Oxidative stress in cardiovascular inflammation: its involvement in autoimmune responses.

Recently, it has become clear that atherosclerosis is a chronic inflammatory disease in which inflammation and immune responses play a key role. Accelerated atherosclerosis has been reported in patients with autoimmune diseases, suggesting an involvement of autoimmune mechanisms in atherogenesis. Different self-antigens or modified self-molecules have been identified as target of humoral and cellular immune responses in patients with atherosclerotic disease. Oxidative stress, increasingly reported in these patients, is the major event causing structural modification of proteins with consequent appearance of neoepitopes. Self-molecules modified by oxidative events can become targets of autoimmune reactions, thus sustaining the inflammatory mechanisms involved in endothelial dysfunction and plaque development. In this paper, we will summarize the best characterized autoantigens in atherosclerosis and their possible role in cardiovascular inflammation.

1. Introduction

Atherosclerosis was initially believed as a process caused by the passive accumulation of lipids in the vessel wall. Recently, however, it has become clear that atherosclerosis is a complex condition and that multiple pathogenic factors contribute to trigger and sustain vessel wall damage [1]. Experimental studies have clearly demonstrated that atherosclerosis can be considered a chronic inflammatory disease of the arterial wall and that inflammation plays a key role in all stages of the pathogenic process, including formation, progression, and rupture of atherosclerotic plaque [2, 3]. In early lesions, chemokines and adhesion molecules expressed by endothelial cells recruit inflammatory cells, in particular monocytes and T cells, to the arterial intima [4]. If the acute inflammatory response does not resolve and macrophages and T cells continue to accumulate in the intima, a fibrotic repair process activates, leading to the formation of an atherosclerotic lesion [5]. This process is driven by the inflammatory cells that secrete cytokines and growth factors and stimulate smooth muscle cells to migrate to the intima, where they proliferate and produce extracellular matrix proteins [4]. In the advanced lesion, matrix metalloproteinases secreted from activated macrophages degrade the connective tissue in the fibrous cap causing plaque rupture.

Accelerated atherosclerosis has been reported in patients with various autoimmune diseases, suggesting an involvement of autoimmune mechanisms in atherogenesis [6-9]. This phenomenon is attributed to the presence of traditional risk factors for atherosclerosis, but could be also the result of autoimmune and inflammatory mechanisms that are aggravated in these diseases [6].

The first evidence for the involvement of autoimmune responses in atherosclerosis was provided by Jonasson et al. [10] who demonstrated the expression of MHC class II molecules and the presence of activated T cells in human atherosclerotic plaques. Analysis of plaque-infiltrating T cells revealed that these cells primarily showed the proinflammatory Th1 phenotype [11]. Subsequent studies on different animal models demonstrated that activation of Th1 responses contributes to a more aggressive progression of atherosclerosis [4]. Different studies have strongly suggested that atherosclerosis to some extent can be viewed as an autoimmune disease in which the adaptive immune system is targeted against self-antigens modified by biochemical factors such as oxidative stress and hypercholesterolemia [12]. In this respect, atherosclerosis shares some similarities with other diseases characterized by an autoimmune etiology, such as type I diabetes and rheumatoid arthritis. In this contest, identifying the antigens responsible for the activation of immune responses that promote and sustain inflammation in atherosclerosis may be relevant.

2. Mechanisms of Autoimmunity Generation

Although infectious agents have been associated with the activation of immune mechanisms, evidence exist that the main antigenic targets in atherosclerosis are modified endogenous structures [12]. Atherosclerotic plaques express autoantigens that are targeted by both IgM and IgG. It is likely that these autoimmune responses initially have a beneficial effect facilitating the removal of potentially harmful antigens [13]. However, studies performed on hypercholesterolaemic mice deficient in different components of innate and adaptive immunity uniformly indicate that the net effect of immune activation is proatherogenic [13, 14] and that atherosclerosis, at least to some extent, should be regarded as an autoimmune disease.

In general, three mechanisms have been proposed to explain the autoimmune phenomena. (i) The molecular mimicry theory proposes that the autoimmune response is triggered by the initial activation of lymphocytes recognizing epitopes derived from microorganisms that share sequence homology with self-molecules. Therefore, autoimmunity resulting from epitope mimicry may be a consequence of the antipathogen immune response that can lead to disease in predisposed individuals [15]. (ii) Impairments in apoptosis execution and clearance can potentially render apoptotic cells as a source of autoantigens normally sequestered in the intracellular environment. Structural changes occurring during cell death may influence the immunogenicity of clustered self-antigens at the surface of apoptotic bodies [16]. (iii) Autoimmune responses may be directed against self-structures altered by high-affinity ligand binding or by chemical damage due to environmental events, such as oxidative stress [17].

3. Oxidative Stress in Atherosclerosis

Excessive oxidative stress and chronic inflammation are both major characteristics of atherosclerosis [18, 19]. However, the mechanisms by which oxidative stress mediates cardiovascular diseases are not clear [20]. Oxidative stress is the major event causing protein structural modification and appearance of neo-/cryptic epitopes [21, 22]. Several systems that generate reactive oxygen species (ROS) catalyze a variety of oxidative damage to nucleic acids, lipids, and proteins [23]. In physiological conditions oxidative stress is well compensated. When there is an overproduction of ROS or a deficiency of antioxidant enzyme activity, a biological damage with vascular lesion formation and functional defects may occur [24].

Oxidative stress and inflammation may determine the modification of self-structures also favouring the formation of advanced glycation end products (AGEs). Chronic oxidative stress causes an accumulation of AGEs [25]. The generation of AGEs and augmentation of proinflammatory mechanisms in the vessel provide a potent feedback loop for sustained oxidant stress, ongoing generation of AGEs, and vascular perturbation.

Epidemiological studies have demonstrated an inverse association between risk of stroke and intake of several antioxidant-rich food items [26, 27]. Intake of high total antioxidant capacity (the cumulative capacity of food components to scavenge free radicals) has been related to reduced inflammation and increased circulating antioxidants in both cross-sectional and randomized intervention studies [28, 29]. Nevertheless, clinical trials with anti-oxidants in humans have shown conflicting results in protecting against detrimental cardiovascular outcomes [20]. In particular, most antioxidant vitamin trials have failed to reduce cardiovascular morbidity and mortality [30]. In contrast, other investigators sustain that the beneficial effects of lipid-lowering and antihypertensive treatments are in part due to their antioxidant properties [31, 32]. Furthermore, recent findings suggest that antioxidants may play a role in reducing the risk of cerebral infarction [33], thus confirming the pathogenetic role of oxidative stress in inflammation and cardiovascular pathology. Collectively, these studies suggest that more rigorous clinical trial designs are needed to evaluate the usefulness of an antioxidant-based therapeutic approach to cardiovascular diseases [34].

4. Autoantigens Implicated in Cardiovascular Diseases

4.1. Oxidized Low-Density Lipoproteins

Oxidized low-density lipoproteins (LDLs) is the best characterized autoantigen in atherosclerosis. LDL modifications caused by oxidation and enzymatic attacks result in the release of proinflammatory phospholipids and lipid peroxides, which rapidly activate an inflammatory response in surrounding cells [35, 36]. The oxidation process is also associated with major structural modifications of LDL determining the formation of new antigenic epitopes which can be presented by dendritic cells and give rise to clonal expansion of oxidized LDL-specific T cells [12]. About 10% of all T cells present in human atherosclerotic plaques specifically recognize oxidized LDL [17], and these cells are also present in the circulation [37]. Furthermore, autoantibodies specific for oxidized LDL have been detected in humans and associated with cardiovascular disease, but their role is controversial [38, 39]. Pilot studies in animal models have provided promising results for the development of vaccines based on oxidized LDL antigens [12].

4.2. Heat Shock Proteins

A second category of autoantigens that have been implicated in atherosclerosis are the stress-induced heat shock proteins (HSPs) [40]. HSPs act as molecular chaperons facilitating refolding of denatured proteins in stressed cells. Interestingly, some of them have also been implicated in loading of immunogenic peptides to major histocompatibility class (MHC) I and II molecules [41]. Besides being expressed in cells under physiological conditions, HSPs increase in response to many environmental stresses, including oxidative stress [42]. Under stress conditions, HSPs are expressed not only within cells, but also on the cell surface and can be released into the intercellular space. Intracellular HSPs have cytoprotective functions whereas extracellular located or membrane-bound HSPs mediate immunological functions [43]. In atherosclerotic lesions, human HSPs appear to stimulate an immune response leading to the development and progression of atherosclerosis [44, 45]. Antibody levels against HSP-60/65 are increased in subjects with established cardiovascular disease and predict further development of the disease [46]. These antibodies specifically react with cells in atherosclerotic plaques and mediate lysis of stressed endothelial cells and macrophages in vitro [47]. Recently, we demonstrated that human HSP90 is overexpressed in plaque and serum from patients with carotid atherosclerosis and induces humoral and cellular immune responses in these patients, implicating this self-protein as a possible target autoantigen in the pathogenesis of carotid atherosclerosis [48, 49]. In particular, we detected HSP90-specific T lymphocytes within the atherosclerotic plaque; these cells showed a predominant Th1, pro-inflammatory profile, suggesting a role for HSP90 in sustaining the inflammatory mechanisms responsible for the thrombogenicity of the atherosclerotic lesion [49]. Major questions for future research are the possible role of circulating anti-HSP90 antibodies and perhaps HSP90-specific peripheral blood T cells as diagnostic and prognostic markers of disease.

4.3. Beta2-Glycoprotein I

Beta2-glycoprotein I (β2-GPI) is a plasma protein involved in the haemostatic system that has been detected in carotid atherosclerotic lesions. Previous studies in animal models demonstrated that the transfer of lymphocytes obtained from β2-GPI-immunized mice was associated with the presence of larger fatty streaks within the recipients compared with animals that received lymphocytes from control mice, suggesting that T cells specific for β2-GPI are capable to increase atherosclerosis and that β2-GPI is a target autoantigen in this disease [6].

β2-GPI is also the most common target for antiphospholipid antibodies (aPLs). These autoantibodies are associated with thrombotic events and with the incidence of accelerated atherosclerosis in patients with antiphospholipid antibody syndrome and systemic lupus erythematosus [50-52]. In a previous study, we observed that β2-GPI, as several plasma proteins involved in the haemostatic system, undergoes major structural and functional changes upon exposure to oxidative stress and that such modification renders this self-molecule able to activate immature monocyte-derived dendritic cells (DCs) [21]. We demonstrated that DCs stimulated with the oxidized form of human β2-GPI presented a mature phenotype, produced cytokines that support T-cell activation, and were able to activate a Th1-type response by allogenic naïve T cells, characterized by interferon (IFN)-γ production. These findings are in accordance with our recent study demonstrating that β2-GPI is a target antigen of Th1 cellular immune response in patients with carotid atherosclerosis [53]. In this study, we used the native form of the plasma protein, but our previous evidence that β2-GPI spontaneously undergoes oxidative modification in in vitro culture conditions [21] led us to hypothesize that T-cell reactivity detected in these patients is directed to the oxidized form of the protein.

More recently, we have demonstrated that a glycated form of β2-GPI is able to activate monocyte-derived immature DCs through RAGE engagement and to trigger a proinflammatory signaling pathway mediated by the activation of mitogen-activated protein kinases and nuclear factor-κB [54].

Our findings underline the role of glycation/glycoxidation in rendering this self-protein able to activate the immune system and suggest that chronic activation of autoimmune reactions against β2-GPI modified by oxidative events may contribute to local and systemic inflammation, thus sustaining endothelial dysfunction and promoting thrombotic events in patients with cardiovascular diseases.

4.4. Oxidized Haemoglobin

Microvascular haemorrhage in atherosclerotic plaques is a common event in advanced lesions [55]. Intraplaque haemorrhage is an event characterizing high-risk “vulnerable” plaques, which are prone to rupture and associated with acute thrombotic events. Intraplaque haemorrhage causes the deposition of blood products into the extravascular space, particularly red blood cells (RBCs) and haemoglobin (Hb). In physiological conditions, Hb released within the vascular compartment from destroyed RBCs dimerizes and is rapidly bound by the serum protein haptoglobin. The haptoglobin-Hb complex is recognized by the scavenger receptor CD163 on the surface of mononuclear phagocytes, that promotes endocytosis and degradation of the complex [56]. Complicated plaques are characterized by repetitive haemorrhage events and hemolysis, accompanied with the release of large amounts of Hb into the atherosclerotic lesions. In these conditions, the capacity of Hb scavenging mechanisms is saturated. The pro-inflammatory and pro-oxidant microenvironment within the plaque may predispose free Hb to oxidative modifications. Free Hb or its oxidized forms may represent dangerous autoantigens, unwanted target of immune responses initially directed to the removal of escaped or modified proteins. Following this hypothesis, we have examined the presence of T cells specific for oxidized Hb in the peripheral blood of patients with advanced carotid atherosclerosis [57]. We used an oxidized Hb preparation predominantly containing hemichromes. Hemichromes represent Hb oxidation products characterized by a cross-linking between globin and heme that is responsible for molecule distortion and structural changes. We observed that the mean frequency of IFN-γ-secreting T lymphocytes specific for oxidized Hb was significantly higher in patients with carotid atherosclerosis than in healthy subjects, suggesting that the oxidized forms of Hb display immunodominant T-cell epitopes that are able to stimulate adaptive immunity. Furthermore, our oxidized Hb preparation enhanced phenotypic maturation of LPS-stimulated DCs, as demonstrated by the appearance of the DC maturation marker CD83 and by the upregulation of the costimulatory molecules CD80, CD40, HLA-DR, and CD86, and significantly increased the production of the pro-inflammatory cytokines interleukin (IL)-12p70 and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α by DCs [57]. In a more recent study, we extended our results and demonstrated the presence of T lymphocytes specific for oxidized Hb within human atherosclerotic plaques. These cells produced high levels of the pro-inflammatory Th1 cytokines IFN-γ and TNF-α [58].

Previous studies demonstrated that Hb exerts a pro-inflammatory and oxidative action on endothelial cells [59, 60]. In particular, oxidized Hb upregulates the transcription rate of several pro-inflammatory genes, that is, E-selectin, ICAM-1, and VCAM-1, on vascular endothelial cells through the activation of the NF-κB family of transcription factors [61]. Our data implicate oxidized Hb as a possible antigenic target of cell-mediated immune responses contributing to tissue damage in the pathogenesis of carotid atherosclerosis. We can hypothesize that intraplaque haemorrhage in complicated lesions determines the release of large amounts of free Hb. In these conditions, haptoglobin and CD163, getting overwhelmed, are unable to clear efficiently the protein which accumulates in the extracellular compartment [55, 62]. The pro-oxidant microenvironment within the atherosclerotic plaque may promote oxidative modifications of Hb determining the generation of novel antigenic epitopes on this self-molecule. These epitopes can activate specific T lymphocytes with a predominant Th1 profile that contribute to inflammation. In physiological conditions, the oxidized forms of Hb do not reach consistent levels in vivo because oxidative stress is well compensated. Of note, we observed the presence of T-cells specific for oxidized Hb also in the peripheral blood from healthy subjects, suggesting that T cell clones specific for this rare molecule are not deleted within the thymus as, in basal conditions, they do not encounter the target antigen necessary for their activation.

Overall, these results indicate that Hb, in particular conditions, can sustain endothelial dysfunction interacting with endothelial cells and/or with immune cells, thus promoting the pathogenetic mechanisms involved in the progression of cardiovascular diseases.

5. Conclusions

Excessive oxidative stress and low-grade chronic inflammation are major pathophysiological factors contributing to the development of cardiovascular diseases. The strong oxidative and inflammatory conditions occurring in patients with atherosclerosis trigger the generation of a series of oxidation byproducts that may contribute to the pathogenesis of the disease. In addition to pro-inflammatory properties, self molecules modified by oxidative events can become targets of autoimmune reactions, thus sustaining the inflammatory mechanisms involved in endothelial dysfunction and plaque development (Figure 1). More studies aimed to clarify these aspect might be useful for designing novel preventive strategies in cardiovascular diseases. Modulation of the immune system could represent a useful approach to prevent and/or treat these diseases. A vaccination approach might be a useful, effective tool in the modern arsenal of cardiovascular therapy and could possibly be used on a large scale at a low cost. Several modalities of vaccines have been tested against oxidized LDL, β2-GPI, HSPs, cholesterol, and other molecules, with promising results. Nevertheless, a deeper understanding of the role of immunization in atherosclerosis will be essential to the use of vaccines in clinical medicine [63, 64].

Figure 1

Schematic representation of the relationship between oxidative stress and inflammation in cardiovascular diseases. Patients with atherosclerosis are characterized by strong oxidative stress conditions. Prooxidant compounds that form may interact with molecular and cellular components thus determining expression of cryptic antigens, such as HSPs, and/or structural modifications of self-molecules and generation of neoepitopes, such as oxidized LDL. These cryptic or neoantigens may trigger autoimmune reactions, thus sustaining the inflammatory mechanisms involved in endothelial dysfunction and plaque progression. Of note, molecular and cellular mediators of inflammatory mechanisms sustain oxidative stress, thus creating a pathogenic system that amplifies itself. Ox-LDL: oxidized low-density lipoproteins; HSPs: heat shock proteins; beta2-GPI: beta2-glycoprotein I; Hb: haemoglobin.