Michael Orth1, Carsten Schwenke. 1. Department of Neurology, University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany and Independent Statistical Consultant, SCOSSiS, Germany.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: In Huntington disease, the accurate determination of age-at-onset is critical to identify modifiers and therapies that aim to delay it. METHODS: Retrospective data from the European Huntington's Disease Network's REGISTRY and PREDICT-HD, a longitudinal study in prodromal huntingtin gene expansion mutation carriers. Data (age, gender, CAG repeat length, parent affected, and Unified Huntington's Disease Rating Scale motor score, total functional capacity) from at least three visits in 423 REGISTRY and 124 PREDICT-HD participants were included. Data based extrapolations of individual age-at-onset using generalized linear mixed models based on individual slopes of motor score or total functional capacity, and predictions using the Langbehn, or Ranen formula, were compared with clinicians' estimates. RESULTS: Concordance was best for the observed age-at-onset in PREDICT-HD and the calculated onset using the PREDICT-HD UHDRS longitudinal motor scores. This was superior to the REGISTRY data. For total functional capacity, the investigator's estimate was 4 years before the data derived age-at-onset. The concordance of predictions of probability of age-at-onset is better with the observed age-at-onset in the PREDICT-HD data (difference in 25%tile -5 to 10 years) than the REGISTRY data (±20 years). CONCLUSIONS: Estimating or predicting age-at-onset in Huntington disease may be inaccurate. It can be useful to 1) add in the manifest population motor score regression derived age-at-onset as additional motor onset and 2) add total functional capacity regression derived age-at-onset for the onset of functional impact of Huntington disease when patients are in mid- to late-stage.
BACKGROUND: In Huntington disease, the accurate determination of age-at-onset is critical to identify modifiers and therapies that aim to delay it. METHODS: Retrospective data from the European Huntington's Disease Network's REGISTRY and PREDICT-HD, a longitudinal study in prodromal huntingtin gene expansion mutation carriers. Data (age, gender, CAG repeat length, parent affected, and Unified Huntington's Disease Rating Scale motor score, total functional capacity) from at least three visits in 423 REGISTRY and 124 PREDICT-HDparticipants were included. Data based extrapolations of individual age-at-onset using generalized linear mixed models based on individual slopes of motor score or total functional capacity, and predictions using the Langbehn, or Ranen formula, were compared with clinicians' estimates. RESULTS: Concordance was best for the observed age-at-onset in PREDICT-HD and the calculated onset using the PREDICT-HD UHDRS longitudinal motor scores. This was superior to the REGISTRY data. For total functional capacity, the investigator's estimate was 4 years before the data derived age-at-onset. The concordance of predictions of probability of age-at-onset is better with the observed age-at-onset in the PREDICT-HD data (difference in 25%tile -5 to 10 years) than the REGISTRY data (±20 years). CONCLUSIONS: Estimating or predicting age-at-onset in Huntington disease may be inaccurate. It can be useful to 1) add in the manifest population motor score regression derived age-at-onset as additional motor onset and 2) add total functional capacity regression derived age-at-onset for the onset of functional impact of Huntington disease when patients are in mid- to late-stage.
Authors: Jane S Paulsen; Chiachi Wang; Kevin Duff; Roger Barker; Martha Nance; Leigh Beglinger; David Moser; Janet K Williams; Sheila Simpson; Douglas Langbehn; Daniel P van Kammen Journal: Mov Disord Date: 2010-11-15 Impact factor: 10.338
Authors: K Marder; H Zhao; R H Myers; M Cudkowicz; E Kayson; K Kieburtz; C Orme; J Paulsen; J B Penney; E Siemers; I Shoulson Journal: Neurology Date: 2000-01-25 Impact factor: 9.910
Authors: Sarah J Tabrizi; Douglas R Langbehn; Blair R Leavitt; Raymund Ac Roos; Alexandra Durr; David Craufurd; Christopher Kennard; Stephen L Hicks; Nick C Fox; Rachael I Scahill; Beth Borowsky; Allan J Tobin; H Diana Rosas; Hans Johnson; Ralf Reilmann; Bernhard Landwehrmeyer; Julie C Stout Journal: Lancet Neurol Date: 2009-07-29 Impact factor: 44.182
Authors: Nancy S Wexler; Judith Lorimer; Julie Porter; Fidela Gomez; Carol Moskowitz; Edith Shackell; Karen Marder; Graciela Penchaszadeh; Simone A Roberts; Javier Gayán; Denise Brocklebank; Stacey S Cherny; Lon R Cardon; Jacqueline Gray; Stephen R Dlouhy; Sandra Wiktorski; Marion E Hodes; P Michael Conneally; Jack B Penney; James Gusella; Jang-Ho Cha; Michael Irizarry; Diana Rosas; Steven Hersch; Zane Hollingsworth; Marcy MacDonald; Anne B Young; J Michael Andresen; David E Housman; Margot Mieja De Young; Ernesto Bonilla; Theresa Stillings; Americo Negrette; S Robert Snodgrass; Maria Dolores Martinez-Jaurrieta; Maria A Ramos-Arroyo; Jacqueline Bickham; Juan Sanchez Ramos; Frederick Marshall; Ira Shoulson; Gustavo J Rey; Andrew Feigin; Norman Arnheim; Amarilis Acevedo-Cruz; Leticia Acosta; Jose Alvir; Kenneth Fischbeck; Leslie M Thompson; Angela Young; Leon Dure; Christopher J O'Brien; Jane Paulsen; Adam Brickman; Denise Krch; Shelley Peery; Penelope Hogarth; Donald S Higgins; Bernhard Landwehrmeyer Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2004-03-01 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: N G Ranen; O C Stine; M H Abbott; M Sherr; A M Codori; M L Franz; N I Chao; A S Chung; N Pleasant; C Callahan Journal: Am J Hum Genet Date: 1995-09 Impact factor: 11.025
Authors: Sonia Di Tella; Maria RIta Lo Monaco; Martina Petracca; Paola Zinzi; Marcella Solito; Carla Piano; Paolo Calabresi; Maria Caterina Silveri; Anna Rita Bentivoglio Journal: J Neurol Date: 2022-08-01 Impact factor: 6.682
Authors: Leire Valcárcel-Ocete; Gorka Alkorta-Aranburu; Mikel Iriondo; Asier Fullaondo; María García-Barcina; José Manuel Fernández-García; Elena Lezcano-García; José María Losada-Domingo; Javier Ruiz-Ojeda; Amaia Álvarez de Arcaya; José María Pérez-Ramos; Raymund A C Roos; Jørgen E Nielsen; Carsten Saft; Ana M Zubiaga; Ana Aguirre Journal: PLoS One Date: 2015-07-06 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Hyun Sook Kim; Chul Hyoung Lyoo; Phil Hyu Lee; Sang Jin Kim; Mee Young Park; Hyeo-Il Ma; Jae Hyeok Lee; Sook Kun Song; Jong Sam Baik; Jin Ho Kim; Myung Sik Lee Journal: J Mov Disord Date: 2015-01-13
Authors: Sarah L Gardiner; Chiara Milanese; Merel W Boogaard; Ronald A M Buijsen; Marye Hogenboom; Raymund A C Roos; Pier G Mastroberardino; Willeke M C van Roon-Mom; N Ahmad Aziz Journal: Neurol Genet Date: 2018-10-04