BACKGROUND: Although recurrent hamstring injury is a frequent problem with a significant impact on athletes, data on factors determining the risk for a recurrent hamstring injury are scarce. OBJECTIVE: To systematically review the literature and provide an overview of risk factors for re-injury of acute hamstring muscle injuries. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective studies on risk factors for re-injury following acute hamstring injuries were systematically reviewed. Medical databases and reference lists of the included articles were searched. Two reviewers independently selected potential studies and assessed methodological quality; one reviewer extracted the data. A best-evidence synthesis of all studied risk factors was performed. RESULTS: Of the 131 articles identified, five prospective follow-up studies fulfilled our inclusion criteria. These studies reported a recurrence incidence of 13.9-63.3% in the same playing season up to 2 years after initial injury. Limited evidence for three risk factors and one protective factor for recurrent hamstring injury was found; patients with a recurrent hamstring injury had an initial injury with a larger volume size as measured on MRI (47.03 vs 12.42 cm(3)), more often had a Grade 1 initial trauma (Grade 0: 0-30.4%; Grade 1: 60.9-100%; Grade 2: 8.7%) and more often had a previous ipsilateral anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (66.6% vs 17.1%) independent of graft selection. Athletes in a rehabilitation programme with agility/stabilisation exercises rather than strength/stretching exercises had a lower risk for re-injury (7.7% vs 70%). No significant relationship with re-injury was found for 11 related determinants. There was conflicting evidence that a larger cross-sectional area is a risk factor for recurrent hamstring injury. CONCLUSIONS: There is limited evidence that athletes with a larger volume size of initial trauma, a Grade 1 hamstring injury and a previous ipsilateral ACL reconstruction are at increased risk for recurrent hamstring injury. Athletes seem to be at lower risk for re-injury when following agility/stabilisation exercises.
BACKGROUND: Although recurrent hamstring injury is a frequent problem with a significant impact on athletes, data on factors determining the risk for a recurrent hamstring injury are scarce. OBJECTIVE: To systematically review the literature and provide an overview of risk factors for re-injury of acute hamstring muscle injuries. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective studies on risk factors for re-injury following acute hamstring injuries were systematically reviewed. Medical databases and reference lists of the included articles were searched. Two reviewers independently selected potential studies and assessed methodological quality; one reviewer extracted the data. A best-evidence synthesis of all studied risk factors was performed. RESULTS: Of the 131 articles identified, five prospective follow-up studies fulfilled our inclusion criteria. These studies reported a recurrence incidence of 13.9-63.3% in the same playing season up to 2 years after initial injury. Limited evidence for three risk factors and one protective factor for recurrent hamstring injury was found; patients with a recurrent hamstring injury had an initial injury with a larger volume size as measured on MRI (47.03 vs 12.42 cm(3)), more often had a Grade 1 initial trauma (Grade 0: 0-30.4%; Grade 1: 60.9-100%; Grade 2: 8.7%) and more often had a previous ipsilateral anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (66.6% vs 17.1%) independent of graft selection. Athletes in a rehabilitation programme with agility/stabilisation exercises rather than strength/stretching exercises had a lower risk for re-injury (7.7% vs 70%). No significant relationship with re-injury was found for 11 related determinants. There was conflicting evidence that a larger cross-sectional area is a risk factor for recurrent hamstring injury. CONCLUSIONS: There is limited evidence that athletes with a larger volume size of initial trauma, a Grade 1 hamstring injury and a previous ipsilateral ACL reconstruction are at increased risk for recurrent hamstring injury. Athletes seem to be at lower risk for re-injury when following agility/stabilisation exercises.
Authors: Lasse Lempainen; Ingo J Banke; Kristian Johansson; Peter U Brucker; Janne Sarimo; Sakari Orava; Andreas B Imhoff Journal: Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc Date: 2014-02-21 Impact factor: 4.342
Authors: Joel D Presland; Ryan G Timmins; Nirav Maniar; Paul J Tofari; Dawson J Kidgell; Anthony J Shield; Jessica Dickson; David A Opar Journal: Sports Med Date: 2021-07-26 Impact factor: 11.136
Authors: Gustaaf Reurink; Gert Jan Goudswaard; Maarten H Moen; Adam Weir; Jan A N Verhaar; Johannes L Tol Journal: Sports Med Date: 2014-07 Impact factor: 11.136
Authors: Jo Verschueren; Bruno Tassignon; Kevin De Pauw; Matthias Proost; Amber Teugels; Jeroen Van Cutsem; Bart Roelands; Evert Verhagen; Romain Meeusen Journal: Sports Med Date: 2020-04 Impact factor: 11.136
Authors: Robin Vermeulen; Rod Whiteley; Anne D van der Made; Nicol van Dyk; Emad Almusa; Celeste Geertsema; Stephen Targett; Abdulaziz Farooq; Roald Bahr; Johannes L Tol; Arnlaug Wangensteen Journal: Br J Sports Med Date: 2022-03-25 Impact factor: 18.473