BACKGROUND: Psychiatry residents in North America are generally required to work on-call on the psychiatric emergency service (PES) during training. Resident discontent with the long hours, onerous case loads, and lack of on-call teaching has been reported as a barrier to PES training. Given that the PES is a longitudinal and important experience, we sought to develop a better understanding of this service from the resident perspective and identify factors that affect residents as they work and train in this area. METHODS: In this grounded theory qualitative study, we collected data from focus groups with psychiatry residents. We analyzed data according to grounded theory methodology to develop an enhanced understanding of the resident experience on the PES. RESULTS: THREE MAJOR THEMES EMERGED FROM DATA ANALYSIS: (1) challenges residents face in the PES are complex and attributable to more than simply long duty hours, (2) the PES offers unique learning opportunities for residents, and (3) resident satisfaction with the PES depends on a good relationship with the team. CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights important topics for any residency programs that require residents to work on a PES team. Although much attention has been paid to addressing challenges inherent to the on-call experience, such as limiting the amount of on-call hours and call frequency, equal attention should be paid to team dynamics. Like prior work on physician contentment and multidisciplinary team functioning, our study found that physicians will tolerate stressful workplace factors, so long as there is a supportive and healthy team dynamic. It is important for program directors to identify problems with team dynamics in the PES in light of their potential impact on residents.
BACKGROUND: Psychiatry residents in North America are generally required to work on-call on the psychiatric emergency service (PES) during training. Resident discontent with the long hours, onerous case loads, and lack of on-call teaching has been reported as a barrier to PES training. Given that the PES is a longitudinal and important experience, we sought to develop a better understanding of this service from the resident perspective and identify factors that affect residents as they work and train in this area. METHODS: In this grounded theory qualitative study, we collected data from focus groups with psychiatry residents. We analyzed data according to grounded theory methodology to develop an enhanced understanding of the resident experience on the PES. RESULTS: THREE MAJOR THEMES EMERGED FROM DATA ANALYSIS: (1) challenges residents face in the PES are complex and attributable to more than simply long duty hours, (2) the PES offers unique learning opportunities for residents, and (3) resident satisfaction with the PES depends on a good relationship with the team. CONCLUSIONS: This study highlights important topics for any residency programs that require residents to work on a PES team. Although much attention has been paid to addressing challenges inherent to the on-call experience, such as limiting the amount of on-call hours and call frequency, equal attention should be paid to team dynamics. Like prior work on physician contentment and multidisciplinary team functioning, our study found that physicians will tolerate stressful workplace factors, so long as there is a supportive and healthy team dynamic. It is important for program directors to identify problems with team dynamics in the PES in light of their potential impact on residents.
Authors: M Kivimäki; R Sutinen; M Elovainio; J Vahtera; K Räsänen; S Töyry; J E Ferrie; J Firth-Cozens Journal: Occup Environ Med Date: 2001-06 Impact factor: 4.402
Authors: Edwin D Boudreaux; Michael H Allen; Cindy Claassen; Glenn W Currier; Louise Bertman; Rachel Glick; Jennifer Park; David Feifel; Carlos A Camargo Journal: Gen Hosp Psychiatry Date: 2009-06-04 Impact factor: 3.238