PURPOSE: Physical activity benefits cancer survivors, but the comparative effectiveness of a team-based delivery approach remains unexplored. The hypothesis tested was that a team-based physical activity intervention delivery approach has added physical and psychological benefits compared to a group-based approach. A team-based sport accessible to survivors is dragon boating, which requires no previous experience and allows for diverse skill levels. METHODS: In a non-randomized trial, cancer survivors chose between two similarly structured 8-week programs, a dragon boat paddling team (n = 68) or group-based walking program (n = 52). Three separate intervention rounds were carried out in 2007-2008. Pre-post testing measured physical and psychosocial outcomes. RESULTS: Compared to walkers, paddlers had significantly greater (all p < 0.01) team cohesion, program adherence/attendance, and increased upper-body strength. For quality-of-life outcomes, both interventions were associated with pre-post improvements, but with no clear-cut pattern of between-intervention differences. CONCLUSIONS: These hypothesis-generating findings suggest that a short-term, team-based physical activity program (dragon boat paddling) was associated with increased cohesion and adherence/attendance. Improvements in physical fitness and psychosocial benefits were comparable to a traditional, group-based walking program. Compared to a group-based intervention delivery format, the team-based intervention delivery format holds promise for promoting physical activity program adherence/attendance in cancer survivors.
PURPOSE: Physical activity benefits cancer survivors, but the comparative effectiveness of a team-based delivery approach remains unexplored. The hypothesis tested was that a team-based physical activity intervention delivery approach has added physical and psychological benefits compared to a group-based approach. A team-based sport accessible to survivors is dragon boating, which requires no previous experience and allows for diverse skill levels. METHODS: In a non-randomized trial, cancer survivors chose between two similarly structured 8-week programs, a dragon boat paddling team (n = 68) or group-based walking program (n = 52). Three separate intervention rounds were carried out in 2007-2008. Pre-post testing measured physical and psychosocial outcomes. RESULTS: Compared to walkers, paddlers had significantly greater (all p < 0.01) team cohesion, program adherence/attendance, and increased upper-body strength. For quality-of-life outcomes, both interventions were associated with pre-post improvements, but with no clear-cut pattern of between-intervention differences. CONCLUSIONS: These hypothesis-generating findings suggest that a short-term, team-based physical activity program (dragon boat paddling) was associated with increased cohesion and adherence/attendance. Improvements in physical fitness and psychosocial benefits were comparable to a traditional, group-based walking program. Compared to a group-based intervention delivery format, the team-based intervention delivery format holds promise for promoting physical activity program adherence/attendance in cancer survivors.
Authors: Darren E R Warburton; A William Sheel; Alastair N H Hodges; Ian B Stewart; Eric M Yoshida; Robert D Levy; Donald C McKenzie Journal: Am J Cardiol Date: 2004-04-01 Impact factor: 2.778
Authors: M H Antoni; J M Lehman; K M Kilbourn; A E Boyers; J L Culver; S M Alferi; S E Yount; B A McGregor; P L Arena; S D Harris; A A Price; C S Carver Journal: Health Psychol Date: 2001-01 Impact factor: 4.267
Authors: V Mock; K H Dow; C J Meares; P M Grimm; J A Dienemann; M E Haisfield-Wolfe; W Quitasol; S Mitchell; A Chakravarthy; I Gage Journal: Oncol Nurs Forum Date: 1997-07 Impact factor: 2.172
Authors: Kathleen Griffith; Jennifer Wenzel; JingJing Shang; Carol Thompson; Kerry Stewart; Victoria Mock Journal: Cancer Date: 2009-10-15 Impact factor: 6.860
Authors: Laura Q Rogers; Stephen J Markwell; Steven Verhulst; Edward McAuley; Kerry S Courneya Journal: Psychooncology Date: 2009-04 Impact factor: 3.894
Authors: Hao Luo; Daniel A Galvão; Robert U Newton; Ciaran M Fairman; Dennis R Taaffe Journal: Integr Cancer Ther Date: 2019 Jan-Dec Impact factor: 3.279