Literature DB >> 2266182

Medical students' views on necropsies.

E W Benbow1.   

Abstract

Second and third year medical students were invited to write down their comments about necropsies during a pilot study of a postal questionnaire on the subject. Their comments were analysed in detail on the following aspects: about how useful and necessary a procedure the necropsy is in medical practice and in education; their personal distaste for the procedure; whether attendance at a necropsy should remain a compulsory part of a medical education; staff attitudes; observance of relatives' wishes; and feelings about necropsies carried out on self or relatives. The data collated from the questionnaire showed that, although students regard the necropsy as useful in clinical practice, a single demonstration does not clarify what its uses are. For some, the necropsy represents disrespect to its subject, and few students seemed aware of the use of the necropsy as an instrument of quality control. It is concluded that the unpleasant aspects of a necropsy demonstration should be kept to a minimum to encourage attendance and promote a sense of its value, and that it might be useful to influence and modify students' opinions before they become entrenched, perhaps by giving a higher priority to training in discussing dying and death in the medical curricula.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  1990        PMID: 2266182      PMCID: PMC502967          DOI: 10.1136/jcp.43.12.969

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Clin Pathol        ISSN: 0021-9746            Impact factor:   3.411


  40 in total

1.  The autopsy in geriatrics.

Authors:  J T Freeman
Journal:  J Am Geriatr Soc       Date:  1975-01       Impact factor: 5.562

2.  Necropsy rates in the United Birmingham Hospitals.

Authors:  H A Waldron; L Vickerstaff
Journal:  Br Med J       Date:  1975-05-10

3.  Trends in hospital necropsy rates: Scotland 1961-74.

Authors:  H M Cameron; E McGoogan; J Clarke; B A Wilson
Journal:  Br Med J       Date:  1977-06-18

4.  Evaluation of a teaching hospital necropsy service.

Authors:  E F Fowler; A G Nicol; I N Reid
Journal:  J Clin Pathol       Date:  1977-06       Impact factor: 3.411

5.  Diagnostic errors discovered at autopsy.

Authors:  M Britton
Journal:  Acta Med Scand       Date:  1974-09

6.  The autopsy: its decline and a suggestion for its revival.

Authors:  W C Roberts
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  1978-08-17       Impact factor: 91.245

7.  Clinical attitudes to the autopsy.

Authors:  E McGoogan; H M Cameron
Journal:  Scott Med J       Date:  1978-01       Impact factor: 0.729

8.  Necropsy: a yardstick for clinical diagnoses.

Authors:  H M Cameron; E McGoogan; H Watson
Journal:  Br Med J       Date:  1980-10-11

9.  Clinical and post-mortem assessment of the cause of death.

Authors:  F Hartveit
Journal:  J Pathol       Date:  1977-12       Impact factor: 7.996

10.  A prospective study of 1152 hospital autopsies: I. Inaccuracies in death certification.

Authors:  H M Cameron; E McGoogan
Journal:  J Pathol       Date:  1981-04       Impact factor: 7.996

View more
  16 in total

1.  Medical educators' personal attitudes towards the necropsy.

Authors:  J L Burton
Journal:  J Clin Pathol       Date:  2003-12       Impact factor: 3.411

2.  Death of the teaching autopsy.

Authors:  Gregory O'Grady
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2003-10-04

3.  Declining necropsy rate.

Authors:  A P Giles; R Doshi; G G Menon; M K Khan
Journal:  J Clin Pathol       Date:  1991-11       Impact factor: 3.411

4.  Auditing necropsies.

Authors:  I Lauder
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  1991-11-16

Review 5.  The conventional autopsy in modern medicine.

Authors:  Tariq Ayoub; Jade Chow
Journal:  J R Soc Med       Date:  2008-04       Impact factor: 5.344

6.  Declining necropsy rate.

Authors:  A P Giles; R Doshi; G G Menon; M K Khan
Journal:  J Clin Pathol       Date:  1991-10       Impact factor: 3.411

7.  A survey of general practitioners' views on autopsy reports.

Authors:  S Karunaratne; E W Benbow
Journal:  J Clin Pathol       Date:  1997-07       Impact factor: 3.411

8.  Autopsy in undergraduate medical education--what do students really learn?

Authors:  Sven Anders; Martina Mueller; Jan-Peter Sperhake; Corinna Petersen-Ewert; Sarah Schiekirka; Tobias Raupach
Journal:  Int J Legal Med       Date:  2014-02-01       Impact factor: 2.686

Review 9.  Autopsy and medical education: a review.

Authors:  R Charlton
Journal:  J R Soc Med       Date:  1994-04       Impact factor: 5.344

10.  Necropsy practice after the "organ retention scandal": requests, performance, and tissue retention.

Authors:  J L Burton; J C E Underwood
Journal:  J Clin Pathol       Date:  2003-07       Impact factor: 3.411

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.