STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review study. OBJECTIVES: To estimate the clinical outcome of various resection protocols in patients with chondrosarcoma (CHS) at the challenging region of cervical and cervicothoracic spine (CCT). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: It is challenging to surgically manage CHS of the spine. Although total en-bloc resection has proven to be an ideal treatment, this option is not always feasible in the spine because of the constrains of critical neurovascular structures in the vicinity. Lesions at the CCT region pose even more difficulties, and few large clinical series concerning various protocols and long-term outcomes of these lesions exist at present. METHODS: Fifteen patients with CHS at the CCT region who underwent surgical management in our institute were retrospectively studied. Twelve piecemeal resections and 3 en-bloc resections were performed. Intraoperative local chemotherapy and postoperative cyberknife radiotherapy were given as adjuvant therapy. Neurologic status, local recurrence, distant metastasis, and treatment-related complications were evaluated. RESULTS: The mean follow-up time was 58.7 months (median 37 mo; ranging from 18 to 141 mo). Local recurrence was detected in 5 of 5 cases (100%) treated by intracapsular piecemeal resection, and in 1 of 7 cases (14.3%) treated by extracapsular piecemeal resection, whereas no recurrence was found in 3 cases treated by en-bloc resection. Of the 6 recurrent patients, 5 died of disease 24 to 46 months after present surgery, and the remaining patient was alive with disease in the final follow-up. There were no signs of recurrence in the remaining 9 patients. CONCLUSIONS: For CHS at the CCT region, intralesional piecemeal resection has a poor prognosis and should be avoided. Oncologically, en-bloc resection remains the best form of disease management and should be the primary treatment of choice. For cases in which an uncontaminated en-bloc resection could not be achieved, the extracapsular piecemeal resection with adjuvant therapy including local chemotherapy and cyberknife radiotherapy is an effective and achievable option.
STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review study. OBJECTIVES: To estimate the clinical outcome of various resection protocols in patients with chondrosarcoma (CHS) at the challenging region of cervical and cervicothoracic spine (CCT). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: It is challenging to surgically manage CHS of the spine. Although total en-bloc resection has proven to be an ideal treatment, this option is not always feasible in the spine because of the constrains of critical neurovascular structures in the vicinity. Lesions at the CCT region pose even more difficulties, and few large clinical series concerning various protocols and long-term outcomes of these lesions exist at present. METHODS: Fifteen patients with CHS at the CCT region who underwent surgical management in our institute were retrospectively studied. Twelve piecemeal resections and 3 en-bloc resections were performed. Intraoperative local chemotherapy and postoperative cyberknife radiotherapy were given as adjuvant therapy. Neurologic status, local recurrence, distant metastasis, and treatment-related complications were evaluated. RESULTS: The mean follow-up time was 58.7 months (median 37 mo; ranging from 18 to 141 mo). Local recurrence was detected in 5 of 5 cases (100%) treated by intracapsular piecemeal resection, and in 1 of 7 cases (14.3%) treated by extracapsular piecemeal resection, whereas no recurrence was found in 3 cases treated by en-bloc resection. Of the 6 recurrent patients, 5 died of disease 24 to 46 months after present surgery, and the remaining patient was alive with disease in the final follow-up. There were no signs of recurrence in the remaining 9 patients. CONCLUSIONS: For CHS at the CCT region, intralesional piecemeal resection has a poor prognosis and should be avoided. Oncologically, en-bloc resection remains the best form of disease management and should be the primary treatment of choice. For cases in which an uncontaminated en-bloc resection could not be achieved, the extracapsular piecemeal resection with adjuvant therapy including local chemotherapy and cyberknife radiotherapy is an effective and achievable option.
Authors: Nuno Rui Paulino Pereira; Stein J Janssen; Nicky Stoop; Stefan Hartveldt; Yen-Lin E Chen; Thomas F DeLaney; Francis J Hornicek; Joseph H Schwab Journal: Global Spine J Date: 2019-02-18