Lindsay Prior1, Joanne Wilson, Michael Donnelly, Andrew W Murphy, Susan M Smith, Mary Byrne, Molly Byrne, Margaret E Cupples. 1. School of Sociology, Social Policy & Social Work, Queen's University, BelfastCentre of Excellence for Public Health Medicine (NI), Queen's University, BelfastDiscipline of General Practice, NUI, GalwayDepartment of Public Health and Primary Care, Trinity College, DublinSchool of Psychology, NUI, GalwayDepartment of General Practice and Primary Care, Centre of Excellence for Public Health Medicine (NI), Queen's University, Belfast, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: This paper focuses on the relationships between health 'policy' as it is embodied in official documentation, and health 'practice' as reported and reflected on in the talk of policy-makers, health professionals and patients. The specific context for the study involves a comparison of policies relating to the secondary prevention of coronary heart disease (CHD) in the two jurisdictions of Ireland - involving as they do a predominantly state funded (National Health Service) system in the north and a mixed health-care economy in the south. The key question is to determine how the detail of health policy as contained in policy documents connects to and gets translated into practice and action. METHODS: The data sources for the study include relevant health-care policy documents (N=5) and progress reports (N=6) in the two Irish jurisdictions, and semi-structured interviews with a range of policy-makers (N=28), practice nurses (14), general practitioners (12) and patients (13) to explore their awareness of the documents' contents and how they saw the impact of 'policy' on primary care practice. RESULTS: The findings suggest that although strategic policy documents can be useful for highlighting and channelling attention to health issues that require concerted action, they have little impact on what either professionals or lay people do. CONCLUSION: To influence the latter and to encourage a systematic approach to the delivery of health care it seems likely that contractual arrangements - specifying tasks to be undertaken and methods for monitoring and reporting on activity - are required.
BACKGROUND: This paper focuses on the relationships between health 'policy' as it is embodied in official documentation, and health 'practice' as reported and reflected on in the talk of policy-makers, health professionals and patients. The specific context for the study involves a comparison of policies relating to the secondary prevention of coronary heart disease (CHD) in the two jurisdictions of Ireland - involving as they do a predominantly state funded (National Health Service) system in the north and a mixed health-care economy in the south. The key question is to determine how the detail of health policy as contained in policy documents connects to and gets translated into practice and action. METHODS: The data sources for the study include relevant health-care policy documents (N=5) and progress reports (N=6) in the two Irish jurisdictions, and semi-structured interviews with a range of policy-makers (N=28), practice nurses (14), general practitioners (12) and patients (13) to explore their awareness of the documents' contents and how they saw the impact of 'policy' on primary care practice. RESULTS: The findings suggest that although strategic policy documents can be useful for highlighting and channelling attention to health issues that require concerted action, they have little impact on what either professionals or lay people do. CONCLUSION: To influence the latter and to encourage a systematic approach to the delivery of health care it seems likely that contractual arrangements - specifying tasks to be undertaken and methods for monitoring and reporting on activity - are required.
Authors: Paddy Gillespie; Eamon O'Shea; Andrew W Murphy; Mary C Byrne; Molly Byrne; Susan M Smith; Margaret E Cupples Journal: Int J Technol Assess Health Care Date: 2010-07 Impact factor: 2.188
Authors: Zubair Kabir; Kathleen Bennett; Emer Shelley; Belgin Unal; Julia Critchley; John Feely; Simon Capewell Journal: Eur J Public Health Date: 2006-06-23 Impact factor: 3.367
Authors: Andrew W Murphy; Margaret E Cupples; Susan M Smith; Molly Byrne; Claire Leathem; Mary C Byrne Journal: Curr Control Trials Cardiovasc Med Date: 2005-07-29
Authors: Mairead Corrrigan; Margaret E Cupples; Susan M Smith; Molly Byrne; Claire S Leathem; Pauline Clerkin; Andrew W Murphy Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2006-07-18 Impact factor: 2.655