporting adherence and reducing HIV transmission.
OBJECTIVE: To compare the cost-effectiveness of three different strategies for long-term monitoring of antiretroviral therapy (ART) failure and regimen switching in sub-Saharan Africa: a symptom-based approach, or monitoring of either CD4 cell counts or plasma viral load (pVL). DESIGN: Markov model. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Hypothetical HIV-infected adult population who began first-line ART and subsequently had up to 6 years of follow-up. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Total cost, life expectancy and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). RESULTS: A symptom-based approach yielded a life expectancy of 64.0 months at a total cost of US$ 4028 per person. All laboratory-based strategies, at testing intervals of 6 or 12 months, were cost-saving and improved life expectancy, compared with a symptom-based approach. The life-expectancy gain was larger for pVL than for CD4 strategies at 6-monthly (2.3 and 0.9 months, respectively) and 12-monthly testing (2.0 and 0.8 months, respectively). Cost-savings of 6-monthly pVL or CD4 testing were similar (US$ 630 and 621, respectively), whereas 12-monthly CD4 cell counts were more cost-saving than 12-monthly pVL (US$ 1132 and 880, respectively). Testing every 12 months - rather than every 6 months - decreased the ICER by 102% for CD4 cell count and 67% for pVL. These findings were robust to a wide range of deterministic sensitivity analyses, but were sensitive to the specificity and costs of diagnostic tests. CONCLUSION: Additional diagnostic costs are balanced by cost-savings from avoiding unnecessary switching due to misdiagnosis of ART failure. Routine pVL monitoring may be preferred as a replacement for CD4 cell counts because of its additional public-health advantages in preventing drug-resistance, supporting adherence and reducing HIV transmission.
Authors: Paul K Drain; Emily P Hyle; Farzad Noubary; Kenneth A Freedberg; Douglas Wilson; William R Bishai; William Rodriguez; Ingrid V Bassett Journal: Lancet Infect Dis Date: 2013-12-10 Impact factor: 25.071
Authors: Paul K Drain; Jienchi Dorward; Andrew Bender; Lorraine Lillis; Francesco Marinucci; Jilian Sacks; Anna Bershteyn; David S Boyle; Jonathan D Posner; Nigel Garrett Journal: Clin Microbiol Rev Date: 2019-05-15 Impact factor: 26.132
Authors: Andrew Phillips; Amir Shroufi; Lara Vojnov; Jennifer Cohn; Teri Roberts; Tom Ellman; Kimberly Bonner; Christine Rousseau; Geoff Garnett; Valentina Cambiano; Fumiyo Nakagawa; Deborah Ford; Loveleen Bansi-Matharu; Alec Miners; Jens D Lundgren; Jeffrey W Eaton; Rosalind Parkes-Ratanshi; Zachary Katz; David Maman; Nathan Ford; Marco Vitoria; Meg Doherty; David Dowdy; Brooke Nichols; Maurine Murtagh; Meghan Wareham; Kara M Palamountain; Christine Chakanyuka Musanhu; Wendy Stevens; David Katzenstein; Andrea Ciaranello; Ruanne Barnabas; R Scott Braithwaite; Eran Bendavid; Kusum J Nathoo; David van de Vijver; David P Wilson; Charles Holmes; Anna Bershteyn; Simon Walker; Elliot Raizes; Ilesh Jani; Lisa J Nelson; Rosanna Peeling; Fern Terris-Prestholt; Joseph Murungu; Tsitsi Mutasa-Apollo; Timothy B Hallett; Paul Revill Journal: Nature Date: 2015-12-03 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Janne Estill; Matthias Egger; Nello Blaser; Luisa Salazar Vizcaya; Daniela Garone; Robin Wood; Jennifer Campbell; Timothy B Hallett; Olivia Keiser Journal: AIDS Date: 2013-06-01 Impact factor: 4.177
Authors: Daniel Keebler; Paul Revill; Scott Braithwaite; Andrew Phillips; Nello Blaser; Annick Borquez; Valentina Cambiano; Andrea Ciaranello; Janne Estill; Richard Gray; Andrew Hill; Olivia Keiser; Jason Kessler; Nicolas A Menzies; Kimberly A Nucifora; Luisa Salazar Vizcaya; Simon Walker; Alex Welte; Philippa Easterbrook; Meg Doherty; Gottfried Hirnschall; Timothy B Hallett Journal: Lancet Glob Health Date: 2013-12-10 Impact factor: 26.763
Authors: T B Leeme; M Mine; K Lechiile; F Mulenga; M Mosepele; T Mphoyakgosi; C Muthoga; J Ngidi; B Nkomo; D Ramaabya; M Tau; M W Tenforde; R Hayes; J N Jarvis Journal: HIV Med Date: 2020-09-02 Impact factor: 3.094