| Literature DB >> 22447212 |
Hiroshi Murayama1, Yoshinori Fujiwara, Ichiro Kawachi.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: This article presents an overview of the concept of social capital, reviews prospective multilevel analytic studies of the association between social capital and health, and discusses intervention strategies that enhance social capital.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2012 PMID: 22447212 PMCID: PMC3798618 DOI: 10.2188/jea.je20110128
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Epidemiol ISSN: 0917-5040 Impact factor: 3.211
Figure 1.Conceptual arrangement of social capital
Prospective multilevel analytic studies of the association between social capital and health
| Author | Country | Setting | Year of survey | Study subjects | Social capital | Outcome | Analysis | Key findings |
| Snelgrove | United Kingdom | Community | Baseline: 1998–1999 | Community-dwelling residents | Social trust and civic participation | Self-rated health | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | High individual and area social trust were inversely associated with poor self-rated health, but civic participation was not associated with individual or area levels after adjustment for sociodemographic characteristics and health-related behaviors. |
| Wen | United | Community | Baseline: 1993 | Patients newly diagnosed in 1993 with 1 of 13 serious illnesses | Collective efficacy (7 items; ie, mutual | All-cause mortality | Multilevel Cox proportional hazards model | Contextual collective efficacy had a protective effect on mortality, whereas community social network density was detrimental. Social support, local organizations, and voluntary associations did not affect mortality after adjustments for sociodemographic characteristics and health status at the baseline. |
| Blakely | New | Community | Baseline: 1996 | Community-dwelling residents | Unpaid voluntary activities outside the respondent’s home over 4 weeks (4 items) | Mortality (all-cause, cardiovascular disease, cancer, unintentional injury, and suicide) | Multilevel Poisson regression analysis | There was no significant association of neighborhood- or regional-level social capital with any cause of death after adjustment for sociodemographic characteristics. |
| Blomgren | Finland | Community | Baseline: 1990 | Community-dwelling males aged | Family cohesion (proportion of persons living alone, of persons divorced by 1993 who were married in 1990, and of 1-parent families from all families with children) and civic participation (voting turnout) in the regions. (No individual-level social capital variable was used.) | Alcohol-related mortality | Multilevel Poisson regression analysis | Low family cohesion and high voter turnout in the region were associated with alcohol-related mortality, and the independent effects of these remained after adjustments for individual sociodemographic characteristics and area-level characteristics (proportion of unemployment, median household income, Gini coefficient, etc). |
| Lofors and | Sweden | Community | Baseline: 1997 | Entire Swedish population aged | Mean voting participation at neighborhood unit-level. (No individual-level social capital variable was used.) | First hospitalization for psychosis or depression | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | Low voter participation in neighborhoods was associated with hospitalization for psychosis in both men and women, but not with hospitalization for depression, after adjustment for individual sociodemographic characteristics and neighborhood-level deprivation. |
| Mohan | United | Community | Baseline: 1984–1985 | Community-dwelling adults | Engagement in activities (5 items), voting in the last election (1 item), sense of community (5 items), social network (2 items): the proportions of these in the area were used as real indicators of social capital. | All-cause mortality | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | Lower proportions of engagement in activities in the neighborhood area were associated with mortality, but the others did not produce conclusive contextual associations with mortality, after adjustment for age, sex, and health-related behaviors. |
| Sundquist | Sweden | Community | Baseline: 1997 | Community-dwelling residents | The proportion of people in the neighborhood who voted in the 1998 local government elections as neighborhood-level linking social capital. (No individual-level social capital variable was used.) | First hospitalization for a fatal or nonfatal coronary heart disease (CHD) event | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | Low linking social capital was associated with hospitalization for CHD in both men and women, after adjustment for sociodemographic characteristics. |
| Islam | Sweden | Community | Baseline: 1980–1997 | Community-dwelling residents | Election participation rate and registered number of crimes per 1000 populations as municipal-level social capital. | Mortality (all-cause, cancer, cardiovascular, other diseases, suicide, and other external) | Cox proportional hazards model | Both high election participation rates and low crime rates were protectively associated with individual risk from all-cause mortality for males, particularly among those aged 65+, after adjustment for sociodemographic characteristics and quality of life at the baseline. These associations were not found for females. A high election participation rate and a low crime rate also had protective associations on mortality risks from cancer for males and females aged 65+. |
| Desai | United | Community | Baseline: 1994–1998 | Psychiatric patients ( | Social cohesiveness and trust at state level. (No individual-level social capital variable was used.) | Suicide mortality | Multilevel Poisson regression analysis | Suicide risk was lower in states that had higher social capital, after adjustment for individual sociodemographic characteristics and clinical characteristics. |
| Kouvonen | Finland | Workplace | Baseline: 2000–2002 | Finnish public sector employees | Cognitive and structural components of workplace social capital (8 items: sense of cohesion, mutual acceptance, trust for the supervisor, etc) at individual level and work unit level (aggregated). | Self-reported, physician-diagnosed depression; | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | Lower individual social capital at work, but not aggregate-level social capital, was associated with subsequent self-reported depression after adjustment for sociodemographic characteristics. No association of individual- or work unit-level social capital with antidepressant treatment was found. |
| Kouvonen | Finland | Workplace | Baseline: 2000–2002 | Finnish public sector employees | Cognitive and structural components of workplace social capital (8 items: sense of cohesion, mutual acceptance, trust for the supervisor, etc) at individual level and work unit level (aggregated). | Smoking cessation | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | High individual-level social capital in workplaces was associated with increased likelihood of smoking cessation after adjustment for sociodemographic characteristics, health-related behaviors, and depression. This association was strong in groups with high socioeconomic status (non-manual laborers). Work unit-level social capital was not associated with smoking cessation. |
| Oksanen | Finland | Workplace | Baseline: 2000–2001 | Finnish public sector employees ( | Cognitive and structural components of workplace social capital (8 items: sense of cohesion, mutual acceptance, trust for the supervisor, etc) at individual-level and work unit-level (aggregated). | Self-rated health | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | Both a constantly low level of social capital and a decline in social capital at an individual level were associated with impairment of self-rated health after adjustments for sociodemographic characteristics and health-related behaviors. A constant low level of social capital in work units was marginally associated with risks of poor health, after adjustment for work-unit characteristics. |
| Väänänen | Finland | Workplace | Baseline: 2000–2002 | Finnish public sector employees | Cognitive and structural components of workplace social capital (8 items: sense of cohesion, mutual acceptance, trust for the supervisor, etc) at individual level and work unit level (aggregated). | Co-occurrence of lifestyle risk factors (current smoking, heavy drinking, overweight, and physical inactivity) | Multilevel logistic regression analysis | Social capital at the individual and work unit levels at the baseline was not associated with an increased risk of co-occurrence of lifestyle risk factors at follow-up, after adjustment for sociodemographic characteristics and co-occurrence at baseline. |
Figure 2.Image of desired relationship between social capital and health promotion intervention programs