Brett S Jarosz1, Rick A Ames. 1. Private Practice of Chiropractic, Gisborne, Victoria, Australia; Sessional Lecturer, RMIT University, Discipline of Chiropractic, Bundoora, Victoria, Australia.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this case report is to describe and discuss the clinical diagnosis of a medial meniscus tear in an older patient using a multimodal management approach provided by a chiropractor. CLINICAL FEATURES: A 60-year-old woman reported to a chiropractic clinic with left knee pain and swelling. The history and physical examination findings suggested a medial meniscus tear, which was confirmed with magnetic resonance imaging. INTERVENTION AND OUTCOME: Treatment consisted of therapeutic ultrasound; rest, ice, compression, and elevation protocol; soft tissue therapy using effleurage and lymphatic drainage; chiropractic mechanically assisted adjusting techniques to the left knee using a handheld mechanical thrusting instrument; sports taping applied to assist facilitation of the vastus medialis obliquus; and a specific rehabilitation program aimed at strengthening this musculature. The patient's pain was assessed using a quadruple numeric pain scale. Function of the left knee was examined using McMurray, Apley, and a variation of Helfet orthopedic tests, as well as joint line tenderness. Monitoring was done at the initial consultation and at the sixth and 12th treatments. The patient reported being able to walk, swim, and ride a bicycle asymptomatically. Her pain score at the concluding visit was 16.7%, indicating low-intensity pain. CONCLUSION: This case indicated that conservative management of a meniscus tear through a chiropractic multimodal treatment approach provided an alternative or adjunctive therapy to routine orthopedic surgery for this patient.
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this case report is to describe and discuss the clinical diagnosis of a medial meniscus tear in an older patient using a multimodal management approach provided by a chiropractor. CLINICAL FEATURES: A 60-year-old woman reported to a chiropractic clinic with left knee pain and swelling. The history and physical examination findings suggested a medial meniscus tear, which was confirmed with magnetic resonance imaging. INTERVENTION AND OUTCOME: Treatment consisted of therapeutic ultrasound; rest, ice, compression, and elevation protocol; soft tissue therapy using effleurage and lymphatic drainage; chiropractic mechanically assisted adjusting techniques to the left knee using a handheld mechanical thrusting instrument; sports taping applied to assist facilitation of the vastus medialis obliquus; and a specific rehabilitation program aimed at strengthening this musculature. The patient's pain was assessed using a quadruple numeric pain scale. Function of the left knee was examined using McMurray, Apley, and a variation of Helfet orthopedic tests, as well as joint line tenderness. Monitoring was done at the initial consultation and at the sixth and 12th treatments. The patient reported being able to walk, swim, and ride a bicycle asymptomatically. Her pain score at the concluding visit was 16.7%, indicating low-intensity pain. CONCLUSION: This case indicated that conservative management of a meniscus tear through a chiropractic multimodal treatment approach provided an alternative or adjunctive therapy to routine orthopedic surgery for this patient.
Authors: Pieter Van Dyck; Jan Gielen; Jan D'Anvers; Filip Vanhoenacker; Lieven Dossche; Jozef Van Gestel; Paul M Parizel Journal: Arch Orthop Trauma Surg Date: 2007-04-14 Impact factor: 3.067
Authors: James W Brantingham; Gary Globe; Henry Pollard; Marian Hicks; Charmaine Korporaal; Wayne Hoskins Journal: J Manipulative Physiol Ther Date: 2009-01 Impact factor: 1.437
Authors: Harry Pa Wagemakers; Edith M Heintjes; Simone S Boks; Marjolein Y Berger; Jan An Verhaar; Bart W Koes; Sita Ma Bierma-Zeinstra Journal: Clin J Sport Med Date: 2008-01 Impact factor: 3.638