BACKGROUND: The clinical management of lobular carcinoma in situ lesions remains challenging. Our aim was to evaluate the risk of relapse for lobular carcinoma in situ (LCIS) patients, diagnosed on mammography performed for microcalcifications and according to proliferation assessed by Ki67 staining. METHODS: A series of 47 patient's files with LCIS and followed in our institution were retrospectively selected. All patients underwent lumpectomy without radiation therapy. The expression of E-cadherin, estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PR), EGFR and Ki67 were determined. Four different classes were then defined with the following criteria: ER+ and Ki67 ≤ 10%; ER+, Ki67 >10%; ER-; ER-PR- and EGFR+. RESULTS: Patient's mean age was 51.3 yrs. The majority of the lesions were classical LCIS (97%). All cases were E-cadherin either negative (71%) or weak and incomplete (29%). Among the 44 evaluable cases, 34 cases were ER or PR positive with KI67 ≤ 10% (79%), 9 cases ER positive with KI67 > 10% (21%), 1 case was ER and PR negative and expressed EGFR. At five years, all patients were alive, 1/34 ER positive and Ki67 low experienced a relapse contrasting with 3 out of 9 ER positive and Ki67 high (3 invasive carcinomas including 2 ductal and 1 lobular) (p = 0.0054). CONCLUSION: In this retrospective study, we observed a higher risk of relapse associated with a high proliferative activity of classical LCIS. If confirmed in larger series, this observation suggests that radiation therapy or hormonotherapy could be discussed for patients with Ki67 high classical LCIS in order to decrease their risk of relapse.
BACKGROUND: The clinical management of lobular carcinoma in situ lesions remains challenging. Our aim was to evaluate the risk of relapse for lobular carcinoma in situ (LCIS) patients, diagnosed on mammography performed for microcalcifications and according to proliferation assessed by Ki67 staining. METHODS: A series of 47 patient's files with LCIS and followed in our institution were retrospectively selected. All patients underwent lumpectomy without radiation therapy. The expression of E-cadherin, estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PR), EGFR and Ki67 were determined. Four different classes were then defined with the following criteria: ER+ and Ki67 ≤ 10%; ER+, Ki67 >10%; ER-; ER-PR- and EGFR+. RESULTS:Patient's mean age was 51.3 yrs. The majority of the lesions were classical LCIS (97%). All cases were E-cadherin either negative (71%) or weak and incomplete (29%). Among the 44 evaluable cases, 34 cases were ER or PR positive with KI67 ≤ 10% (79%), 9 cases ER positive with KI67 > 10% (21%), 1 case was ER and PR negative and expressed EGFR. At five years, all patients were alive, 1/34 ER positive and Ki67 low experienced a relapse contrasting with 3 out of 9 ER positive and Ki67 high (3 invasive carcinomas including 2 ductal and 1 lobular) (p = 0.0054). CONCLUSION: In this retrospective study, we observed a higher risk of relapse associated with a high proliferative activity of classical LCIS. If confirmed in larger series, this observation suggests that radiation therapy or hormonotherapy could be discussed for patients with Ki67 high classical LCIS in order to decrease their risk of relapse.
Authors: Greg J Logan; David J Dabbs; Peter C Lucas; Rachel C Jankowitz; Daniel D Brown; Beth Z Clark; Steffi Oesterreich; Priscilla F McAuliffe Journal: Breast Cancer Res Date: 2015-06-04 Impact factor: 6.466
Authors: Satbir Singh Thakur; Haocheng Li; Angela M Y Chan; Roxana Tudor; Gilbert Bigras; Don Morris; Emeka K Enwere; Hua Yang Journal: PLoS One Date: 2018-01-05 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Vandna Shah; Salpie Nowinski; Dina Levi; Irek Shinomiya; Narda Kebaier Ep Chaabouni; Cheryl Gillett; Anita Grigoriadis; Trevor A Graham; Rebecca Roylance; Michael A Simpson; Sarah E Pinder; Elinor J Sawyer Journal: Breast Cancer Res Date: 2017-01-17 Impact factor: 6.466