Lupus anticoagulant (LA) in pregnant women with history of recurrent fetal loss.

The frequency of LA in 50 women with intact pregnancy, age range 26 to 39 years, but with past history of at least 2 lost pregnancies, was determined using coagulation-based assays. Most (68%) of the pregnant women were in the first trimester. Venous blood (4.5 mL) carefully collected from each of the subjects and also the controls (normal relative donors) was put in 0.5 mL of 3.8% citrate (ratio 9:1). The blood was quickly centrifuged at 1500 g; platelet-poor plasma was separated and frozen at -30°C until analyzed. The control plasma was pooled and dispensed in 2 mL aliquots. Partial thromboplastin time with kaolin (PTT(k)) (against the control samples for comparison) and kaolin clotting time (KCT) were determined on each of the test samples using standard laboratory procedures. Prolonged PTT(k) was obtained in 36 patients (72%). KCT was obtained through mixtures of patients' plasma with pooled control plasma (P:C) at 100:0; 0.8:0.2; 0.6:0.4; 0.5:0.5; 0.4:0.6; 0.2:0.8; 0:100; and lin-lin graph paper was used to plot out each of these dilutions against their respective clotting time in seconds. The interpreted graph showed that 12 (24%) had LA, while 3 (6%) had LA with cofactor. This high frequency necessitates regular screening for LA in pregnant women with a history of recurrent fetal loss at any gestational age.

Introduction

The lupus anticoagulant (LA), most commonly an immunoglobulin, is an immediate-acting coagulation inhibitor found in a variety of autoimmune disorders and sometimes found in otherwise healthy individuals.1 It appears to be directed specifically against the phospholipids moiety of prothrombinase complex formed by the interaction of factors Xa, Va, platelet phospholipids, and calcium.2 It was first described in 1952.3 and its strong association with thromboembolic phenomenon, spontaneous miscarriage, and stillbirth was established.4–6

LA is an acquired autoantibody that binds to phospholipids’ active coagulation factors, which slows down the rate of thrombin generation and therefore retards clot formation in vitro,6 but promotes both venous and arterial thrombosis in vivo.7 This paradoxical association between in vitro anticoagulant effect and in vivo prothrombotic state activity of this autoantibody is not fully understood.

While antiphospholipid syndrome (APS) is known to be one of the most important causes of acquired hypercoagulable states8 and specifically causes late pregnancy loss, some studies found an association of 7% to 10% between recurrent spontaneous abortions in the first trimester and LA.6

Placental vessel thrombosis with ischemia,9 which starts early in pregnancy, and spiral artery vasculopathy,10 which begins at about 8 weeks and is complete by 16 to 20 weeks of gestation, are regarded as the causes of pregnancy loss.

Information about LA frequency in pregnant women with history of recurrent fetal loss is sparse in this part of the world, hence this study.

Materials and methods

Subjects

Before the study began, approval was obtained from the ethical review committee of Oyo State Hospitals Management Board and informed consent from individual patients. Fifty women with intact pregnancy but who had had at least two previous unexplained pregnancy losses (ie, at least gravida 3), irrespective of their gestational age, were consecutively recruited into the study at the antenatal clinic of Adeoyo Maternity Hospital, Yemetu, Ibadan between January and April 1998. The age range was 26 to 39 years (average 31.6 years). Their antenatal records did not show comorbidities attributable to pregnancy loss.

Sample collection

Venous blood (4.5 mL) was carefully collected through clean venupucture from each patient into a clean plastic tube containing 0.5 mL of 3.8% trisodium citrate (9 parts venous blood: 1 part anticoagulant). After thorough but gentle mixing, the sample was centrifuged for 15 minutes at 1500 g at 25°C and platelet-poor plasma (PPP) was immediately and carefully aspirated and stored on ice in the freezer at −20°C prior to use.

Using a similar method PPP was obtained from each of the individual’s voluntary relative donors, which was pooled but discounted and stored in 2 mL aliquot at −20°C.

Coagulation tests

Prothrombin time was determined by the original technique by Quick.11 Also partial thromboplastin time with kaolin was performed using the original method by Proctor and Rapparport.12

A kaolin clotting time (KCT) test, which is essentially an activated partial thromboplastin test but without any added phospholipid, was performed as previously described by Exner et al13,14 by preincubating 0.2 mL of citrated plasma with 0.1 mL of kaolin suspension (20 g/L in tris buffer pH 7.4) for 3 minutes at 37°C.

Method

A mixing experiment was performed using dilutions of normal patient plasma prepared as shown in Table 1. Kaolin is added and then calcium to initiate coagulation. The KCT is the time from adding calcium to clot formation.

Table 1

Dilutions of normal patient plasma

Normal plasma	Patient plasma
100%	0%
90%	10%
80%	20%
50%	50%
20%	80%
10%	90%

KCT ratio,14 ie, a ratio of KCT at 20% test plasma to KCT at 100% normal control plasma, was then calculated for each of the samples

A ratio of ≥1.2 is considered positive for a lupus anticoagulant.

Results

Out of the 50 recruited pregnant women, 34 (68%), 7 (14%), and 9 (18%) were in first, second, and third trimester, respectively.

Table 2 summarizes the outcome and interpretation of results in 50 pregnant women with history of fetal loss. The percentage dilution of neat/Test (N/T) plasma was plotted against time on a Lin-Lin graph for the 15 patients (30%) that had prolonged KCT; of these, 12 (24%) showed graphical evidence of LA in circulation and 3 (6%) showed graphical evidence of LA as well as deficiency in the cofactor necessary for full inhibitory effect.

Table 2

Outcome of partial thromboplastin time with kaolin (PTTk) and kaolin clotting time (KCT) in 50 pregnant women with recurrent pregnancy loss

Tests	n	Within normal	Mild prolongation	Very prolonged
PTTk	50	14	–	36 (72%)
KCT	50	35	3 (6%) (LA + cofactor)	12 (24%) (LA in circulation)

Abbreviation: LA, lupus anticoagulant.

Discussion

The APS is defined by the presence of antiphospholipid antibody or LA, usually in high titer, and any or all of the following clinical events: recurrent thromboses, recurrent fetal losses, and thrombocytopenia.15 Also Livedo reticularis is considered to be an additional marker for the disease.16 Antiphospholipid antibody is identified either with an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), which commonly uses cardiolipin as the phospholipid’s antigen or by finding an LA with clotting tests. While ELISA for antiphospholipid antibody is known to be sensitive, but not very specific for predicting clinical events, LA with clotting tests, on the other hand, are specific but less sensitive.17 Although antiphospholipid antibody thus occurs in a variety of situations in healthy individuals, in association with infections such as syphilis, in HIV-1, hepatitis C, and cytomegalovirus and in relation to medications, autoimmune antiphospholipid antibodies have higher titers and are more commonly of IgG isotype (mainly IgG2 and IgG4 subclasses), have higher avidity, and require presence of a cofactor.15,17,18 APS is a heterogeneous disorder both in terms of clinical manifestation and the range of autoantibodies.

Although antiphospholpid antibody causes prolongation of phospholipid-dependent clotting tests in vitro, it causes thrombosis in vivo. Different mechanisms thought to be responsible for this in vivo thrombosis and ischemia include inhibition by antibodies of antithromb-independent anticoagulant mechanisms, activated protein C, and inhibition of fibrinolysis.19 Other mechanisms are increased plasma concentration of soluble tissue factor and tissue pathway inhibitor, increased monocyte expression of tissue factor, and procoagulant activity in some patients with the syndrome.20 Also, the autoantibody can inhibit prostacyclin secretion and promote release of von Willebrand factor by endothelia cells in vitro.21,22 Finally, platelet activation also plays a role in APS, particularly in arterial thrombosis. Therefore a thrombotic basis for pregnancy failure in APS is highly supported by the finding of decidual vasculopathy and placental infarction observed by Rand et al.23

In the present study, 60% of the patients have prolonged prothrombin time (18% mildly prolonged and 42% severely prolonged). This phenomenon has been observed in the past that LA occasionally increases the prothrombin time, and in turn the international normalized ratio, and therefore monitoring anticoagulation with warfarin becomes difficult.24,25

Also our results agree with those of Haywood and Brown26 who observed approximately 10% to 15% presence of LA in all the patients undergoing recurrent pregnancy loss.

The diagnosis of LA requires a high degree of suspicion. Many other manifestations should arouse this high degree of suspicion for LA apart from recurrent fetal loss, including unexplained thrombocytopenia, pulmonary hypertension, history of thrombotic events, cerebral vascular diseases in the young, unexplained infertility, autoimmune hemolytic anemia, thrombotic endocarditic mimicking rheumatic heart disease without history, and other features of rheumatic fever.

This high prevalence cannot be solely attributable to primary APS bearing in mind the heterogeneous nature of the antibody and the protean manifestation of its clinical picture. As enumerated by Greaves7 LA is also detectable in association with infections, ie, viral infections such as HIV-1, varicella, and hepatitis C, bacteria infections such as syphilis, and parasitic infections such malaria, which is endemic in this part of the world. Also various drugs such as guanidine, hydralazine, procainamide, and phenytoin may be responsible, as may be miscellaneous associations such as sickle cell disease, autoimmune hemolytic anemia, and autoimmune thrombocytopenia. Therefore strong relevant clinical information is required to make a meaningful decision.