BACKGROUND: Recruitment method can impact the sample composition of a clinical trial and, thus, the generalizability of the results, but the importance of recruitment method in substance use disorder trials has received little attention. The present paper sought to address this research gap by evaluating the association between recruitment method and sample characteristics and treatment outcomes in a substance use disorder trial. METHODS: In a multi-site trial evaluating Seeking Safety (SS), relative to Women's Health Education (WHE), for women with co-occurring PTSD (either sub-threshold or full PTSD) and substance use disorders, one site assessed the method by which each participant was recruited. Data from this site (n=106), which recruited participants from newspaper advertising and clinic intakes, were analyzed. RESULTS: Participants recruited through advertising, relative to those from the clinic, had significantly higher levels of baseline drug use and higher rates of meeting DSM-IV-TR criteria for full PTSD. Results suggest that the effectiveness of SS in decreasing PTSD symptoms was greater for participants recruited through advertising relative to those recruited from the clinic. Conversely, the results revealed a significant treatment effect in the clinic-recruited participants, not seen in the advertising-recruited participants, with SS, relative to WHE, participants being more likely to report past week drug use during the follow-up phase. CONCLUSION: Recruitment method may impact sample composition and treatment effects. Replication of this finding would have important implications for substance use disorder efficacy trials which often utilize advertising to recruit participants.
BACKGROUND: Recruitment method can impact the sample composition of a clinical trial and, thus, the generalizability of the results, but the importance of recruitment method in substance use disorder trials has received little attention. The present paper sought to address this research gap by evaluating the association between recruitment method and sample characteristics and treatment outcomes in a substance use disorder trial. METHODS: In a multi-site trial evaluating Seeking Safety (SS), relative to Women's Health Education (WHE), for women with co-occurring PTSD (either sub-threshold or full PTSD) and substance use disorders, one site assessed the method by which each participant was recruited. Data from this site (n=106), which recruited participants from newspaper advertising and clinic intakes, were analyzed. RESULTS:Participants recruited through advertising, relative to those from the clinic, had significantly higher levels of baseline drug use and higher rates of meeting DSM-IV-TR criteria for full PTSD. Results suggest that the effectiveness of SS in decreasing PTSD symptoms was greater for participants recruited through advertising relative to those recruited from the clinic. Conversely, the results revealed a significant treatment effect in the clinic-recruited participants, not seen in the advertising-recruited participants, with SS, relative to WHE, participants being more likely to report past week drug use during the follow-up phase. CONCLUSION: Recruitment method may impact sample composition and treatment effects. Replication of this finding would have important implications for substance use disorder efficacy trials which often utilize advertising to recruit participants.
Authors: M Schlernitzauer; A J Bierhals; M D Geary; H G Prigerson; J A Stack; M D Miller; R E Pasternak; C F Reynolds Journal: Am J Geriatr Psychiatry Date: 1998 Impact factor: 4.105
Authors: Fred Andersen; Torgeir A Engstad; Bjørn Straume; Matti Viitanen; Dag S Halvorsen; Samuel Hykkerud; Kjell Sjøbrend Journal: BMC Med Res Methodol Date: 2010-04-29 Impact factor: 4.615
Authors: Denise A Hien; Elizabeth A Wells; Huiping Jiang; Lourdes Suarez-Morales; Aimee N C Campbell; Lisa R Cohen; Gloria M Miele; Therese Killeen; Gregory S Brigham; Yulei Zhang; Cheri Hansen; Candace Hodgkins; Mary Hatch-Maillette; Chanda Brown; Agatha Kulaga; Allison Kristman-Valente; Melissa Chu; Robert Sage; James A Robinson; David Liu; Edward V Nunes Journal: J Consult Clin Psychol Date: 2009-08
Authors: J A Stack; C F Paradis; C F Reynolds; P R Houck; E Frank; B Anderson; A L Mayo; M D Miller; A H Rifai; J M Perel Journal: Psychiatry Res Date: 1995-01-31 Impact factor: 3.222
Authors: Kari Jo Harris; Jasjit S Ahluwalia; Delwyn Catley; Kolawole S Okuyemi; Matthew S Mayo; Ken Resnicow Journal: Nicotine Tob Res Date: 2003-08 Impact factor: 4.244
Authors: Tina Karwalajtys; Janusz Kaczorowski; Larry W Chambers; Cheryl Levitt; Lisa Dolovich; Bea McDonough; Christopher Patterson; James E Williams Journal: BMC Fam Pract Date: 2005-08-19 Impact factor: 2.497
Authors: Theresa M Winhusen; Eugene C Somoza; Daniel F Lewis; Frankie B Kropp; Viviana Elizabeth Horigian; Bryon Adinoff Journal: Drug Alcohol Depend Date: 2012-07-06 Impact factor: 4.492
Authors: Denise A Hien; Aimee N C Campbell; Lesia M Ruglass; Lissette Saavedra; Abigail G Mathews; Grace Kiriakos; Antonio Morgan-Lopez Journal: J Subst Abuse Treat Date: 2015-04-07
Authors: Theresa M Winhusen; Bryon Adinoff; Daniel F Lewis; Gregory S Brigham; John G Gardin; Susan C Sonne; Jeff Theobald; Udi Ghitza Journal: Drug Alcohol Depend Date: 2013-09-11 Impact factor: 4.492
Authors: Theresa M Winhusen; Gregory S Brigham; Frankie Kropp; Robert Lindblad; John G Gardin; Pat Penn; Candace Hodgkins; Thomas M Kelly; Antoine Douaihy; Michael McCann; Lee D Love; Eliot DeGravelles; Ken Bachrach; Susan C Sonne; Bob Hiott; Louise Haynes; Gaurav Sharma; Daniel F Lewis; Paul VanVeldhuisen; Jeff Theobald; Udi Ghitza Journal: J Clin Psychiatry Date: 2014-04 Impact factor: 4.384
Authors: Denise Hien; Frankie Kropp; Elizabeth A Wells; Aimee Campbell; Mary Hatch-Maillette; Candace Hodgkins; Therese Killeen; Teresa Lopez-Castro; Antonio Morgan-Lopez; Lesia M Ruglass; Lissette Saavedra; Edward V Nunes Journal: J Subst Abuse Treat Date: 2020-03