BACKGROUND: This study compared the initial strength of acromioclavicular joint reconstructions using coracoclavicular tendon grafts using interference screws, a tendon square knot, or side-to-side suturing for graft fixation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An acromioclavicular joint reconstruction was performed using a hamstring allograft looped under the coracoid and then fixed using interference screws, a square knot in the graft, and side-to-side graft suturing in each of 8 cadaveric shoulders. Each reconstruction was cycled in a superior direction, and displacements were recorded. Stiffness and ultimate load to failure of the reconstructions were determined. RESULTS: The knot construct had a greater elongation after cycling compared with the screw (P = .003) or side-to-side suture (P = .001) repairs and had a higher ultimate load to failure than the screw construct (614.9 ± 124.6 vs 469.79 ± 175.1 N; P = .02). No significant differences were found between the screw and side-to-side suture constructs in elongation (P = .11) or ultimate loads to failure (P = .58). Finally, the side-to-side construct was significantly stiffer than the screw (P = .01) or knot (P = .01) reconstructions. CONCLUSIONS: Clavicular fixation of a coracoclavicular graft during an acromioclavicular joint reconstruction using a square knot has superior ultimate strength compared with interference screw fixation. Side-to-side suture and screw constructs have superior cyclic displacement properties compared with knot fixation, with no differences in cyclic properties found between the side-to-side suture and screw constructs. Side-to-side suturing provides equivalent initial biomechanical strength compared with interference screw fixation.
BACKGROUND: This study compared the initial strength of acromioclavicular joint reconstructions using coracoclavicular tendon grafts using interference screws, a tendon square knot, or side-to-side suturing for graft fixation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An acromioclavicular joint reconstruction was performed using a hamstring allograft looped under the coracoid and then fixed using interference screws, a square knot in the graft, and side-to-side graft suturing in each of 8 cadaveric shoulders. Each reconstruction was cycled in a superior direction, and displacements were recorded. Stiffness and ultimate load to failure of the reconstructions were determined. RESULTS: The knot construct had a greater elongation after cycling compared with the screw (P = .003) or side-to-side suture (P = .001) repairs and had a higher ultimate load to failure than the screw construct (614.9 ± 124.6 vs 469.79 ± 175.1 N; P = .02). No significant differences were found between the screw and side-to-side suture constructs in elongation (P = .11) or ultimate loads to failure (P = .58). Finally, the side-to-side construct was significantly stiffer than the screw (P = .01) or knot (P = .01) reconstructions. CONCLUSIONS: Clavicular fixation of a coracoclavicular graft during an acromioclavicular joint reconstruction using a square knot has superior ultimate strength compared with interference screw fixation. Side-to-side suture and screw constructs have superior cyclic displacement properties compared with knot fixation, with no differences in cyclic properties found between the side-to-side suture and screw constructs. Side-to-side suturing provides equivalent initial biomechanical strength compared with interference screw fixation.
Authors: Theodorakys Marín Fermín; Jean Michel Hovsepian; Víctor Miguel Rodrigues Fernandes; Ioannis Terzidis; Emmanouil Papakostas; Jason Koh Journal: Arthrosc Sports Med Rehabil Date: 2021-02-24
Authors: Patrick Holweg; Wolfgang Pichler; Gerald Gruber; Ellen Tackner; Franz Josef Seibert; Patrick Sadoghi; Gloria Hohenberger Journal: Case Rep Med Date: 2017-05-23
Authors: Lane N Rush; Nicholas Lake; Eric C Stiefel; Edward R Hobgood; J Randall Ramsey; Michael J O'Brien; Larry D Field; Felix H Savoie Journal: Orthop J Sports Med Date: 2016-07-25