OBJECTIVE: To describe the frequency, characteristics, and outcomes of medicolegal disputes over informed consent. DESIGN AND SETTING: Retrospective review and analysis of negligence claims against doctors insured by Avant Mutual Group Limited and complaints lodged with the Office of the Health Services Commissioner of Victoria that alleged failures in the informed consent process and were adjudicated between 1 January 2002 and 31 December 2008. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Case frequency (by medical specialty), type of allegation, type of treatment. RESULTS: A total of 481 cases alleged deficiencies in the informed consent process (218 of 1898 conciliated complaints [11.5%]; 263 of 7846 negligence claims [3.4%]). 57% of these cases were against surgeons. Plastic surgeons experienced dispute rates that were more than twice those of any other specialty or subspecialty group. 92% of cases (442/481) involved surgical procedures and 16% (77/481) involved cosmetic procedures. The primary allegation in 71% of cases was that the clinician failed to mention or properly explain risks of complications. Five treatment types - procedures on reproductive organs (12% of cases), procedures on facial features excluding eyes (12%), prescription medications (8%), eye surgery (7%) and breast surgery (7%) - accounted for 46% of all cases. CONCLUSIONS: The typical dispute over informed consent involves an operation, often cosmetic, and allegations that a particular complication was not properly disclosed. With Australian courts now looking to patient preferences in setting legal standards of care for risk disclosure, medicolegal disputes provide valuable insights for targeting both quality improvement efforts and risk management activities.
OBJECTIVE: To describe the frequency, characteristics, and outcomes of medicolegal disputes over informed consent. DESIGN AND SETTING: Retrospective review and analysis of negligence claims against doctors insured by Avant Mutual Group Limited and complaints lodged with the Office of the Health Services Commissioner of Victoria that alleged failures in the informed consent process and were adjudicated between 1 January 2002 and 31 December 2008. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Case frequency (by medical specialty), type of allegation, type of treatment. RESULTS: A total of 481 cases alleged deficiencies in the informed consent process (218 of 1898 conciliated complaints [11.5%]; 263 of 7846 negligence claims [3.4%]). 57% of these cases were against surgeons. Plastic surgeons experienced dispute rates that were more than twice those of any other specialty or subspecialty group. 92% of cases (442/481) involved surgical procedures and 16% (77/481) involved cosmetic procedures. The primary allegation in 71% of cases was that the clinician failed to mention or properly explain risks of complications. Five treatment types - procedures on reproductive organs (12% of cases), procedures on facial features excluding eyes (12%), prescription medications (8%), eye surgery (7%) and breast surgery (7%) - accounted for 46% of all cases. CONCLUSIONS: The typical dispute over informed consent involves an operation, often cosmetic, and allegations that a particular complication was not properly disclosed. With Australian courts now looking to patient preferences in setting legal standards of care for risk disclosure, medicolegal disputes provide valuable insights for targeting both quality improvement efforts and risk management activities.
Authors: Cameron Stewart; Tina Cockburn; Bill Madden; Sascha Callaghan; Christopher James Ryan Journal: J Bioeth Inq Date: 2012-07-24 Impact factor: 1.352
Authors: Yueyue Miao; Victoria L Venning; Kylie-Ann Mallitt; Julia E J Rhodes; Noah J Isserman; Gilberto Moreno; Simon Lee; William Ryman; Gayle Fischer; Rebecca B Saunderson Journal: JAAD Int Date: 2020-05-11
Authors: Meena Putturaj; Sara Van Belle; Nora Engel; Bart Criel; Anja Krumeich; Prakash B Nagendrappa; Prashanth N Srinivas Journal: Health Policy Plan Date: 2021-10-12 Impact factor: 3.344
Authors: Marie M Bismark; Andrew J Gogos; Richard B Clark; Russell L Gruen; Atul A Gawande; David M Studdert Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2012-08-07 Impact factor: 11.069
Authors: Rochelle Smits; Jamie Bryant; Rob Sanson-Fisher; Flora Tzelepis; Frans Henskens; Christine Paul; William Stevenson Journal: J Med Internet Res Date: 2014-03-14 Impact factor: 5.428