Vani Chetty1, Dhayendre Moodley, Anil Chuturgoon. 1. Womens Health and HIV Research Unit, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine, University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Currently used 3rd generation rapid HIV-tests in resource-limited settings do not detect acute HIV-infections (AHI). They are known to detect HIV-infections after or late in the "window period". Detecting incident-HIV infections early in pregnancy increases opportunities for initiating antiretroviral prophylaxis to prevent mother-to-child transmission of HIV. OBJECTIVES: We evaluated the Determine(®) HIV1/2 Ag/Ab Combo Rapid Test (Combo RT), a 4th generation test against two 3rd generation tests (SENSA-HIV1/2/0 Tri-line, SD-Bioline) for early detection of HIV-infection in pregnancy. STUDY DESIGN: In a cohort study, plasma samples from 32 pregnant women who seroconverted at a subsequent antenatal visit (incident-infection), samples from 189 women who tested HIV positive at baseline (established-infections) and samples from 32 women remaining HIV-seronegative at a subsequent antenatal visit were tested with 3rd generation (antibody detection only) and 4th generation (antibody/antigen detection) rapid HIV tests. The HIV-1 NucliSENSEasyQ(®) v2.0 PCR test was used to quantify HIV-viral copies in women with incident HIV-infections. RESULTS: Eighteen of 32 (56.3%) women (incident-infections) had detectable viral copies (baseline); 16 (88.9%) were antibody reactive with the Combo RT. None of the 32 specimens were reactive on the antigen component of the Combo RT. The sensitivity and specificity of the Combo RT in detecting HIV infections prior to seroconversion is 59.4% (95%CI 40.6-76.3) and 96.9% (95%CI 83.8-99.9) respectively. The Combo RT detected 94.0% of all HIV-infections if used as a screening test (baseline) compared to 85.5% detected by 3rd generation tests. CONCLUSIONS: The Combo RT does not identify AHI but is superior to 3rd generation tests in detecting HIV antibody responses.
BACKGROUND: Currently used 3rd generation rapid HIV-tests in resource-limited settings do not detect acute HIV-infections (AHI). They are known to detect HIV-infections after or late in the "window period". Detecting incident-HIV infections early in pregnancy increases opportunities for initiating antiretroviral prophylaxis to prevent mother-to-child transmission of HIV. OBJECTIVES: We evaluated the Determine(®) HIV1/2 Ag/Ab Combo Rapid Test (Combo RT), a 4th generation test against two 3rd generation tests (SENSA-HIV1/2/0 Tri-line, SD-Bioline) for early detection of HIV-infection in pregnancy. STUDY DESIGN: In a cohort study, plasma samples from 32 pregnant women who seroconverted at a subsequent antenatal visit (incident-infection), samples from 189 women who tested HIV positive at baseline (established-infections) and samples from 32 women remaining HIV-seronegative at a subsequent antenatal visit were tested with 3rd generation (antibody detection only) and 4th generation (antibody/antigen detection) rapid HIV tests. The HIV-1 NucliSENSEasyQ(®) v2.0 PCR test was used to quantify HIV-viral copies in women with incident HIV-infections. RESULTS: Eighteen of 32 (56.3%) women (incident-infections) had detectable viral copies (baseline); 16 (88.9%) were antibody reactive with the Combo RT. None of the 32 specimens were reactive on the antigen component of the Combo RT. The sensitivity and specificity of the Combo RT in detecting HIV infections prior to seroconversion is 59.4% (95%CI 40.6-76.3) and 96.9% (95%CI 83.8-99.9) respectively. The Combo RT detected 94.0% of all HIV-infections if used as a screening test (baseline) compared to 85.5% detected by 3rd generation tests. CONCLUSIONS: The Combo RT does not identify AHI but is superior to 3rd generation tests in detecting HIV antibody responses.
Authors: Yen T Duong; Yvonne Mavengere; Hetal Patel; Carole Moore; Julius Manjengwa; Dumile Sibandze; Christopher Rasberry; Charmaine Mlambo; Zhi Li; Lynda Emel; Naomi Bock; Jan Moore; Rejoice Nkambule; Jessica Justman; Jason Reed; George Bicego; Dennis L Ellenberger; John N Nkengasong; Bharat S Parekh Journal: J Clin Microbiol Date: 2014-08-13 Impact factor: 5.948
Authors: M Kumi Smith; Sarah E Rutstein; Kimberly A Powers; Sarah Fidler; William C Miller; Joseph J Eron; Myron S Cohen Journal: J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Date: 2013-07 Impact factor: 3.731
Authors: Eleanor R Gray; Robert Bain; Olivia Varsaneux; Rosanna W Peeling; Molly M Stevens; Rachel A McKendry Journal: AIDS Date: 2018-09-24 Impact factor: 4.177
Authors: Damian P Conway; Martin Holt; Anna McNulty; Deborah L Couldwell; Don E Smith; Stephen C Davies; Philip Cunningham; Phillip Keen; Rebecca Guy Journal: PLoS One Date: 2014-04-08 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Joseph M Lewis; Peter Macpherson; Emily R Adams; Eleanor Ochodo; Anita Sands; Miriam Taegtmeyer Journal: AIDS Date: 2015-11-28 Impact factor: 4.177