J J Thomas1, P K Keel, T F Heatherton. 1. Eating Disorders Clinical and Research Program, Massachusetts General Hospital, WAC 816D, 15 Parkman St., Boston, MA 02114, USA. jjthomas@partners.org
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Ballet dancers are at elevated risk for eating disorders, but the extent to which disordered eating attitudes and behaviors represent a relatively benign adaptation to an environment that values extreme thinness, or a functionally impairing form of psychopathology, has sparked considerable debate. METHOD: To determine whether disordered eating is associated with role impairment in dancers, we evaluated its association with musculoskeletal injuries among 239 adolescent female ballet students. RESULTS: Dance students reported a variety of lifetime disordered eating behaviors to control weight including fasting (29.3%), vomiting (9.6%), and laxative use (4.2%). More than half (52.3%) reported a lifetime history of injury (stress fracture, broken bone, and/or medically treated tendonitis). A greater number of lifetime disordered eating behaviors was associated with a greater number of lifetime injuries (p=0.01). Moreover, vomiting history was associated with greater likelihood of injury (p=0.004) and increased time to recover from injury (median difference=22.8 days, p=0.006). CONCLUSION: Although the direction of causality cannot be determined from this retrospective design, these results suggest that disordered eating is associated with role-relevant functional impairment, even among members of a subculture that values extreme thinness.
BACKGROUND: Ballet dancers are at elevated risk for eating disorders, but the extent to which disordered eating attitudes and behaviors represent a relatively benign adaptation to an environment that values extreme thinness, or a functionally impairing form of psychopathology, has sparked considerable debate. METHOD: To determine whether disordered eating is associated with role impairment in dancers, we evaluated its association with musculoskeletal injuries among 239 adolescent female ballet students. RESULTS: Dance students reported a variety of lifetime disordered eating behaviors to control weight including fasting (29.3%), vomiting (9.6%), and laxative use (4.2%). More than half (52.3%) reported a lifetime history of injury (stress fracture, broken bone, and/or medically treated tendonitis). A greater number of lifetime disordered eating behaviors was associated with a greater number of lifetime injuries (p=0.01). Moreover, vomiting history was associated with greater likelihood of injury (p=0.004) and increased time to recover from injury (median difference=22.8 days, p=0.006). CONCLUSION: Although the direction of causality cannot be determined from this retrospective design, these results suggest that disordered eating is associated with role-relevant functional impairment, even among members of a subculture that values extreme thinness.
Authors: Rebecca Ringham; Kelly Klump; Walter Kaye; David Stone; Steven Libman; Susan Stowe; Marsha Marcus Journal: Int J Eat Disord Date: 2006-09 Impact factor: 4.861
Authors: Rachel Bachner-Melman; Ada H Zohar; Richard P Ebstein; Yoel Elizur; Naama Constantini Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2006-04 Impact factor: 5.411
Authors: Michelle P Warren; Jeanne Brooks-Gunn; Richard P Fox; Claire C Holderness; Emily P Hyle; William G Hamilton Journal: J Clin Endocrinol Metab Date: 2002-07 Impact factor: 5.958