OBJECTIVE: There are several examples in nutrition of discordance between the results of observational studies and randomized controlled trials (RCTs). We hypothesized that this discordance is attributable to differences in the translational paths of nutrient-disease associations. Translational paths can be assessed using citation analysis. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We compared the characteristics of citation networks using examples, where RCTs and observational studies agreed (long-chain n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids [n-3 PUFA]) or disagreed (vitamin E). We performed systematic reviews in each example, constructed citation networks, and compared them with respect to the number of articles and citation relationships between them, as well as the distribution of articles' hub and authority scores. RESULTS: For n-3 PUFA, meta-analyses of 14 RCTs and 10 observational studies both suggested that higher intake was associated with lower cardiovascular mortality. For vitamin E, the meta-analysis of 14 RCTs excluded a clinically significant effect, whereas 14 observational studies reported a significant inverse association. The respective citation networks consisted of 392 (n-3 PUFA) and 351 (vitamin E) articles. No differences between the characteristics of the two networks were identified. There was no evidence that the observational studies predated RCTs in the translational process in either example. CONCLUSION: In the two examples, citation network characteristics do not predict concordance in the results of observational studies and RCTs.
OBJECTIVE: There are several examples in nutrition of discordance between the results of observational studies and randomized controlled trials (RCTs). We hypothesized that this discordance is attributable to differences in the translational paths of nutrient-disease associations. Translational paths can be assessed using citation analysis. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: We compared the characteristics of citation networks using examples, where RCTs and observational studies agreed (long-chain n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids [n-3 PUFA]) or disagreed (vitamin E). We performed systematic reviews in each example, constructed citation networks, and compared them with respect to the number of articles and citation relationships between them, as well as the distribution of articles' hub and authority scores. RESULTS: For n-3 PUFA, meta-analyses of 14 RCTs and 10 observational studies both suggested that higher intake was associated with lower cardiovascular mortality. For vitamin E, the meta-analysis of 14 RCTs excluded a clinically significant effect, whereas 14 observational studies reported a significant inverse association. The respective citation networks consisted of 392 (n-3 PUFA) and 351 (vitamin E) articles. No differences between the characteristics of the two networks were identified. There was no evidence that the observational studies predated RCTs in the translational process in either example. CONCLUSION: In the two examples, citation network characteristics do not predict concordance in the results of observational studies and RCTs.
Authors: J M Leppälä; J Virtamo; R Fogelholm; J K Huttunen; D Albanes; P R Taylor; O P Heinonen Journal: Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol Date: 2000-01 Impact factor: 8.311
Authors: David J A Jenkins; Andrea R Josse; Joseph Beyene; Paul Dorian; Michael L Burr; Roxanne LaBelle; Cyril W C Kendall; Stephen C Cunnane Journal: CMAJ Date: 2008-01-15 Impact factor: 8.262
Authors: M Dietrich; P F Jacques; M J Pencina; K Lanier; M J Keyes; G Kaur; P A Wolf; R B D'Agostino; R S Vasan Journal: Atherosclerosis Date: 2008-12-24 Impact factor: 5.162
Authors: Mei Chung; Naisi Zhao; Deena Wang; Marissa Shams-White; Micaela Karlsen; Aedín Cassidy; Mario Ferruzzi; Paul F Jacques; Elizabeth J Johnson; Taylor C Wallace Journal: Adv Nutr Date: 2020-07-01 Impact factor: 8.701
Authors: Keisuke Ejima; Peng Li; Daniel L Smith; Tim R Nagy; Inga Kadish; Thomas van Groen; John A Dawson; Yongbin Yang; Amit Patki; David B Allison Journal: Eur J Clin Invest Date: 2016-10-28 Impact factor: 4.686
Authors: Asmaa S Abdelhamid; Tracey J Brown; Julii S Brainard; Priti Biswas; Gabrielle C Thorpe; Helen J Moore; Katherine Ho Deane; Fai K AlAbdulghafoor; Carolyn D Summerbell; Helen V Worthington; Fujian Song; Lee Hooper Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2018-11-30
Authors: Asmaa S Abdelhamid; Tracey J Brown; Julii S Brainard; Priti Biswas; Gabrielle C Thorpe; Helen J Moore; Katherine Ho Deane; Fai K AlAbdulghafoor; Carolyn D Summerbell; Helen V Worthington; Fujian Song; Lee Hooper Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2018-07-18
Authors: Anne Austin; Ana Langer; Rehana A Salam; Zohra S Lassi; Jai K Das; Zulfiqar A Bhutta Journal: Reprod Health Date: 2014-09-04 Impact factor: 3.223